Here is a letter I recieved from Sandra on November 15, 1997.Jacob was five months old at this time, so the behavior is largely due to instinct.

November 15, 1997

Jacob is nowfairly consistent with responding to a call back when he takes off aftersomething. His tendency is usually to want to gather, but yesterday, Steve madepretty good progress with a situation that required driving. The cows hadgotten out of their fence (a short in the electric fence made it too weak to stopthem). He went to get them and of course Jacob went along. He would get thecows pointed in the right direction and start driving them back to thepasture, and Jacob would run around in front of or beside the cows and bark, drivingthem back the way they had come. Steve was about to lose it after the thirdtime, but he finally managed to convince Jacob to stay beside him, and itworkedvery well.

This morning, the cows were out again (fence not fixed yet, although it is now!), and Steve again went out to get them. This time,when Steve told Jacob to stay with him, he was very cooperative and it wentoff without a hitch.

He still does not "herd" in the sense that we can ask him to bring the animals, but he will block avenues of escape when we are trying to catchan animal and he often will come into the pasture and corner an animal forus that he observes us trying to catch. He doesn't always do helpfulthings, but he is usually pretty easy to call off if he is just in the way. I have been surprised at his sense for how young he is.

Guardian Behavior

February 20, 1998
Here is another letter I received from Sandra illustrating Jacob's guardian behavior. Jacob is eight months old at this time.


I am so delighted with what I am seeing this week. If there was anydoubt left in my mind about the fact that Jacob is truly both guard andherder, there is none left now. Last week, he was rounding up yearlings. This week he is cuddling babies, and in his glory. He has been on aperpetual high all week. Before, if there was something unusual to bark at, orhawks to chase off, he did it as if it was all part of the fun. This week,he is in dead earnest about these things. He spends his days hovering aroundbaby goats, cleaning up after them (he's a MALE, acting like a motherdog with puppies!), sleeping with them, but never letting up on hisvigilant guard. Even Lady and Jenny are suspect, although he is relaxing alittle about them (Lady even slept in with the babies last night). I haveneverseen anything so sweet as this big, masculine-looking dog hopelessly in love with a bunch of baby goats.

Now, for the million-dollar question. What happens when this batch of babies gets big enough to herd? Will they move if they aren't afraidof him, or will he resort to feet nipping to make them? I'll let you knowwhen I find out.


Sandra later wrote to say that the goats were growing up knowing to mind Jacob.

At about this time, Steve and Sandra moved to Texas from Pennsylvania, and took their best goats with them. Jacob protested vehemently when they sold the young goats before the relocation, but the hardest part was getting a new territory and new cows. When the bew cow first came, Jacob did not know where she belonged and thought she was a strange intruder and maybe he should run her off. This set back his progress in the cow herding department.

Hunting vs Guarding

July 9, 1998

We had a few incidents with Jacob yesterday that are leaving me a bit puzzled as to how I should react and what direction the training should take. Here is what happened: Yesterday afternoon, all three dogs tookoff out of the yard barking. A few moments later, I heard one of our guinea keets making some loud distress noises, and I ran outside, thinking ithad gotten out and maybe the dogs were hurting it. The collies were standing back watching and Jacob was actively going into the bushes after it. He was standing in one spot barking repeatedly. I looked into the bushes,and sure enough, inches from his nose was the guinea keet. He had trapped it against the fence. I retrieved it and Jacob got very excited, running circles around me and leaping around snapping at it. I corrected him and told him "GENTLE!", holding the keet up to him to sniff at it but making sure he didn't bite it. He didn't want to sniff at it and kept up the excited act until I put the guinea back in the pen. I was puzzled since Jacob is usually a very calm and gentlemanly sort of dog. Leaping around wildly is not typical at all.

Late that night, we again heard a guinea distress call. We took a flashlight and went out to investigate. Once again, the collies were watching as Jacob was going up and down the length of a dense thicket of long neglected rose bushes that was a thick tangle of intertwiningthorns. I watched him for a moment and then told him to find the guinea. He searched for awhile along the edge until he was satisfied that he was close, and then started to inch his way into the middle of that horrible tangle of thorns. A minute or two later, he gave a few soft, muffled barks. I shone my flashlight into the bush where he was, and there wasthe keet, not three inches from his nose. I retrieved it, and once again he started the hyper act, running around and leaping into the air, snappingat it. I corrected him again, holding the keet down for him to sniff andlook at, but he turned his head away (apparently the temptation to snap at it was too much!). When I threw it back in the pen, he had a very alert attitude at the side of the pen, almost like a hunting stance, as he watched the bird go back to the flock.

Here is my dilemma: Is he exhibiting hunting or herding behavior? Idon't think his intention was to kill the birds, or he could easily have doneso both times in the bush. Of course, even if it is herding behavior, asnap at a baby bird is not quite the same as a snap at the heels of a goat!How I correct his behavior really depends on his intention and what is motivating his behavior.

I would really appreciate any insights fromthose of you who are familiar with working dog behavior, especially any whohave experience in using dogs with poultry.


July 10, 1998
Here's a strange one for you. Jacob has somehow turned his "hunting" behavior into appropriate livestock care behavior. Last night, my boys were rounding up some errant guineas and Jacob (with Jenny,who joined him) helped them corner the birds. This morning, I heard him give a series of short sharp barks. Steve went out and Jacob had rounded up a guinea and brought it tothe house, "pinning" it against the wall of the house and holding it therewaiting for somebody to come and pick it up. He still doesn't like them, but apparently he has figured out that we do. ;-)

This whole incident is really pretty funny, when I think about how worried I was about appropriate "training" for him in this situation. It's a nice development to have the dog figure the situation out for himself!


July 11, 1998

Jacob has decided that the birds are his responsibility now. He was with me tonight while I was working on their pen. When Lady walked up, he growled a warning at her, just like he does when he is stating his exclusive right to the baby goats. This afternoon, he helped round up the guineas and escaped chicks, hopefully for the last time! One guinea took off across the field and he went after it. I held my breath, sure that he would involuntarily kill it in trying to catch it. He gave a big lunge and caught the keet's wingtip between his teeth, and then he firmly planted his foot on it, holding it there till I came and picked it up. It was totally unhurt. I have seen Jenny do that with full-grown chickens before when we were rounding them up, but it was really interesting to see it done on a baby bird, without hurting it at all. I have a feeling we won't have too much trouble when we release our guineas, except maybe to convince Jacob that they don't belong in the pen anymore.

I still can hardly believe that Jacob is OUR dog. I have always been of the opinion that dogs like that belonged to other people.

From: Steve Niedrauer


We had a real breakthrough with Jacob today when it comes to cows. About time, eh? He has been behaving better, but once in awhile he still frustrates my husband almost to death because he doesn't seem to be able to get the hang of moving the cows in the right direction. He makes them too wild and they almost always get away from him.

Today, my son rode his bike over to the other side of the farm where we are having some building done. The workers had dismantled part of the cattle fence and when my son rode up, the cows were all out. When they saw him, they bolted for the woods (smart cows!). Jacob, who was with him, took off after them. However, this time his running was purposeful. He bunched up a few of them and herded them back into the pasture and then went back for two more that had scattered. He got one of them and drove her back into the pasture and went back for the last one. She thought she had outsmarted him by jumping into our two-acre pond in the middle of the woods. She swam out into the middle, but Jacob didn't hesitate. He jumped into the water after her and swam around behind. It worked. He got her out of the pond and drove her back where she belonged. All this while my son sat and did nothing but look on with great interest.

I don't know if this incident will result in Jacob being cured forever of being too wild around the cows, but it sure proved that when push comes to shove, he's very capable of behaving like he should.Sandra

A few weeks ago, Jacob figured out how to move the cows on his own. Today, the cows were out because somebody knocked down the fence. The cows were scattered through the woods, so Steve and my son David took Jacob over there to try and track them down. Jenny heard the commotion and ran clear across the farm to go join them and help. Jacob understood what Steve wanted and he and Jenny put all the cows back! What a thrill. It took him till he was two years old, but he's got it. We have yet to do any real herding training. One thing and another keeps coming up to stop us before we get fairly started. It has been discouraging, but it's pretty neat to see him figuring it out in spite of us!


September 30, 2000

We had some excitement yesterday. Our Beef Shorthorn cow had a calf a few weeks ago, but it is so wild, we couldn't get close enough to see if it is a bull or a heifer. My 14 year old son David decided yesterday to go out to the pasture and rope the calf so he could find out the sex. Not having a horse, he went out there to rope the calf on foot, taking Jacob (our male farm collie) out there to help him. He was alone, and everyone else was occupied, so when he ran into trouble, there was nobody there to help him but Jacob.

He had no trouble roping the calf, but he hadn't counted on Martha, the momma cow, who has HORNS. She heard the calf bawling, saw the rope, and went ballistic. She charged David, who was afraid to let go of the rope for fear the calf would take off and get hung up somewhere. He tried to get out of her way while still hanging on the the rope, but with a fighting calf on the other end he couldn't move quickly enough. At that moment, Jacob quite possibly saved his life. He darted in between David and the charging cow, and lunged at her face, snapping and snarling. Martha stopped her charge and backed off, bawling.

David grabbed up a fiberglass fencepost and tried to drive her further back so he could get close enough to the calf to get the rope off its neck. Talk about an angry momma! Jacob went after her again and kept her distracted while David tried again to get close to the calf. This went on for half an hour, until the calf gave up and lay down. By this time, Molly had heard the commotion and had run out to join Jacob, and the two of them kept Martha busy long enough for David to run up to the calf, get the rope off its neck, find out it was a bull! A happy ending to what could have been a tragic story.

I don't think David will be roping any more calves until he gets a horse! Thank the Lord for Jacob.