Australian Tour 1964
Publisher: Yellow Dog Records
Reference: YD 071
Liner notes:
These live recordings presented in this 2 CD set have been
recently re-discovered in Delaware,USA,in May 1998.
The tapes were sourced from a retired American photographer, who
had covered the Australian - Far East leg of the Beatles 1964
world tour for a New York newspaper.
He had apparently been in possession of a copy of these tapes
since the heady days of June 1964.
Due to the poor conditions in which the tapes had been stored,preliminary
assessment of the tapes,showed that some degradation of the sound
quality of the recordings had occurred,in particular during the
Beatles' support acts section of the tapes.
However, much of the Beatles recordings remain unscathed, and
with the use of modern sound and production techniques, every
attempt has been made to present the best ever quality of these
historical shows.
These recordings for the first time present the best known source
tapes currently available for the two concerts held at Melbourne's
Festival Hall on July 17th 1964.
Previously, bootlegs have attempted to present these recordings
as genuine and complete, but often have either omitted tracks,
substituted tracks from other shows or have used inferior audio
tracks from video tape.
These recordings of the two 17th June 1964 Melbourne shows are
totally different to those versions previously available on other
bootlegs or the "Beatles Sing For Shell" Australian TV
broadcast in 1964 (& on a number of occasions since then).
While it is uncertain as to the exact origin of these recordings,
it is plainly obvious by the different mix and lower level of
crowd noise relative to the music, that these recordings have
originated from a separate recordings system to that used record
the video (+ associated audio) for the TV broadcast.
Whether these are actual inline recordings or from a separate
microphone set up, it is near to impossible to tell.
However considering the era in which they were recorded along
with the fact that multi-track mixes and recorders did not exist,
except for the rarefied hallows of recording studios (and in 1964
only 2 & 4 track units existed), the latter scenario is the
most probable.
But we will never know for certain.
Also for the first time, a significant portion of the Beatles
support acts have been made available to the public.
Unfortunately, in trying to present to you what "Beatlemania"
must have felt & sounded like in 1964, with the inclusion of
press conferences, interviews and arrival material, all of the
available support act's material was not able to be included in
this set. (maybe next time...)
The tapes, when re-discovered, had very little information or
documentation to indicate their historical nature or importance.
One tape had "17/6/64 Tape No.1" and the other "17/6/64
Tape No.2" (For our American friends,please note that
Australia follows the British date nomenclature of Day:Month:Year).
Thus for any one who happened to find the tapes, unless the
significance of the date 17/6/64 was apparent or they managed to
sit through the extremely poor quality (sound wise) of the
support acts, they would never know what lay on the inner
portions of the tapes.
Besides the sonic improvements & restorations to the tapes,
one of the main items which needed to be determined was if in
fact these tapes were (both) from 17/6/64 concerts.
Historical "bootleg" (both vinyl and CD) have had two
distinct concerts available from the Melbourne leg of the Beatles
1964 Australian Tour.
However, it soon was apparent that the information could not be
relied upon as the dates for the other releases ranged from June
16th through to July 1st 1964 (on July 1st, the Beatles were mid
flight, somewhere between Singapore and Frankfurt)
It is our belief that these two concerts are from the 17/6/64,
given the following :
(1) the, albeit limited, information on tape reels themselves
(2) one of the concerts (the late concert) is identical to the
video concert footage filmed on the 17th June for the Melbourne
based GTV-9 Television network, and shown on Australian TV as
"Beatles Sing For Shell" (note: although the music is
the same,the actual mix is different to that available on the
video tape)
(3) The mix and "sound" of the two concerts is very
similar and to achieve such a similarity on consecutive evenings
would be near to impossible. Rather, consecutive concerts on the
same night, with equipment and settings on recorders not being
altered,is more probable.
(4) During the Sounds Incorporated set on the first tape, it is
mentioned that this particular evening was their last in
Melbourne, while Paul McCartney says the same during his
monologue between Twist & Shout and Long Tall Sally from the
second tape.
Besides confirming the date of the concerts, identification of
which reel-to-reel tape contained the early concert and which
contained the late concert needed to be done.
Here the evidence is somewhat circumstantial, but without other
evidence it is the best we have to go by.
Again we have the fact that (1) the tapes were numbered "No.1"
tape and "No.2" tape. (an obvious deduction is that
tape No.1 is the early concert and tape No.2 is the late concert).
(2) The second tape (as already mentioned) corresponds to the
concert which was video taped, and used for the "Beatles
Sing For Shell" TV broadcast. (this can be confirmed very
easily by listening to the last portion of Long Tall Sally, where
John suddenly stops playing because a male spectator has rushed
onto the stage to shake his hand).
It seems the obvious deduction that the TV station would have
video taped the final concert of the day (17/6/64) ,maybe using
the early concert to set up equipment and sort of technical
problems.
Remember in 1964 video tape was a very expensive commodity. (for
those of you who do not own a copy of the Melbourne video,
technical problems still occurred, as portions of a number of
tracks are either not recorded or have glitches in them).
One of the most puzzling aspects of these tapes is that there is
only one version of Long Tall Sally, that being from the late (video-taped)
concert. (Paul's "thank you" and introduction to Long
Tall Sally is also missing from the early concert tape.)
In fact of all the Melbourne Festival Hall bootlegs released over
the past 21 years, there has only ever been one version of Long
Tall Sally (i.e. the one with John momentarily stopping playing).
Recent CD Bootleg releases such as "All the Best From
Australia" have substituted this single version of Long Tall
Sally for both their 16/6/64 and 17/6/64 concerts (which in fact
should have been dated as the late and early 17/6/64 concerts) or
in the case of "Melbourne Complete!", where the date is
correct, the order of the concerts has been swapped around, to
have the announcer's full introduction at the start of the CD.
One final point of confusion is that although no bootleg has ever
had two different version of Long Tall Sally from Melbourne 1964
concerts, some bootlegs actually have a second (from the early
concert) Paul McCartney "thank you" and introduction
monologue to Long Tall Sally. (This is where he thanks the
president of Melbourne fan club..... and "...his girl...")
This Paul monologue was not evident of the tapes which were used
as the basis for this CD release.
While not directly saying that this "other" Paul
monologue is a fake, or has been taken from another concert, the
bootlegs on which this Paul monologue exists, all precede this
monologue with a version of Twist & Shout which ends with (what
appears to be) two hits of a snare drum.
The tapes which we have used only show at the end of Twist &
Shout a single drum hit for the late concert or the no-hit for
the early concert.
And to even murky the waters further, the "two snare drum
hit" is exactly the same as that at the end of the late
concert version of This Boy.
So what are two of Ringo's drum beats, from the late concert
version of This Boy, doing trying to cover an obvious edit point
between Twist & Shout and Paul's monologue from the early
concert,on these previously available bootlegs?
Confused?
Then we have This Boy..... Until the re-discovery of the tapes
which have lead to this release, there had only been one version
of This Boy available from the Melbourne concerts.
And again, over the past 21 years, bootleggers had substituted
the single version of This Boy into all available concerts.
The main difference between the two versions of This Boy is that
the early version seems to almost fall apart, as the Beatles are
playing it, in the same manner as the final version of Get Back
from the Rooftop concert, some five years later, just stumbles
along. (also at the end of the late concert version,someone -
maybe John - makes what can only be described at "turkey
noise".... have a listen)
Of the support acts, the entire Sounds Incorporated sets from
both the early and late concerts have been included in this two
CD set.
Surprisingly, the sonic quality of the recording of the Sounds
Incorporated drummer, appears to be far better than that afforded
to Ringo's drum sound.
Why this is, is anyone's guess....
To complete the bill, two local Australian acts were engaged as
support acts.
We have presented one track from each of the two local acts.
Johnny Chester sings the track Fever, from the early concert and
from the late concert, Johnny Delvin sings (the not so old in
1964,Ray Charles classic) What'd I Say, backed by the group the
Phantoms.
The interview and arrival portions of this CD set have been
sourced from various (aging) documentary cine-film and video
tapes, which were taken during the tour of Australia by the local
and oversea news agencies.
CD1:
Track | Comments | ||
1. | Ringo Arrives In Melbourne | Ringo arrives at Essendon Aerodrome Melbourne Australia, 14th June 1964 (commentary by Brian Naylor) | |
14 Jun 1964 | |||
2:34 | |||
2. | Interview With Ringo And Brian Epstein | Interview with Ringo and Brian Epstein, Essendon Aerodrome, 14th June 1964 | |
14 Jun 1964 | |||
3. | Beatles Arrive In Melbourne | Beatles arrive at Essendon Aerodrome Melbourne Australia, 14th June 1964 | |
14 Jun 1964 | |||
9:20 | |||
4. | Beatlemania | Edited highlights from 3 hours of Beatlemania at the Southern Cross Hotel Melbourne, including the Beatles on the roof top, 14th June 1964. | |
14 Jun 1964 | |||
10:31 | |||
5. | Fever | Concert - Melbourne | NOT THE BEATLES. Morning concert. Johnny Chester singing. |
Davenport/Cooley | 17 Jun 1964 | ||
3:21 | |||
6. | Fingertips | Concert - Melbourbe | Not The Beatles ! Morning concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
Paul/Cosby | 17 Jun 1964 | ||
7. | Brontosorus Stomp | Concert - Melbourbe | Not The Beatles ! Morning concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
8. | Spartans | Concert - Melbourbe | Not The Beatles ! Morning concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
9. | Drum Solo | Concert - Melbourbe | Not The Beatles ! Morning concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
10. | Maria | Concert - Melbourbe | Not The Beatles ! Morning concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
11. | William Tell Overture | Concert - Melbourbe | Not The Beatles ! Morning concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
Rossini | 17 Jun 1964 | ||
12. | Introduction | Concert - Melbourne | Introduction by announcer & the Beatles "plugging in". |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
0:57 | |||
13. | I Saw Her Standing There | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.01 |
||
14. | You Can't Do That | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.02 |
||
15. | All My Loving | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.03 |
||
16. | She Loves You | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.03 |
||
17. | Till There Was You | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Willson | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.04 |
||
18. | Roll Over Beethoven | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Berry | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.05 |
||
19. | Can't Buy Me Love | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.06 |
||
20. | This Boy | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.07 |
||
21. | Twist And Shout | Concert - Melbourne | Morning concert. |
Russell/Medley | 17 Jun 1964 C640617a.08 |
CD2:
Track | Comments | ||
1. | What'd I Say | Concert - Melbourne | Not The Beatles Evening concert. Johnny Delvin singing. |
Charles | 17 Jun 1964 | ||
3:20 | |||
2. | Fingertips | Concert - Melbourne | Not The Beatles. Evening concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
Paul/Cosby | 17 Jun 1964 | ||
3. | Brontosorus Stomp | Concert - Melbourne | Not The Beatles. Evening concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
4. | Spartans | Concert - Melbourne | Not The Beatles. Evening concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
5. | Drum Solo | Concert - Melbourne | Not The Beatles. Evening concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
6. | Maria | Concert - Melbourne | Not The Beatles. Evening concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
7. | William Tell Overture | Concert - Melbourne | Not The Beatles. Evening concert. Sounds Incorporated playing. |
Rossini | 17 Jun 1964 | ||
8. | Introduction | Concert - Melbourne | Announcement |
17 Jun 1964 | |||
2:23 | |||
9. | I Saw Her Standing There | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.01 |
||
10. | You Can't Do That | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.02 |
||
11. | All My Loving | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.03 |
||
12. | She Loves You | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.04 |
||
13. | Till There Was You | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Willson | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.05 |
||
14. | Roll Over Beethoven | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Berry | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.06 |
||
15. | Can't Buy Me Love | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.07 |
||
16. | This Boy | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Lennon/McCartney | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.08 |
||
17. | Twist And Shout | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Russell/Medley | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.09 |
||
18. | Long Tall Sally | Concert - Melbourne | Evening concert. |
Johnson/Penniman/Blackwell | 17 Jun 1964 C640617b.10 |
||
19. | Press Conference | Press Conference at the Southern Cross Hotel Melbourne, 14th June 1964. | |
14 Jun 1964 |