Michegan Fish-In (the veiw is changing)
Carp get a hard time in most parts of the U.S. many states veiw carp as simply a rough ,trash fish, taking up space for the more disirables. But,this veiw seems to be changing slowly . Here is a write up seen from a local T.V station's unbiased veiwpoint.Well known T.V host fred trost made a show to go on -air with this one.
CARPING -- LET'S GIVE IT SOME RESPECT (11:59 am)
Anglers who espouse catch and release should put the carp back on their
list of respectable game fish. Yesterday's video-taping of a carp fishing
contest at Kent Lake was great. The anglers were primarily members of the
Carp Anglers Group, an organization originally formed by a Dr. Keyes from
Chicago. CAG has about 300 members nationally, with some members in Europe.
The Michigan group, spearheaded by Gary Gillis and Tom Feeny, chummed the
area with 600 pounds of corn during the past two weeks, and as schools of
carp would move through, "electronic bite alarms" would sound and rods
would bend. The fish ranged from five to twenty pounds, and the battles
were meritorious.
Many of the anglers were trout and steelhead fishermen, and some
specialized in bass. They tended to be proponents of catch and release, so
the battle of a carp stood on its own in their world of fishing. Carp
fishing is not such a simple task as you might think. Much of the
specialized carp-fishing equipment comes from Europe, and is not widely
available in this country. I am told that Grand River Bait & Tackle in
Lansing has an array. I'll have to drop in sometime this week to see what
they have in stock. I'll be looking for things like baskets,
monkey-climbers, hair rigs, and bait needles. There are rods for carp
fishing, and spinning reels with anti-reverse features designed for
carping.
Both John Ford and I were impressed with the potential of carping. It's
time for American anglers to wake up and take advantage of this
highly-available urban fishing activity. If we want to get kids and
newcomers into fishing, there's no better way to start them than with
carping. They're found in most every lake or river in southern Michigan,
from muddy ponds to crystal clear lakes. Carp are big, they fight hard, and
even a five pounder is a thrill for a new angler. Specialized equipment is
not necessary to catch carp, nor is necessary to have special bait. There's
nothing cleaner than fishing with canned corn which is available at every
grocery store or Seven-Eleven. You don't have to get up before dawn to
catch carp. They're big fish, they have to eat a lot, and they tend to bite
all day long. Carp fishing is the most accessible, easiest to reach, and
quickest-to-find fishing that we have. It's perfectly suited for our
couch-potato society that doesn't want to spend much time, money or effort
doing things that don't involve a video screen. Carp fishing can be done at
any picnic that's near a body of water. It's perfect for rekindling
people's interest in fishing.
One thing is missing from carping, though. Few fishermen eat the carp they
catch. There are two major reasons for this:
1) carp have never been recognized as a desirable food fish in this
country, and the disdain for carp meat is largely sociological; and
2) public health warnings put carp at the top of the list of fish that
may have an overabundance of toxic chemicals in their fat.
But, if an angler is satisfied with catch-and-release, as many trout and
bass fishermen are, why not add carp to the list of desirable hook-and-line
fish? Catching a big one is an accomplishment. Aside from the social status
attributed to various species, it's as much fun to catch a big carp as it
is to catch any large game fish. Many times I've seen anglers excited about
the trophy at the end of their line, anticipating a big trout, pike, musky
or salmon. When the fish shows itself, and the angler learns it's a carp,
they get upset. Why? The fight told them the fish was a trophy. Their
social attitudes told them it wasn't. Is that logical?
I was impressed with the physical quality of the carp in Kent Lake. They
were actually quite pretty fish, clean, sleek, and shiny. None that I saw
had any blemishes, fungus, bacterial growths, tumors, or the kinds of
reddish, unpleasant growths that we often see on warmwater fish in the
summer. For the first time in my life, I looked at a carp as a
fine-looking, hard-fighting game fish. It seemed logical to see the anglers
handle these fish gently, returning them to the water to grow, and fight
again for another angler.
Another real joy of the Carp Anglers Group was the international flavor of
the carpers. There were a number of fishermen from Canada, whose roots were
in England or Australia. These guys were fun! They not only had the
specialized equipment, but they had the lingo to go with it. I asked one
fellow, as he was battling a big carp, if he was upset at the demise of the
Spice Girls. He said something like, "If I were 20 years younger, and
didn't have a big carp on, maybe I'd be alarmed. But I really don't care."
In a week or so we'll post a full transcript of my conversations with these
anglers on this site. It's very interesting.
I will put a small excerpt from this taping on the show this week, but the
main features will appear next TV season. And you can expect increased
coverage of carp fishing next year, as well. I met several anglers who fly
fish for carp! They have been using stonefly imitations to hook and land
some big ones, from Lake Michigan shorelines to the Grand River. You say
carp aren't game fish? You need an attitude adjustment. In the world of
catch and release, I can't see any reason why carp aren't ranked with the
rest of the species.
I also believe that after years of discrimination, the carp may emerge as
one of the species that rejuvenates fishing in urban America. The carp
doesn't have to change, we do. And the change is an easy one -- we only
need to change our attitudes, which we have full control over. Those who
change will enjoy carping. The others will do their carping on the couch.
Too bad. There's some fun fishing awaiting us out there. I'm going to get
into it. There's no reason not to.
Press your Back button for more carpy stories