BACK TO MALAYSIA & HUMAN RIGHTS HOMEPAGE
BACK TO MADPET HOMEPAGE

Wednesday
Proposal to abolish the death penalty: Still hung on capital punishment
ALYSSA WONG
KUALA LUMPUR, March 21(MALAY MAIL)
The death penalty should not be abolished for major crimes as it serves as a deterrent.

A street poll by The Malay Mail yesterday showed a consensus on this.

Many feel that without the death penalty, the rate of serious crimes will soar.

They were commenting on Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Seri Nazri Aziz’s statement that the Bar Council’s proposal to abolish the death sentence was worth looking into.

Here are the views of some of those interviewed:

- HAMZAH KAMAR, 61, retired Assistant Superintendant of Police, Kuala Lumpur:

"I do not agree with the idea of abolishing the death penalty as it serves as a deterrent to those intending to commit serious crimes like murder.

"The absence of capital punishment will only encourage a person to kill another. To me, it’s simple.

"If you take someone’s life, you pay back with your own. I don’t think it (capital punishment) is cruel, it is justice!"

- EDMOND WEE, 45, marketing manager, Kuala Lumpur:

"I disagree with the proposal. The death sentence is a punishment to ensure justice. Without the death penalty, our society would be unstable. People will think they can get away with anything.

"I believe in punishment meted out after several stages of judgment and based on evidence. That’s good enough.

"However, by doing away with capital punishment, victims like Canny Ong will have no justice! By skinning a few cats, it will certainly serve as a deterrent, and reduce the crime rate."

- MOHD FAROUK ESHAK, 31, policeman from Cheras:

"I disagree. I think the death penalty serves as a deterrent against serious crimes. For example, if drug smugglers are not given the death sentence, the matter would have got worst.

"There have been many cases where criminals were released from jail after a few years only to commit more serious crimes."

- RATHIKGA GUNALAN, 24, bank clerk, Kuala Lumpur:

"I am not happy with it. I think the death sentence should stay. As women, we are afraid that without the death penalty, we will not be protected.

"We read in the newspapers daily of women being raped and murdered. There is no justice at all, if the criminal just gets away with mere imprisonment. If they do it, they should pay for it!"

- NURUL AKMA ABD RAHIM, 29, assistant manager, Kuala Lumpur:

"They should not abolish it. Without the death sentence, criminals can just get away easily.

"Death sentence is a must for serious crimes. At least, criminals will think twice before they commit a serious crime like murder.

"I feel that a five-year jail term for a rapist is way too lenient."

- ROBERT ONG, 55, a retiree, Kuala Lumpur:

"I disagree with the proposal. We must have the death penalty in our country.

"Our country is unlike advanced countries, and I think that ours is not that stable yet. Even the United States still has the death sentence as capital punishment.

"We do not want any more rape and murder victims like Canny Ong. They have to pay for what they did, and only the death penalty is a deterrent to serious crimes."

- SUSAN YIN, 42, administrative officer, from Kuala Lumpur:

"No, I don’t agree with the idea. People who murder and smuggle dangerous drugs should not just get away so easily.

They should be given the death sentence to prevent similar crimes.

"I understand that the death penalty might sound cruel, but if left unchecked, they will commit more crimes. With the law in place now, everything is fine."