The Summer of
the Swans
by
Betsy Byars
 
I may be somewhat old-fashioned, but I just love The Summer of the Swans.  To me, it seems like a perfect book for younger teens.  .I have searched the net for other references to this wonderful novel, but for the most part have been disappointed.  I see papers by young critics who treat it as a thriller about a girl's search for her missing brother.  That's part of the story of course, but only a small part.  The real focus of the story is about an adolescent girl who learns to grow up.  In many ways, she's a seventies version of Anne of Green Gables and a perfect comparison for that novel.
 
Sara Godfrey is a girl with many problems: She's unhappy with her looks; she misunderstands her father's coldness for a lack of love; she is overly protective of her handicapped brother; she misjudges the motives of everyone around her.  The Summer of the Swans is about a summer in which an ugly duckling discovers she may really be a swan. Everything in the book is relevant; there are no wasted scenes. It's brilliantly written, with clear symbols, foreshadowing, and a serious, sensitive theme.
 
This is the plot worksheet I use to teach this book. (Page numbers refer to the 1991 edition of Introduction to Literature, published by Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc; and Harcourt Brace, Jovanovich, Inc.) 
 
 
 
Plot Worksheet:
Title: The Summer of the Swans
Author: Betsy Byars

I. Situation
     A. Place: a small town in West Virginia, surrounded by hills, with many coal mines. (see p. 660)
                        B. Time: the seventies, in the summer.  (p.651 tells us a leader in fashion is Jackie Kennedy
            Onassis.  Other references include Green Acres (660) and Laugh-in: beautiful downtown
            Burbank (659), and Gentle Ben)

     C. Characterization:

     SARA GODFREY, a 14 year old girl who wears orange sneakers and thinks of herself as
            awkward, with big feet. (651)

     BOYSIE, her dog, on the old side

     CHARLIE, her ten year old mentally handicapped brother, who looks just like her (p.653).  He
             hasn't spoken a word since he had two serious illnesses. (688)

      WANDA, her older sister (655) 19, who is beautiful (659)

      FRANK, Wanda's boyfriend (651)  He rides a motorbike (659)

      AUNT WILLIE, in her early forties, their guardian since their mother died six years ago.  Sarah
              doesn't like her very much (655) but she appears to be a real sport (655)

      SWANS  Sara thinks they live at the university and visit in a nearby pond. (664)

      MARY WEICEK, Sara's friend (660)

      MRS. WEICEK (662)

      SAM GODFREY (684, 686)  Sara's father.  Sam had to support his family when his own
                father died.  Later on, after his wife's death and Charlie's illness, he became cold and
                remote to Sara.

      GRETCHEN WYANT, a girl Sara's age whom Sara hosed for calling Charlie a "retard."683

      JOE MELBY, a boy Sara believes is a "crook" who stole Charlie's watch.  (682)

    (Students will soon see that we are seeing everything through Sara's eyes, and her
      interpretation of these people are distorted by her selfishness.  It seems that she is wrong
      about everybody, as she will learn in the story.)

II. CONFLICT:

         Sara must grow up:
         1.She must get a better self-image and overcome the awkwardness of adolescence. (652)
         2. She must learn to understand other people's feelings. (665)
 
 

III. EVENTS WHICH INTENSIFY THE CONFLICT:

    650. Wanda criticizes her for dressing up Boysie.

    651: Sara thinks she's ugly, big feet and all.

    651-2. Even Boysie doesn't love her. (Sara's scene with Boysie leads to an understanding of
            her attitude toward Charlie.  By dressing Boysie up, it shows she has no respect for
            Boysie's dignity.  The class should see that she treats Charlie in much the same way:
            he is a retarded child for her to protect and defend, not a person to her with human
            dignity and frailties.)

    652. Charlie is a burden to Sara, first with candy, then with a tent.

    656.  Sara gets mad at Wanda for discussing Charlie with the doctors, and uses the word
        retarded" for the first time. 

    658. Aunt Willy tells Sara she is not ugly and will become a swan.  Sara doesn't listen.

    660- Aunt Willy can't afford a dress Sara wants, so she will make one.  (This is the first hint
            That Sara is wrong about somebody.  Aunt Willy is kind.)

    662-Sara finds the beauty of the swans painful.

    666. Sara doesn't like Frank--or boys in general.

    668. Sara hears Charlie kicking the wall and remembers his illness.

    670. Charlie can't sleep because he has a button missing on his pajamas and he tore his shirt.

    670. Sara's shoes turn puce.

    672. Charlie thinks he hears the swans and goes out to look for them.

    673-75. Dogs terrorize Charlie; he is hurt, cut, scared, and crying.

    676. Sara is worried about her hair.

    676. It takes awhile before they realize Charlie isn't in the house.  (This part is especially well-
            written.  While Sara worries about trivialities, we sit there practically screaming at her
            to go downstairs and help Charlie!)
 

    679. They go to the lake, but Charlie isn't there.

    681. Charlie's picture reminds them of the danger of his situation.  (This picture is a very
        important symbol because for the first time, Sara begins to see Charlie not as a retarded
        brother, but as a human being, frightened, scared, and alone.)

    683. Aunt Willy compares Sara to Uncle Bert who used to hold grudges.  (Another dead
        relative!  It is unclear as to who he is.  Aunt Willy's husband?  Brother?  Either way,
        it's one more death for Sam to deal with.)

    683. This is the first summer that Sara did not have scabby knees.  (She's less of a tomboy.)

    685. Sam calls, but is very cold--says he'll call back later.

    686. Joe Melby offers to help, but Sara still blames him for the watch.

    688. Sara decides to let Joe help them.
 
    690-691. Sara learns that Joe is innocent.  He got the watch back from some boys who were
        teasing Charlie.

    691. Sara begins to realize how badly she's treated Joe.

    692. Mary can't stay long; she needs to go to Benny Hoffman's party.  (Compare this self-
            centered bubbledhead to Joe.)

    692. Aunt Willie's uncle and brother(?) were killed in a coal mine!

    693. The radio reminds Sara to keep searching.  (Again, she is seeing Charlie as a person.
            She knows how scared he will be if strangers find him first.)

    694. Joe found Charlie's slipper.  (When Sara sees the slipper, she sees loneliness in the image
            of the indian on the toe.  Obviously, it shows more of her continuing appreciation of the
            humanity of her brother.)

    696. Joe decides to go with Sara, rather than talk to Mary about the party.
 
 

IV. CLIMAX:

        696.  Sara knows she must say she's sorry to Joe.  It takes her a long time to work up the
    courage but she finally says it, admitting that she knows she was wrong about him.
 

V. TURNING POINT: (The turning point of novel tells us the results of the climax.  In this case,
        we see how Sara's opinions of all the other characters, including herself, have changed.  In
        her eyes, they have perhaps all become swans.)

    697. Joe explains how he was hurt by a teacher.  (He is more sensitive than Sara realized.
        She knows that Joe is just like her.)

    698. Charlie is stuck in a ravine, feels hopeless, decides to give up!

    698: SYMBOLISM: CHARLIE'S WATCH HAS DIED!  (This is such an easy symbol for the
            kids to see--Charlie had it all the time; it was just so much a part of him.  Now it is dead,
            and we know Charlie has given up all hope.)

    700. They climb a high hill to look for Charlie.

    701. She calls but cannot get an answer.

    702. Sara thinks she hears Charlie and races down the hill.

    703. Charlie hears Sarah calling for him.

    705. . . . As he saw Sara a strange expression came over his face, an expression of wonder
            and joy and disbelief, and Sara knew that if she lived to be a hundred no one would ever
            look at her quite that way again.  (Sara now sees him as a person, not a thing.)

    707. Joe gives Charlie his watch to replace the broken one. (IRONY--a reversal, or twist of
            events)

    707. She sees the swans going home. (SYMBOL:  all the swans are going home, including
            Sara, Joe, and Charlie.)

    708. Charlie runs to Aunt Willie, and it doesn't bother Sarah. (Sara would have been jealous
                    of this yesterday, but now she understands that Aunt Willy will always be the mother
                    figure for Charlie.  Aunt Willy has just become a swan in Sara's eyes.)

    708. Joe asks Sara to the party. (Sara is a swan in her own eyes at last.)

    710. Dad calls.  THE PARAGRAPH ON THE RIGHT COLUMN SUMS UP SARA'S
        LEARNING EXPERIENCE!

           "A picture came into her mind of the laughing, curly-headed man with the broken tooth in the photograph album, and she suddenly saw life as a series of huge, uneven steps, and she saw herself on the steps, standing motionless in her prison shirt, and she had just taken an enormous step up out of the shadows, and she was standing, waiting, and there were other steps in front of her, so that she could go as high as the sky, and she saw Charlie on a flight of small difficult steps, and her father down at the bottom of some steps, just sitting and not trying to go further.  She saw everyone she knew on those blinding white steps, and for a moment everything was clearer than it had ever been."
        (Sara finally is adult enough to understand others.  She knows now that Charlie must be allowed to climb his own steps, perhaps at the school Wanda spoke of; and she understands that her father has suffered too much and doesn't want to try to climb anymore.  Clearly, she knows what must be done. And, clearly, Wanda and Sam have become swans, too.)
 
 

VI. DENOUEMENT:

         Sara's got blue feet. (She is still Sara, despite the many changes she has undergone.)


 CLICK HERE FOR ANOTHER SUMMER OF THE SWANS REFERENCE
 
CLICK HERE TO RETURN TO THE MULTIMEDIA CLASSROOM
 
The Multimedia Classroom is proud to be associated with Amazon.com.  Books and videos to accompany my lessons may be obtained by clicking on the logo.


You are visitor number  to visit this site.  Thank you! 
This page hosted byGeoCitiesGet your own Free Home Page