The
study of the death penalty in different states is important so that we
can see if the use of capital punishment is effective or not.
The fact that 38 states use the death penalty and 12 do not shows that
our country thinks it is an effective form of punishment. This page
will show the comparison of states with and with out the death penalty.
It will also show the methods of execution and statistics of how many wrongful
convictions and executions were taken place in the U.S.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
For more information on all states
click
here
These states use the death penalty
to deter homicide.
To some people the death penalty is
seen as a deterrent for crime. These people believe that when a pserosn
is put to death it will stope that criminal from killing again. Other people
that see this as a deterrent think that there should be an eye for and
eye to create closure for the victim's families.
On the other hand people see the death
penalty the opposite way. The think that the dath penalty is not a deterrent
because even if a sperson is put to deather there is still crime. These
people say that criminals don't stop and think about the consequences of
their actions so therefore the criminal still commits the crime. Some of
these people think that this system of punishment teaches using violence
to stop violence.
Both arguments are valid. Whether
capital punishment is a deterrent or not is a personal opinion.
Circumstances for use of the Death Penalty
Aggravating Factors
This chart shows the top five states
that use Capital Punishment and what crimes allow for the death penalty
to be an option.
A review of death penalty judgments
over a 23-year period found a national error rate of 68%. In a matter of
life and death, we are getting it wrong more than 2 out of every 3 times.
- Nationally, the overall rate of
reversible error found in capital sentences was 68% -- in other words,
in nearly seven out of every ten cases involving capital sentences, the
courts found error sufficiently prejudicial to reverse. The most common
errors, prompting the majority of the reversals, were ineffective assistance
of counsel and police or prosecutorial misconduct.
- Of the 68% of defendants whose
cases were reversed, 82% were found to deserve something less than death
when errors were cured on retrial; 7% were found to be innocent of the
capital crime.
- High error rates exist across
the country. More than nine out of 10 states with the death penalty have
overall error rates of 52% or higher; 85% of the states have error rates
of 60% or higher; three-fifths of the states have error rates of 70% or
higher.
These states were chosen because
they are the top states that use the death penalty.
The Useage of the Death penalty is more
prominant in the south because of the vast amount of crime in the
south
- Multiple killings
- Racial motivated killings
- Rape
- Other felonies
Circumstances used by different
states of the death penalty
murder of a public safety officer,
firefighter or correctional employee
murder during the commission of
specified felonies (kidnapping burglary robbery aggravated rape arson)
murder for remuneration
multiple murders
murder during a prison escape
murder by a state prison inmate
murder of an individual under eight
years old
murder during the commission or
attempts to commit specified felonies (abduction, armed robbery, rape,
sodomy)
contracted murder
murder by a prisoner while in custody
murder of a law enforcement officer
multiple murders
murder of a child under the age
of 12 during an abduction
murder arising from drug violations
murder sexual battery of a female
age 11 or under by a male 18 or older.
Allows it as an option in
first degree murder cases
murder with malice aforethought
murder arising from specified felonies
(forcible rape robbery with a dangerous weapon kidnapping escape from lawful
custody first degree burglary arson)
murder when the victim is a child
who has been injured tortured or maimed
*To see charts of States overall error rate
*click here
To get more information click
*Example
- South Carolina - 306 murders in 1998
- Minnisota - 121 murders in 1998
To see more data go to Crime
Rates (scroll down for all U.S. states statistics)
This is a map of the states that
use certain methods of execution
To see a chart of methods of execution click here
Links:
Court
T.V.
Justice
Policy
Clark
Prosecutor
Disaster
Center
ABC
News Death Penalty