The Experience of the Factory Committees in the Russian
Revolution
October 1917
The insurrection that gave power to the Bolsheviks was strictly
speaking the work of the Military-Revolutionary Committee of the
Petrograd Soviet. Although only small numbers were actively involved
initially, the total lack of opposition to them, the absence of
support for the Provisional Government meant they could not be
described as a minority. Support for the action came rushing in after
the event from the Soviet of Petrograd Trade Unions and the
All-Russian Soviet of Factory Committees amongst others. The factory
committees rallied to the Bolsheviks because the latter appeared to
support the workers' aspirations. The committees had been active in
the July Days, had helped organise armed guards, and were involved In
the Military-Revolutionary Committee. Skrypnik, a Bolshevik on the
Central Council of Factory Committees had told the party's Central
Committee that the workers were ready for a revolution, and if there
wasn't one soon, the committees would swing to the
anarcho-syndicalists. Mass meetings in Petrograd called for the
Second All-Russian Congress of Workers' and Soldiers' Deputies to
form a government. This was a clear ratification of the seizure of
power. If October was 'easy', it was because all the work had been
done beforehand. The Provisional Government was utterly discredited,
and Bolshevism's reactionary aspect had not been revealed.
Despite the mass of workers and soldiers thronging the Soviet
Congress on October 25th, the presidium was elected on the basis of
14 Bolsheviks, 7 Social-Revolutionaries, three Mensheviks and one
Internationalist. The Bolsheviks then trooped out their
worker-candidates Lenin, Trotsky, Kamenev, Zinoviev and so on. When
it came to forming a government, Kamenev read out a Bolshevik Central
Committee proposal for a Soviet of People's Commissars, whereby
"control over the activities of the government is vested in the
Congress of Soviets and its Central Executive Committee". Seven
Bolsheviks from the party's central committee were nominated, and
thus Lenin and Trotsky came to sit at the top, never having done a
day's work in their lives. The "workers' government" was now composed
of middle-class professional revolutionaries.
The Bolshevik party leadership at that time was composed of
well-educated militants, generally in their mid-thirties on average.
Most had some personal means, and thus no need to work, either
sustained by family wealth or party funds. Some took jobs to 'get
into industry' (an updating of the old Narodnik idea of going to the
people: this is still much copied by today's imitation Bolsheviks).
In their origins, the Bolsheviks ranged from the aristocratic, like
Chicherin, to the bureaucratic, like Lenin and Kollontai, via the
landed bourgeois (Smilga), the commercial bourgeois (Yoffe) and the
higher industrial bourgeois (Pyatakov). These were the sort of people
used to being a ruling class.
It was the Red Guard who peremptorily closed clown the Constituent
Assembly, the Western-style parliament. While the Assembly members
and the socialists (including some Bolsheviks) were shocked, the
population as a whole was completely indifferent to the end of
another talking-shop. The Red Guardist Trifonov had wanted to turn
the Red Guard into a militia under the control of the factory
committees that all workers would pass through. But after October the
Bolsheviks did not trust the Red Guard, as it was an armed force
independent of the party, and Lenin said that "the place for the best
workers is the factory." The workers in general used the Bolshevik
slogans, except the call for nationalisation, where workers were for
control by the factory committees. Even at the moment of revolution,
when the Bolsheviks were able to ride the waves, the conflict between
them and the workers was there in potential. In some other ways the
workers went further than the Bolsheviks. It was workers who were
insistent on the closure of all bourgeois papers, and compulsory
labour or expulsion for the bourgeois. But the party won the day: in
1916 the constitution of the new state was ratified with the words
"the party leads and dominates the entire apparatus of state." The
workers, for all their efforts, remained workers.