This one is just great(yes, even without Liam)! Well, aside from the fact that it seems a bit scratchy compared to the Album version. Unfortunately, Noel doesn't say, "You can put your life in the hands of this rock 'n roll band. We're never gonna throw it away."(a line which Noel has been know to sing at live shows instead of the normal, "Please don't put your life in the hands of a rock 'n roll band who'll throw it all away.", which is a tad more dreary.) One more thing, in the last part of the song where Noel sings, "My soul slides away, but don't look back in anger, don't look back in anger, I heard you say. At least not today." He waits a couple beats too many between "my soul slides away" and "but don't look back in anger." Well, that's it. Feel free to look back in anger if you want(but don't tell Noel).