Does Man
Have a Free Will?
Can mankind really choose to be saved (i.e., accept Jesus as personal Savior)
in and of his/her own independent choice apart from God’s intervention? Or, can man choose any number of other things
in and of himself/herself?
Let’s allow God’s Word to answer these questions for us!
Foreknowledge and Foreknow (Gk. “prognosis” and “proginosko”).
1) On page 693 of The New International Dictionary of New Testament Theology, Vol. 1, by Dr. Colin Brown, it states that “foreknow” in Romans 8:29 and 11:2 means “to choose beforehand”.
2) On pages 1025 and 1026 of The New Bible Dictionary by Dr. J.D. Douglas, it states that “foreknowledge” is equated with fore-ordination (Acts 2:23), and that those people elected by God for salvation can only respond to the gospel because of the saving grace God gives them from eternity past, which is based on God’s choice alone and nothing to do with man or anything about the man.
3) On page 35 of Wuest’s Word Studies in the Greek New Testament, vol. 3, “Vocabulary”, Dr. Kenneth Wuest states that “foreknowledge”, when used of God, signifies more than merely the fact of knowing something beforehand, but of determining the destiny of someone (Acts 2:23; Rom. 8:29; 11:2; 1 Pet. 1:2).
4) On page 345 of The New Analytical Greek Lexicon by Dr. W.J. Perschbacher, it states that “foreknowledge” in Rom. 8:29 and 11:2 means “to appoint as the subjects of future privileges.”
5) On page 538 of Thayer’s Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, it states that “foreknowledge” means “prearrangement”.
6) On
page 183 of the Shorter Lexicon of the
Greek New Testament by Dr. F. Wilbur Gingrich, it states that
“foreknowledge” means to “choose beforehand” (Rom.
7) On page 342 of The Analytical Greek Lexicon Revised by H.K. Moulton, it states that “foreknowledge” in Rom. 8:29 and 11:2 means “to appoint as the subjects of future privileges.”
Rom.
Have you been foreknown by God? How do you know?
Rom. 11:2 What has God done to His people (i.e.,
How does knowing this about God
make you feel about God, and why?
Foreknowledge (Gk. “progno”).
Acts
Could Judas really have done anything other than
betray Jesus (Acts
1 Pet.
1:1, 2 What happened
according to the foreknowledge (eternal will and prearrangement) of God
the Father?
Are you chosen by God (for
salvation)? On what basis?
How do you know (clue in
Eph. 2:8, 9)?
Foreordain (Gk. “progin”).
1 Pet. 1:19-21 Who was foreknown (chosen
beforehand/predetermined to have a place as Messiah in the eternal counsel of
God) before the foundation of the world?
Do you think mankind’s fall
into sin took God by surprise? Why?
Predestinate (Gk. “proorizo”).
“Comes from the Greek words “horizo” meaning “to divide
or separate from, as a border or boundary, to mark out boundaries, to mark out,
to determine, appoint”; and “pro” meaning “before”. Thus, the compound word means “to determine
or appoint beforehand, to divide or separate from a border or boundary
beforehand.”
“The genius (distinctive characteristic) of the
word is that of placing limitations upon someone or something beforehand, these
limitations bringing that person or thing within the sphere of a certain future
or destiny. Thus the “predestined” ones
have limitations put around them which bring them within the sphere of becoming
God’s children by adoption (Eph. 1:5), and of being conformed to the
image of the Lord Jesus (Rom. 8:29)” – Wuest’s Word Studies in the
Greek New Testament, vol. 3, “Vocabulary”, p. 34.
“Proorizo” which the New Testament uses only with God as
subject, expresses the thought of appointing a situation for a person, or a
person for a situation, in advance.
“The Old Testament lacks words for expressing the idea
of predestination in an abstract or generalized form, but it often speaks of God
purposing, ordaining, or determining particular things, in contexts which call
attention to the absolute priority and independence of His purposing in
relation to the existence or occurrence of the thing purposed (Psa. 139:16;
Isa. 14:24-27; 19:17; 46:9-11; Jer. 49:20; Dan. 4:24f).”
“As God’s power is unlimited, so His purposes are
certain of fulfillment (Psa. 33:10f; Isa.
“He is Lord of every situation, ordering and directing
everything towards the end for which He made it (Prov. 16:4), and
determining every event, great or small, from the thoughts of kings (Prov.
21:1) and the premeditated words and deeds of men (Prov. 16:1, 9) to
the seemingly random fall of a lot (Prov. 16:33).”
“God planned present and future happenings long ago,
from the beginning (Isa. 22:11; 37:26; 44:6-8; 46:10f), and that, just
because it is He, and no one else, who orders all events (Isa. 44:7),
nothing can prevent the occurrence of the events that He has predicted (Isa.
14:24-27; 44:24 – 45:25; 1 Kings 22:17-31; Psa. 33:10f; Prov. 19:21; 21:30).”
“Sometimes God is pictured as reacting to
developing situations in a way that might seem to imply that He had not
anticipated them (i.e., when He repents and reverses the prior action, Gen.
6:6; Jer. 18:8, 10; 26:3, 13; Joel 2:13; Jonah 4:2). But in their biblical context, it is clear
that the purpose and point of these anthropomorphisms is simply to emphasize
that
That God governs human history to bring about His own predestined purpose is made clear as early as Gen. 3:15 with the prediction of Christ’s death and Satan’s defeat at the cross, and the promise to Abraham in Gen. 12:3. The theme develops through the wilderness promises of prosperity and protection in Canaan (Deut. 28:1-14) and the prophetic pictures of the Messianic glory which would succeed God’s work of judgment (Isa. 9:1ff; 11:1ff; Jer. 23:5ff; Ezek. 34:20ff; 37:21ff; Hosea 3:4f), and it reaches its climax in Daniel’s vision of God over-ruling the rise and fall of pagan world-empires in order to set up the rule of the Son of Man – Christ (Dan. 7, 8; 2:31-45).
God chose
The New Testament writers take for granted the Old
Testament belief that God is the sovereign Lord of events, and rules history
for the fulfilling of His purposes.
Their uniform insistence that Christ’s ministry and the Christian
dispensation represented the fulfillment of biblical prophecies, given
centuries before (Matt. 1:22; 2:15, 23; 4:14; 8:17; 12:17ff; Jn. 7:38ff;
19:24, 28, 36; Acts 2:17ff; 3:22ff; 4:25ff, 8:30ff; 10:43; 13:27ff; 15:15ff;
Gal. 3:8; Heb. 5:6; 8:8ff; 1 Pet. 1:10ff; etc.), and that God’s ultimate
aim in inspiring the Hebrew Scriptures was to instruct Christian believers (Rom.
15:4; 1 Cor. 10:11; 2 Tim. 3:15ff), is proof enough of this. (Both convictions, be it noted, derive
from our Lord Himself; cf. Lk. 18:31ff; 24:24ff; 44ff; Jn.
The
New Bible Dictionary, p. 1025.
Predestinate; Determine (Gk.
“proorizo”).
Rom.
If this is the case, and it is, then
is it possible for someone who is foreknown and predestined to become anything
other than conformed to Christ’s image? Why
(Dan.
Eph.
1:4, 5 In love, what
did God predestine these Ephesians to?
According to what?
Is this the basis you thought
that God predestined people (determined in advance who would be saved),
and why?
Eph.
And
what were they predestined according to?
Does this sound like the Ephesians had anything to do with their being predestined to adoption as sons and obtaining salvation and heaven, and why (vss. 4, 11)?
Acts
If these people did whatever God had predestined or determined for them to do ahead of time, then was there any choice in the matter as to what they could have done other than what they did? Any free will in their choice?
1 Cor.
2:2, 7, 8 When
was God’s hidden wisdom (Jesus’ Messiahship) predestined?
For what purpose was this
predestined?
Will
you receive this glory? How
do you know?
Acts
“The word “call” is used in Scripture with the following
significations: (1) In the sense of “to name,” “to designate” (Gen. 16:11;
Deut. 25:10), and in the sense of “to be, ” e.g.,
“His name will be called Wonderful Counselor” (Isa. 9:6); i.e., He will
be wonderful and so acknowledged. (2)
In the designation of individuals to some special office or work, as the call
of Bezalel (Ex. 31:2), of judges, prophets,
apostles, etc. (Isa.
(a)
Paul uses the words kaleo (29 times),
klesis (8 times) and kletos (7 times) almost always
with the sense of divine calling. Paul
understands calling as the process by which God calls those, whom he has
already elected and appointed, out of their bondage to this world, so that He
may justify and sanctify them (Rom. 8:29f), and bring them into His
service. This means that the call is
part of God’s work of reconciliation and peace (1 Cor.
(b)
Paul addresses church members as kletoi,
called ones (
Dictionary
of New Testament Theology, vol. 1, pp. 275, 276.
(Gk. “kaleo”) – to call anyone, invite, summon (i.e., Matt. 20:8; 25:14). It is used particularly of the Divine call to partake of the blessings of redemption.
Rom.
On what basis were you called (to
become a born-again Christian), if in fact you have been called?
Why that basis?
Rom.
How does knowing this make you
feel? Why?
How else is this same line of
reasoning stated as to why the older will serve the younger in verse 11?
Does this sound like man has a
free will?
1 Cor.
1:9 Through whom were these Corinthians called into fellowship with His
Son?
Through whom or what were you
called (summoned to partake of redemption) into fellowship with Christ?
How do you know?
1
Thes.
Into what have you been
called?
How does knowing this make you
feel about God?
Heb.
9:14, 15 What will these who have been called receive?
Are you planning on receiving
this? Why?
A
calling (Gk. “klesis”) – It
is always used in the New Testament of that “kaleo” calling, the origin, nature,
and destiny of which are heavenly (the idea of invitation being implied);
it is used especially of God’s invitation/summons to man to accept the benefits
of salvation.
Rom.
Does this sound like you have a choice as to whether God calls you or not? And if He does call you, whether you can change His mind? Are you glad He’s planned it this way? Why?
1 Cor.
[“wise” – worldly wise] [“mighty” – having power and authority] [“noble” – high rank in society]
What category person are you? And have
you been called by God?
Eph.
Do you (fully, really) know
what the hope of God’s calling is for you, if you’ve been called, that is? If so, what?
2
Thes.
Will God be able to count you
worthy of His calling you? How do you
know?
2 Pet.
1:5-10 What are these Christians (and us, for that matter) to
be all the more diligent about?
How would they be able to do
this?
Are you certain about God’s
calling of you? How do
you know?
2 Tim.
1:8, 9 How
had and how hadn’t God called these (Christians) people to salvation?
On what basis do you think you
were called?
Called;
Invited (Gk. “kletos”) – Used of an effectual (effective in
producing the desired result) call, in the following passages:
Rom. 1:4-7 Among whom were these Roman Christians
also the called (effectually called, which is the work of the Spirit of God
in efficacious grace whereby saving faith toward Christ is created in the
individual) of Jesus Christ?
How does Paul describe these in
Are you beloved by God and called as a saint? How do you know?
Rom.
How does knowing this affect
you, and why?
1 Cor.
1:2 What is
Christ to the called, of both Jew and Gentile?
1 Cor.
1:23, 24 What
is Christ to the called, of both Jew and Gentile?
What is Christ to you? Why?
Jude
1:1 What does
it say about those who are the called?
From this passage as well as
Rom. 1:6, 7 and 1 Cor. 1:2, who are “the called” always referring to?
So, if someone is called, what
does that mean will happen to him or her?
– Used of an appointment to apostleship (
Election (Gk. “eklego”).
It expresses that a part has been claimed from a greater
quantity, by an independent act of decision for a particular purpose, and that
the remainder has been passed over.
It denotes a picking out, selection, that which is
chosen.
Divine election refers to the act of God in which He
chooses out certain from among mankind for salvation. The main import is that of appointment (for
a certain object or goal – Jn.
A new development, however, is that the idea of
election, now applied, not to national Israel, but to Christian believers, is
consistently individualized (cf. Psa. 65:4) and given a pre-temporal (before
the world) reference. The Old
Testament assimilates/compares election to God’s historical “calling” (cf.
Neh. 9:7), but the New Testament distinguishes the two things (pre-creation
and a point in history) sharply, by representing election as God’s act of
predestinating sinners to salvation in Christ “before the foundation of the
world” (Eph. 1:4; cf. Matt. 25:34; 2 Tim. 1:9); an act correlative (mutually
related) to His foreknowing Christ before the foundation of the world (1
Pet. 1:20). The uniform New
Testament conception is that all saving grace given to men in time (knowledge
of the gospel, understanding of it and power to respond to it, preservation,
and final glory) flows from divine election in eternity.
Luke’s language in the narrative of Acts bears striking
witness to his belief, not merely that Christ was foreordained to die, rise,
and reign (Acts 2:23, 30f; 3:20; 4:27f), but that salvation is the fruit
of prevenient (preceding human action) grace – 2:47; 11:18, 21-23;
14:27; 15:7ff; 16:14; 18:27 – given in accordance with divine foreordination (13:48;
18:10).
In John’s Gospel, Christ says that He has been sent to
save a number of particular individuals whom His Father has “given” Him (Jn.
6:37ff; 17:2, 6, 9, 24; 18:9). These
are His “sheep”, His “own” (
The fullest elucidation/explanation of this principle is
found in the writings of Paul. From all
eternity, Paul declares, God has had a purpose/plan (Gk. “prothesis”) to
save a Church, though in earlier times it was not fully made known (Eph.
3:3-11). The aim of the purpose/plan
is that men should be made God’s adopted sons and be renewed in the image of
Christ (Rom.
It has been argued that God’s foreknowledge (choosing
beforehand) is not foreordination (predetermination), and that personal
election in the New Testament is grounded upon God’s foresight that the persons
chosen will respond to the gospel of themselves. The difficulties in this view seem to be: (1)
this asserts, in effect, election according to works and desert/merit; whereas,
Scripture asserts election to be of grace (Rom. 9:11; 2 Tim. 1:9), and
grace excludes all regard to what a man does for himself (Rom. 4:4; 11:6;
Eph. 2:8f; Titus 3:5); (2) if election is unto faith (2 Thes. 2:13)
and good works (Eph. 2:10), it cannot rest upon foresight of these
things; (3) on this view, Paul ought to be pointing, not to God’s election, but
to the Christian’s own faith, as the ground of his assurance of final
salvation; (4) Scripture does appear to equate foreknowledge with foreordination
(cf. Acts 2:23).
“Reprobate” appears first in Jer.
The
New Bible Dictionary, p. 1025.
The act of choice whereby God picks an individual
or group out of a larger company for a purpose or destiny of His own
appointment.
The complete theological development of the idea of
election is found in Paul’s Epistles (see especially Rom. 8:28 – 11:36; Eph.
1:3-14; 1 Thes. 1:2-10; 2 Thes. 2:13, 14; 2 Tim. 1:9, 10). Paul presents divine election as God’s
gracious, sovereign, eternal choice of individual sinners to be saved and
glorified in and through Christ.
A. Election
is a gracious choice. “The
election of grace” (Rom. 11:5; cf. 2 Tim. 1:9) is an act of undeserved
favor freely shown towards members of a fallen race to which God owed nothing
but wrath (
B. Election
is a sovereign choice, prompted by God’s own good pleasure alone (Eph.
1:5, 9), and not by any works of man, either accomplished or foreseen (Rom.
C. Election
is an eternal choice. God chose
us, says Paul, “before the foundation of the world” (Eph. 1:4; 2 Thes.
D. Election
is God’s choice of individual sinners to be saved in and through Christ. Election is “in Christ” (see Eph. 1:4),
the incarnate Son, whose historical appearing and mediation were themselves
included in God’s eternal plan (1 Pet.
Paul finds in the believer’s knowledge of his election a
threefold religious significance.
A. It
shows him that his salvation, from beginning to end, is all of God, a fruit of
sovereign discriminating/selective mercy.
The redemption which he finds in Christ alone and receives by faith
alone has its source, not in any personal qualification, but in grace/undeserved
favor alone – the grace of election.
Every spiritual blessing flows to him from
God’s electing decree (Eph. 1:3ff).
The knowledge of his election, therefore, should teach him to glory/boast
in God, and God only (1 Cor.
B. It
assures the believer of his eternal security, and removes all grounds for fear
and despondency. If he is in grace now,
he is in grace/undeserved favor forever.
Nothing can affect his justified/declared righteous status (
C. It
spurs the believer to ethical endeavor.
So far from sanctioning license/sin (cf. Eph. 5:5f) or
presumption/pride (cf. Rom. 11:19-22), the knowledge of one’s election
and the benefits that flow from it is the supreme incentive to humble, joyful,
thankful love, the mainspring of sanctifying/holy gratitude (Col. 3:12-17).
The
New Bible Dictionary, pp. 357-361.
Laid out, Chosen, Choice (Gk. “eklektos”).
Matt. 24:22 What will happen during the tribulation of the end time (the
seven years before Christ’s Second Coming, Dan. 9:27, especially the last 42
months, Rev. 11:2; 12:6; 13:5) for the sake of the elect (those chosen
by God to be saved, given eternal life, before they were ever born, and caused
by the Holy Spirit to believe in Christ for salvation – Acts 13:48; 2 Thes.
2:13; Eph. 1:4-6; 2:8; Rom. 9:11, 16)?
How do you feel about God
doing this for the elect? Why?
Matt.
24:23, 24 What
will happen so as to mislead, if possible, even the elect?
Do you have the discernment
and knowledge of the Bible so as not be fooled?
If you’re not sure or your
answer is no, what could you do so as to be able to say yes?
Matt.
24:29-31 What will God send forth His angels to do after the
tribulation?
What do you visualize as you
dwell on what this may look like? Why?
Rom.
If you are one of God’s elect,
how does knowing this make you feel, and why?
Comes from the Greek words “lego”
meaning “to choose” and “ek” meaning “out from”. Thus, the compound word means “to pick,
single out, or to choose out.” The
genius (distinguishing characteristic) of the word has in it the idea of
not merely choosing, but that of choosing out from a number.
The adjective “eklektos” comes
from “eklegomai” and is translated by the words
“chosen” and “elect”. The elect are the
chosen-out ones.
Wuest’s
Word Studies in the Greek New Testament, vol. 3, “Vocabulary”, p. 34.
Chosen (Heb. from “bachur”; Gk. “eklektos”) means –
Singled out from others for some special service
or station. “Warriors”, Ex.
15:4; Judges 20:16; “Israelites”, a chosen people, God having set them apart to
receive His word and maintain His worship, Psa. 105:43; Deut. 7:6, 7; “Christ”,
Isa. 42:1, to be the Savior of mankind; “the apostles”, to be witnesses of the
resurrection, Acts 10:41.
Accepted (Matt.
Choose (Gk. “haireo”) –
taking for oneself (2 Thes.
(Gk. “eklektos” –
verb).
Matt. 22:14 Though many are called (invited to salvation upon hearing the
gospel message, but who don’t respond), how many are chosen (picked from
eternity to inherit life everlasting or salvation not based on human
accomplishment or free choice, but on God’s sovereign grace and selection –
Eph. 1:4; John 6:39, 44, 65; Rom. 9:11, 16)? Are
you among these few? How
do you know?
Col.
3:12 How are
these Christians at
How does God think of you? Why?
2 Tim.
For whom are you willing to
endure hardship, and why?
Titus
1:1 For what
was Paul a bond-servant of God and an apostle of Jesus Christ?
For what are you a
bond-servant? And why?
1 Pet.
1:1, 2 What happened
according to the foreknowledge (the eternal will and choice) of God the
Father?
According to what and by what
were you chosen?
How do you know?
1 Pet.
2:9 For what
were these Christians chosen?
Are you doing this? Why?
(Gk. “eklektos” – adjective) – meaning eminent (Rom.
– meaning selected to
persevere and remain standing; not fall to sin – Jude 1:6 (1 Tim.
(Gk. “eklege” – noun) – choice, selection.
Acts
Are you a chosen instrument of
God? If
so, in what way or for what?
Rom.
Have you come to the conclusion that God desires to be recognized for what happens in this world as being a result of His choice rather than ours? Why?
Rom. 11:5 What had come to be at their present time (at the time Paul
wrote this letter), according to God’s gracious choice?
Do you view God’s choice as
being gracious or as being unfair? Why?
What
does it say about
Does this sound like those who
weren’t chosen had any chance or choice of their own
to obtain salvation? Why?
From the standpoint of God’s
choice, how does He view
Does this sound like we or
they can change what God has planned or decided from the past ages?
Why (Dan.
1
Thes. 1:2-4 What do Paul,
Silvanus and Timothy know about these Thessalonians and so give thanks?
Do you give thanks for those
whom God has chosen for salvation, and why?
2 Pet. 1:5-10 Why were they to make certain about God’s calling (being
invited to participate in salvation) and choosing (picking certain ones
out for salvation) them?
Are you making certain of this
for your life? What
have you decided? Why?
Acts
Acts
Eph. 1:5, 9, 11 –
Heb. 6:17, 18 –
Rom.
Heb. 2:4 –
James
Col. 1:25-27 –
Matt. 11:25, 26 –
Luke
Gal. 1:15, 16 –
Col.
Prov. 16:4 –
Isa. 46:10 –