"We deny duty-faith and duty-repentance - these terms
signifying that it is every man's duty spiritually and savingly to repent
and believe. We deny also that there is any capability in man by
nature to any spiritual good whatever. So that reject the doctrine
that men in a state of nature should be exhorted to believe in or turn
to God."
Whatever our worthy predecessors intended by the terms of
this Article, they certainly did not mean to minimize the sin of
unbelief. The purpose was to rebut the flesh-pleasing error taught
by the Arminian that man in his natural state (that is, dead in
trespasses and sins) is possessed of some latent power to exercise
savingly the spiritual acts of faith and repentance. Our belief is
that fallen man has neither power, nor will, nor inclination to
anything spiritual. Scripture abundantly teaches this (I Cor. 2:14
Rom. 8: 7,8; Matt. 15: 19; John 1:11-13; 3:3-7). But this
notwithstanding, we believe that all men are under obligation to
believe and obey God. Though the Adam Fall utterly depraved
and alienated human nature from God and goodness, rendering
him as entirely incapable as unwilling to submit to God's law, yet
the divine Lawgiver has not lost His power to command and to
judge. Man's inability does not exonerate him. While some
entertain a wholesome fear of the very term duty in relation to
God, through its frequent misapplication, both Solomon and his
divine Antitype speak of man's duty. On the completion of his
extensive survey, the wisest man came to the conclusion that to fear
God and keep His commandments is the whole duty of man (Eccl.12:13).
And the all-wise God-Man said, "When ye shall have done all those
things which are commanded you, say, We are unprofitable servants:
we have done that which was our duty to do" (Luke 17:10).
To the unregenerate the thought of duty Godward either does
not arise or is soon dismissed with some formal religious service.
What to innocent humanity must have been delightful is to sinful
man irksome. Before regeneration he is capable neither of
acceptable obedience nor worship. At the same time, unbelief is a
chief sin, the root of all other sins (John 16:9; Rom. 1. 19, 28).
But what is every man duty-bound to believe? Surely not that
each individual is himself interested in the redemption work of
Christ, Man is not called upon to believe a lie. No, but as God
has revealed Himself in His Word and works, man is inexcusable in
his unbelief. Here caution is needed. Men require to be
thoroughly warned of their lost state under the law, convinced of
their inability to meets its demands and told of their accountability
to God and of his revealed wrath against all unrighteousness of men.
Thus warned of "wrath to come" repentance towards God and faith towards
our Lord Jesus Christ may be properly preached (Acts 20:21).
As the convincing power of the Holy Spirit attends the ministry, the elect
are soughtout and brought in guilty before God. To them Christ will be
attractive as held forth in the gospel. It is the sick soul who wants
the Physician, and it is the minister's duty and privilege to minister
the consolations of the gospel to such.
Faith being the peculiar gift of God's grace, and repentance a
spiritual grant of heaven (Eph. 2:8 Acts 11:18; 5:31), neither can
originate in the will or power of the creature or be the act of the
unregenerate. Even when duly convicted, a sinner proves that to
exercise repentance and faith is more than he is able for [capable
of], apart from the empowering grace of the Holy Spirit. "Dutyfaith" and
"duty-repentance" are little use to one who feels himself lost and
helpless. To demand it from such s to strike the dying dead. But it
is as life from the dead when he is enabled bv the blessed Spirit so
to believe in Christ as to find power and courage to confess sin
(unbelief is well as all other sins) to God, and to plead for pardon
and mercy for His sake. Then, when witness is borne in upon the
confessing sinner's heart of his grace-given interest in the redeeming
blood of Christ, and the love of God is shed abroad in his heart with
sweet dissolving efficacy producing deep contrition, it is the believer's
delightful privilege (call it duty who will) to believe and
to repent with an evangelical repentance unto salvation not to be
repented of (2 Cor. 7:10). Accompanying this faith and repentance
is deep reverence and unbounded happiness and sweet liberty. True
worship, embracing adoration, admiration, trust, thanksgiving, praise,
submission and absolute surrender, flows front the liberated spirit
of the pardoned child; while the gracious fruits of humility and
love and beauty to the garments of salvation which clothe the soul
(Psa. 149:4@ Isa. 61:10). This is the purpose of the gospel ministry,
as said Christ to the Apostle Paul: ". . . to open their eyes, and to
turn them from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan unto God,
that they may receive forgiveness of sins, and inheritance among them which
are sanctified by faith that is in Me" (Acts 26:18). Paul "warned
every man, and taught every man" of the Colossian church in order
to their being presented perfect in Christ Jesus (Col. 1:28). He
did not unconditionally exhort every individual to believe in Christ,
but showed those to whom He was sent "that they should repent
and turn to God, and do works meet for repentance 11 (Acts 26:18-21).
Indiscriminately to call upon all in a mixed congregation to do
their duty, i.e. savingly and spiritually to believe in Christ, is to
imply either that each individual person in the assembly is
regenerate and convinced of sin, or that there is in those who are
dead power to act Godward. This appears contrary to the leading
of the Holy Spirit who instructs gospel ministers both what to
preach and where. Even the apostles were forbidden to preach the
Word in certain places for certain periods. Presumably most Godsent
ministers know in some measure the influence which emanates from
the Holy Spirit through the presence of some in their
congregation whom He inhabits, or whom fie will bless and instruct
through the ministry-, and the totally different influence sometimes
felt when some particular opposition to the truth is being
entertained by some hearers. Mysteriously, but no less trulv, the
Holy Ghost controls the ministry of His Word according to the
purpose of electing love and the condition of those present. In
former and better days this was more clearly manifest than now.
We are charged by some with preaching only to the elect,
instead of "evangelizing" the world. We have no zeal to boast,but
can appeal to the great Searcher of hearts that we are painfully
anxious for the success of the gospel the weight of immortal soul's
is heavy. But we are equally anxious not to deceive into a false
notion of faith (as we much fear is frequently the case) those who
have never been convinced of sin. We venture to say that those
who think themselves quite capable of exercising faith at will
because it is their duty to believe, and are satisfied with their faith,
have probably never yet learned the power of God in which Paul
desired the faith of the Corinthians should stand (I Cor. 2:5), nor
yet discovered the true Object of faith a revealed, not a
"letter" Christ.
One good man said:
Besides, it appears very far removed from the compassion
(which it affects) to command unconvinced people to believe. The
creation of believers is not a work for mere man, though "faith
cometh by hearing, and hearing by the Word of God" (Rom. 10:17).
The mercy of God, which is His compassion, is shown in giving
faith. "He bath concluded them all in unbelief, that he might
have mercy on all" (Rom. 10:32). And it is most solemnly
written: "He hath mercy on whom He will, and whom He will He
hardeneth" (9. 18). "Then hath God also to the Gentiles granted
repentance unto life" (Acts 11:18), and "put no difference between
us and them, purifying their hearts by faith" (15:9). "Not of
ourselves" but "the gift of God" is the saving faith of God's elect,
and of a totally different nature from the faith into which
impenitent unregenerate sinners may be persuaded. The latter
does not purify the heart, nor work by love, nor separate from the
world and sin. "It is dead, being alone" (James 2. 17). The
professing world is filled with these nominal believers. But in
giving living faith to some, the Lord makes effectual the preaching
of the gospel, as in the case of Peter: "God at first did visit the
Gentiles, to take out of them a people for His name" (Acts 15:14),
If Adam's guilt is transmitted to the human race, and all are
born in sin and are dead to God by nature (Eph. 2:1) is it not a
grievous error to suggest that by a general exhortation men can be
awakened from that sleep of death, and of themselves savingly
repent and believe the gospel? As good Berridge says:
Isaiah asks: "Who hath believed our report? and to whom is
the arm of the Lord revealed?" plainly implying that faith results
from divine revelation. It was something more than response to
mere human exhortation to believe that enabled Peter to declare
his faith in such emphatic terms: "Thou art the Christ,
the Son of the living God," The Saviour Himself declared whence
that faith came: - Flesh and blood hath not revealed this unto thee,
but My Father which is in heaven" (Matt. 16:17).
We conclude with the simple statement that whereas we
believe it to be every man's duty to credit God's Word both as to
the law's dernands and the record God has given of His Son, yet to
address assemblies in such a way as to suggest that every person is
capable of exercising saving faith and producing evangelical
repentance is but to mock men. But solemnly to tell sinners that
they have broken the holy law of God which therefore condemns
them, and that "there is none other name under heaven given
among men whereby we must be saved" but that of the Lord Jesus
Christ who is exalted a Prince and Saviour for to give repentance
and forgiveness of sins; to testify that Christ is the end of the law to
every one that believeth in Him, that in Him there is full pardon
and plenteous redemption, and that God honourably justifies the
ungodly who believe in Christ; to declare that however deeply
convinced of sin, Christ is able to save to the uttermost all who
come by Him to God, and that He will in no wise cast out any who
come; to proclaim to all who deeply feel their ignorance that there
is an infallible Teacher,the Holy Spirit, whom Christ hath promised
shall be give to, who asks Him, of the, Father (Luke 11:13),
to guide them into all truth (John 16:13)- this we believe is to preach
according to the tenor of the Word of God.
But though faith, "cometh by hearing", it does not necessarily
come to all who hear. "As many as were ordained to eternal life
believed" (Acts 13:48). Application is the sovereign prerogative
of the Holy Ghost. The great apostle, perceiving that in preaching
Christ he was the savour of life unto life to those who were saved
and the savour of death unto death to those who were lost,
exclaimed, "Who is sufficient for these things?" How much more
reason have we to confess our insufficiency! Our mercy will be
ever to prove with Paul that "our sufficiency is of God."
This will not impair the earnestness of our appeals to the
unconverted, but it will temper our addresses with a sobriety
becoming the solemnity of the eternal issues involved.
"O could I but believe,
Paul attributed to the Holy Ghost the power through which hope,
joy, peace and faith should abound in the Roman saints (Rom. 15,
13). lie also prayed that God would fulfil in the Thessalonians
"the work of faith with power." All which implies what every child
of God proves in experience - that faith is the gift of God's grace,
Christ is its Author, and for every subsequent prevailing act of faith
the believer is dependent upon the reviving power of the Spirit of
Christ who said, "I am the resurrection and the life." Definitely
Paul teaches believing to be the result of the exertion in the soul of
that very same power exerted in raising Christ from the dead (Eph.
1:19, 20). So that to reach that saving faith is a mere duty, for
which a sinner is quite capable, is solemnly wide of the truth. Truly
the just shall live by his faith - not on it, but by it,
as it is drawn out into exercise upon its blessed Object, its Author
and End, the Lord Jesus Christ.
Then all would easy be:
I would but cannot, Lord, relieve,
My help must come from Thee."
"None can raise to life the dead
While we definitely believe that it is the duty of man to believe all
God has declared, and that unbelief is guilt, we consider it
seriously erroneous to call upon all persons indiscriminately to
perform such spiritual acts as repentance and faith as if they
possessed in themselves an inherent power of spiritual life. In the
fervency of a minister's appeal, much depends on the spirit and the
emphasis; but all vitality depends on the Holy Ghost. Vital power
does accompany the preaching of the gospel, both in conviction and
killing, in making alive and delivering, and it is an unspeakable
honour to be the instrument of conveying the gospel ministerially to
poor lost sinners. But as we have so frequently pointed out, there
is a vast difference between preaching the gospel in a mixed
congregation, and offering Christ and salvation
indiscriminately to all. Some who came to John's baptism were
met with a solemn rebuff: "O generation of vipers, who hath warned
you to flee from the wrath to come? Bring forth therefore fruits meet
for repentance" (Matt. 3:7,8). Owen most truly says "Faith without
repentance issues in presumption; repentance [that is, conviction]
without faith issues in despair.
But He who raised Himself indeed,
And for dead sinners died."
Please direct your comments to
Mike Krall.