During the investigation,
Scully and Mulder are going over some files when a drop of
blood appears on the top sheet of paper they are reading
over. Scully is experiencing a bloody nose brought on by her
cancer.
While in the washroom, she
sees an apparition of a dying girl and the words "She Is Me"
written in blood on the mirror.
She goes to the doctor to
get a check-up following the nosebleed. After getting a
blood test, Scully takes the opportunity to visit the
counselor she talked with in the 2nd season episode
"Irresistible".
When asked if she feels she
owes it to Mulder to keep working, she denies it. "I guess I
never realized how much I rely on him before this. His
passion. He's been a great source of strength that I've
drawn on."
She explains the image and
tells the counselor that the woman appeared to be trying to
tell her something. But she claims not to know what the
message was. "Are you sure?" the counselor presses.
Scully asks what of the
other people that also had the visions. Mulder says Harold
had an additional connection with all of them. They were all
dying.
S: I saw something, Mulder.
The 4th victim. I saw her in the bathroom before you came to
tell me. M: Why didn't you tell me? S: Because I didn't want
to believe it. Because I DON'T want to believe it.
You can believe what you
want to believe, Scully. But you can't hide the truth from
me, because if you do then you're working against me. And
yourself. I know what you're afraid of. I'm afraid of the
same thing.
As she sits behind the
wheel, she gives in to her overwrought emotions and breaks
down, beginning to cry.
|
Elegy
The X-File involves an autistic man, Harold, who works at a
bowling alley and lives at a psychiatric center. Harold has
been seeing the victims of murders just before or as they
die. They appear to be speaking to him, as if they want to
make some final form of communication.
During the investigation, Scully and Mulder are going
over some files when a drop of blood appears on the top
sheet of paper they are reading over. Scully is experiencing
a bloody nose brought on by her cancer. She goes to the
restroom to wash up and probably to escape Mulder's concern.
While in the washroom, she sees an apparition of a dying
girl and the words "She Is Me" written in blood on the
mirror. At that moment Mulder knocks on the restroom door
distracting her from the apparition and when she looks back,
it is gone. Mulder came to tell Scully that there has been
another death. It's the girl Scully just saw. She doesn't
share this experience with Mulder; out of fear or denial,
only she can say.
Scully tells Mulder she's going to let him handle this
latest aspect of the case while she goes to the doctor to
get a check-up following the nosebleed. After getting a
blood test, Scully takes the opportunity to visit the
counselor she talked with in the 2nd season episode
"Irresistible".
She tells the counselor of her cancer and its untreatable
nature. The counselor asks why Scully has kept working. Why
it's important to her. Scully seems hard-pressed to
formulate an answer. She says Mulder has been concerned and
supportive. When asked if she feels she owes it to Mulder to
keep working, she denies it. "I guess I never realized how
much I rely on him before this. His passion. He's been a
great source of strength that I've drawn on." The counselor
asks her what happened to bring her in for a session. She
confesses that she "saw something" but she doesn't know if
it was due to the stress, because the image had been
suggested to her, or if it was an image borne of her fears.
"Your fear of failing him?" the counselor queries. Scully
gives a slightly pained laugh and says, maybe. She explains
the image and tells the counselor that the woman appeared to
be trying to tell her something. But she claims not to know
what the message was. "Are you sure?" the counselor presses.
Scully, with tears in her eyes, seems to shake her head no
but with uncertainty or an unwanted knowledge in her eyes.
Mulder goes to Scully's home to bring her up to date. She
is sitting in quiet contemplation when he rings the bell.
Launching into the case and his request for her medical
advice, Mulder barely catches himself and remembers to ask
after her health. With a typical "I'm fine" from Scully,
they get back to the case. He tells her of the bowling alley
owner's death and how Harold had an apparition as it
happened. He then launches into his theory. He thinks
Harold's autism kept him from forming typical bonds with
people he cared about. He says the bonds he formed were
almost psychic, beyond the temporal. Scully asks what of the
other people that also had the visions. Mulder says Harold
had an additional connection with all of them. They were all
dying. One of emphysema, one cancer, one a heart condition,
and he wants Scully's medical opinion on Harold who he's
convinced will also show signs of some fatal condition. What
he doesn't realize is the impact that his theory is having
on Scully. She never mentioned her vision to him but he does
know she has cancer so he might have tempered his talk of
mortality. Poor Scully.
At the conclusion of the case, Harold is dead and the
killer apprehended. As they leave the psychiatric hospital,
Scully reveals to Mulder what she's been holding back. S: I
saw something, Mulder. The 4th victim. I saw her in the
bathroom before you came to tell me. M: Why didn't you tell
me? S: Because I didn't want to believe it. Because I DON'T
want to believe it. M: Is that why you came down here? To
prove that it wasn't true? S: No. I came down here because
you asked me to. M: Why can't you be honest with me? S: What
do you want me to say? That you're right? That I believe it
even if I don't? I mean, is that what you want? M: Is that
what you think I want to hear? S: No. M: You can believe
what you want to believe, Scully. But you can't hide the
truth from me, because if you do then you're working against
me. And yourself. I know what you're afraid of. I'm afraid
of the same thing. S: The doctor said I was fine. M: I hope
that's the truth. S: I'm going home. M: (heavy sigh)
[This whole exchange smacked a bit of Mulder's
self-centered nature to me. This is, of course, my
unsolicited opinion but it seemed almost an afterthought
when he threw in the line "And yourself". Up until then it
was all about how her withholding the vision was effecting
him and the work. What about how the cancer and her
impending death is effecting her? Her feelings. Her fears.
Even when he softens a bit and says he knows what she fears
and that he holds the same fears, her next statement brings
the double edged comment, "I hope that's the truth." He
hopes she is fine but he also hopes she's telling him the
truth and not holding anything back from him. I know that
their partnership is based on trust and that he wants them
to be on an even playing field, but he might consider for
more than one second what she's going through. As she
pointed out in "Never Again", it's not all about him.]
Scully leaves the hospital and gets in her car. As she
sits behind the wheel, she gives in to her overwrought
emotions and breaks down, beginning to cry. An ambulance
with sirens wailing goes by and as she watches it pass, her
gaze goes to her rearview mirror. She sees Harold sitting in
the back seat. When she turns around, the back seat is
empty. It was another vision. Possibly, another harbinger of
death.
|