Yuffie: "You spikey-headed jerk! One more time, let's go one more time!"
You say: Not Interested.
Talk to her again.
Yuffie: "You're pretty scared of me, huh!?"
You say: ......Petrified.
She'll start to walk away but...
Yuffie: "I'm really gonna leave! REALLY!!"
You Say: Wait a second!
Yuffie: "You want me to go with you?"
You Say: That's right.
Yuffie: "All right! I'll go with you!"
You say: ......Let's hurry on.
Name her whatever and there you go. You now have Yuffie in your team!