What's New
 Colet and
  What Music?
Banned Books
About Me
 Hosted By:
Ex Libris
Green Man
Video Vista
Designed for
 1024 X 768
 and Internet
Craig's Book Club
Book Reviews

Spotlight on: the Disaster series of mysteries by Max Allan Collins

Books Reviewed:
The Titanic Murders (Jacques Futrelle) by Max Allan Collins
The War of the Worlds Murder (Walter Gibson) by Max Allan Collins

To arrange to have products considered for review, send an email to craigsbookclub@yahoo.com.

The Titanic Murders by Max Allan Collins Max Allan Collins, The Titanic Murders

Inspired by a story reportedly told to him by Jacques Futrelle's daughter, Max Allan Collins once again makes a mystery out of history with The Titanic Murders. Futrelle, the author of the Thinking Machine mysteries featuring the Holmesian professor Augustus S.F.X. Van Dusen (Futrelle was also referred to as the American Conan Doyle), died after the sinking of the Titanic, so he was the perfect sleuth for this first of Collins's "disaster" series of mysteries centering on real-life tragedies. In this case, the finding of two bodies in the Titanic's cold-storage compartment is the catalyst that moves the story.

Fans of the movie Titanic who pick this up may be disappointed by the lack of a love story other than the one between the happily married Futrelles. Also, the pacing of The Titanic Murders isn't what it could have been. But what can you expect from a novel that takes place entirely onboard an ocean liner?

The Titanic Murders is certainly not the best book in Collins's library, but fans of cozies and locked-room conundrums should especially enjoy this visit back to the early twentieth century, and it will hopefully gather more fans for Jacques Futrelle, a sorely underappreciated mystery writer.

The War of the Worlds Murder by Max Allan Collins Max Allan Collins, The War of the Worlds Murder

Max Allan Collins' historical mysteries are some of the best reading available. His Nathan Heller series has been nominated nine times for the Shamus award (winning twice, for True Detective and Stolen Away) and his "disaster" series has received similar acclaim, with was also nominated for the Shamus). Mysteries are often considered fluff writing, but Collins mixes fact and fiction in a way that is irresistible to those of us who like a little grit in our meringue.

The War of the Worlds Murder is the sixth in the Collins' "disaster" series, and it continues the series on a slightly different note. It is both less "disastrous" than previous entries and slightly less effective. But that doesn't keep it from being fascinating reading, especially to such a rabid fan of Orson Welles, the Shadow, and old-time radio as myself.

This War of the Worlds does not focus on the H.G. Wells novel (although it was undoubtedly released to coincide with the recent film adaptation). It instead features the 1938 Mercury Theatre radio presentation that "panicked America."

Collins introduces the novel, much like the Orson Welles film F for Fake, with the assertion that what follows is true -- the result of a conversation with Walter Gibson in 1975. (Gibson created the Shadow, authored over 230 novels featuring the character, and was the person who recommended Welles the young actor for the role on radio.)

However, also like F for Fake, he abandons this tactic once we are well and truly hooked, introducting a fictional murder into the proceedings. (Welles' mistress, or one of them, is murdered in CBS studios on the night of the broadcast and it is up to pulp writer Gibson, in town to assist Welles on a Shadow film project that never materialized, to solve the crime.)

Unfortunately, it is the murder that is the weak point in what is otherwise a fascinating portrait of an important incident in entertainment history -- it plays little or no role other than slightly enhancing the storyline. It is the real story of the events on the night of October 30, 1938, that keep the reader turning pages: showing the famous War of the Worlds broadcast from behind the scenes (from Gibson's point of view primarily) and how the radio play affected those millions of listeners who tuned in late and missed the opening announcement. By the time they switched from the popular Edgar Bergen and Charlie McCarthy program (once Nelson Eddy began singing), the Mercury play and the "Martian invasion" were well underway.

Max Allan Collins puts a lot of research in his work and often comes up with surprising, heretofore unknown facts. After all, who knew that Judy Holliday (who would later win an Oscar for her portrayal of not-so-dumb blonde Billie Dawn in Born Yesterday) was an office assistant at CBS studios back in 1938, subject to abuse from Welles' Mercury Theatre partner, John Houseman? I didn't. (Interestingly, as Welles' career was coming to an embarrassing close, Houseman's second career was just taking off due to his own Oscar-winning performance in The Paper Chase.) This use of facts brings further enjoyment to The War of the Worlds Murder, and offers a further example why I'll pick up a Max Allan Collins novel over any other.

Click on the links above to purchase any of the books mentioned, or use the search box below to find what you like.

In Association with Amazon.com

(Email me and let me know what you think.)

The Readers Ring
This Readers Ring site is owned by
Craig Clarke
Want to join the ring? Get the info here
The Readers Ring Page
[Prev 5] [Prev] [Next] [Next 5] [Random] [List Sites]