Guidelines

Up

Drak's guidelines for the Workshop:

Definitely Trek
Preferably J/C
Any age. Old, new, beta stage, whatever as long as it is finished.
Can be NC-17, but you will have fewer reviewers

Bucky's rules for feedback happiness:

ALWAYS find something good to say, and make that your first comment [even if it's only 'nice font!':-)]. 
If you're confused about something, say so. Be specific. Cite specific paragraphs, sentences, whatever.
Be gentle. The idea is to encourage.
If you like something, even if it's just a word or a phrase, say so. 
Limit criticism to one or two areas where you think the story can be improved. IE, don't overwhelm the author. Be gentle. The idea is to encourage.
Be specific. "I loved it" is great for the ego, but no help in improving the story.
But again. Be gentle. The idea is to encourage.
Did I mention that beta's should be gentle?
Close with a positive comment.