From the 03 March 2008 Lockport Union Sun and Journal (Lockport, NY)
 

NO NEW TAXES. JUST BIGGER ONES.
By Bob Confer

Last week in the state capital the legislature and Governor Spitzer were arguing over what the budget deficit would be for fiscal year 2008-2009. This wasn’t quibbling over pennies; their differences were in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Spitzer believes the deficit will be $4.8 billion. The state assembly pegs the losses even greater at $5.1 billion. Although they couldn’t agree on the exact amount they made it known that they agreed on at least one thing: we’re in the red. Big time.

What would you do if you were in their shoes? Looking at how you manage your personal finances or those of your employer, you’d probably cut expenses. It’s illogical to live beyond your means. Sadly, that line of thought just doesn’t exist in Albany. Decreasing the size of government never really crossed their minds. Instead, their preferred means of beating the deficit is to find new revenues by taxing us even more.

But, didn’t Eliot Spitzer promise last November and again in January that he’d deliver no new taxes? He did, but, being a lawyer by trade he understands how to misuse language to suit his needs. He may have said no new taxes, but that doesn’t prevent him from making the current ones bigger, adding some new fees (which are really taxes anyways) or closing some "loopholes" which end up making the untaxable taxable.

Over the past four months the Spitzer administration, even to the chagrin of the tax-happy legislature, has devised numerous ploys to increase revenues through bigger taxes. Here are some of the things he wants to do:

Increase the Auto Insurance Surcharge: New York residents currently see a $5 surcharge (tax) on their auto insurance policy. The Governor wants to increase that beyond reason, up to $20 per year. Considering there are just under 12 million registered vehicles in the state, the new revenues would be $178.5 million. Playing the safety card, Spitzer says the funds will be used to further the development of NY Alert and to repair many of our 17,000 bridges. Those same news releases fail to tell us that $100 million of the insurance surcharges will be deposited into his Upstate Revitalization Fund, his $1 billion gimmick that starts from Square One – and Dollar Zero - this year.

Tax Internet Sales: Every day more and more people take up online shopping. For the smart shopper great deals can be had. In many cases the savings are magnified by the lack of sales taxes. If a business entity does not have a physical operation in NY, state sales taxes cannot be collected. At the end of the year NY residents, on an honor system, are supposed to record such purchases on their tax forms so the state can collect the tax from the consumer. Of course, many New Yorkers don’t record this, accounting for "only" $45 million in 2006. Spitzer wants to collect what’s been missing and would like to tax all online stores regardless of their location. His people believe they can rake in at least $100 million every year. If this passes other states will follow suit and the uniqueness that the Internet possesses as a tax-free haven will be gone.

Tax The Rich: "….the rich have more money than they need. A just tax structure would ensure that all taxpayers end up with equal spending after taxes." Eliot Spitzer said those disgusting words last fall. Regardless of one being rich or poor, who is the government to determine the amount of money people should need or have? To fulfill this fascist dream of his, Spitzer wants to adjust the income tax structure. Currently it is a graduated scale that goes from 4% to 6.85%. He wants to move the top end to around 8%.

Tax Subsidiaries: As it stands a company can do business with its out-of-state subsidiary and not be taxed on it because, after all, it’s just an intercompany transaction, a business doing business with itself. Spitzer wants to change this. Charging taxes on such transactions will allow Albany to rake in at least $215 million a year. That is, until some companies decide to leave because of it.

These four changes to the NYS tax structure are just a few of the many that Spitzer has proposed. He’s right…he’s not making any new taxes. But, he sure is trying to squeeze every last penny out of our residents and businesses with the taxes he does have. It’s unbelievable how much he’s let us down. He was elected on a mandate by the people to bring about change in New York. If anything, he’s only been changing it for the worse.

 

COMMENT ON THIS COLUMN HERE

RETURN TO  GREATER NIAGARA EDITORIALS