We've checked out (rented/bought) a few anime titles in the last year or so. The following is a working list that rates how much we liked/disliked the anime (umm soon). Eventually, I will put a synopsis for each title, a viewer rating (kiddie-ok/adult/etc.), and other info.
Legend:
(dvd) = DVD
(s) = subtitled videotape
(d) = dubbed videotape
(ws) = wide screen format
A
Agent Aika -- Parts I, II (s)
Akira (d)
Animatrix (dvd)
B
Bite Me! Chameleon (s)
Black Lion (s)
Bubblegum Crisis (d)
C
The Castle of Cagliostro (d)
Chimera (s)
Cutey Honey -- Part 1 (s)
Cowboy Bebop -- Parts 1-6 (dvd)
Cowboy Bebop The Movie (dvd)
Curse of the Undead Yoma (s)
D
Debutante Detective Corps (s)
Dirty Pair Flash -- Acts I, II (s)
Dragon Half -- Parts I,II (s)
Dragon Knight -- I, III (s)
E
Elven Bride -- Parts I, II
F
Fushigi Yuugi "Mysterious Play" (s)
The Universe of the Four Gods
Trials of the Heart
Separation
The Priestess of Seiryu
Dark Reunion
(we had the sixth, but the subtitled version is faulty and has yet to be reissued, that I know of)
Summoning of Suzaka
G
Galaxy Express 999 (s)
Ghost in the Shell (d)
Goldenboy -- Parts I-VI (d)
Gunsmith Cats - I (dvd)
H
The Hakkenden -- 1-7 (d+dvd) nice soundtrack!
The Hex Files - Magic Twilight 1-3 (s)
Homeroom Affairs -- Parts I, II
Hyperdoll -- Acts I, II
K
Kiki's Delivery Service (s)
L
Lain I,II,III(s)
Lupin III's Greatest Capers (d)
M
Megami Paradise -- I,II
Mermaid Forest
My Neighbor Totoro (dvd)
N
Neon Genesis Evangelion - 0:1 (s)
Ninja Resurrection - The Revenge of Juubei (s)
Ninja Resurrection - (the third Ninja Scroll installment) (s)
Ninja Scroll (d)
Ninja Cadets
O
(Welcome to the) Ogenki Clinic (s)
P
The Ping Pong Club
Love and Comedy (Die! Die! Die!) (s)Plastic Little - The Adventures of Captain Tita (s)
Gone Too Far (s)
Princess Mononoke (dvd)
R
Rail of the Star (s)
Ranma 1/2 - Desperately Seeking Shampoo (d)
Riding Bean (d)
Ruin Explorers - 1,2 (s)
S
Sakura Wars (s)
Sorceror Hunters - I,II (s)
Streetfighter II
U
Urusei Yatsura - "Only You" Movie #1
V
Vampire Hunter D (d)
Vampire Hunter D Blood Lust (dvd)
Voltage Fighter Gowcaizer (s)
W
Weather Report Girl - Parts 1,2 (s)
Wrath of the Ninja - The Yotoden Movie (d)