1909-1910 - George Hoffman
1911-1912 - Wallace Thurston
1913 - Harry Wales
1914-1915 - Fred Kollack
1916 - John Moutagh
1917-1918 - Steve Krug
1919 - Ernest Krestman
1920 - Arthur Fischel
1921 - Harry Shaw
1922 - George Becker
1923 - Arthur Potter
1924 - Carl Jensen
1925 - 1926 - Henry Roth
1927 - Charles Hartaman
1928 - Ward Hoffman
1929 - Clarance Eldert
1930 - Ralph Baylis
1931 - Frank Williamson
1932 - Harry Curtis
1933 - David Peterson
1934 - Arthur Ennis
1935 - George Rettinger, Sr.
1936 - Charles Bernard
1937 - William Wimmer
1938 - Nicholas Hamje
1939 - Max Campbell
1940 - Charles McKenzie
1941 - Frank Wright
1942 - Albert Jaeckle
1943 - Jack Kretzer
1943 - James Dawson
1944 - Joseph Odermatt
1945 - Albert Huer
1946 - Herman Lindacher
1947 - Fredrick Muhl
1948 - Edward Smith
1949 - John Fox
1950 - William Laraia
1951 - Warren Skeoch
1952 - Fred Schlawidt
1953 - Edward Meserole
1954 - Joseph Notary
1955 - George Rettinger, Jr.
1956 - Robert Channing
1957 - Ernest Heins
1959 - Bruno Albertelli
1960 - Stanley Grodski
1961 - Robert Meehan
1962 - James McDonough
1963 - Edward Meehan
1964 - John Callahan
1965 - Lawrence McCabe
1966 - George Link
1967 - Stan Szymanski
1968 - Alred Pepe
1969 - Paul Merzbacher
1970 - Robert McDermott
1971 - Jack Rutland
1972 - John Szymanski
1973 - Joseph Balzac
1974 - Edward Zuba
1975 - Henry Krauss
1976 - Sal Bonagura
1977 - Harry White
1978 - Ron Nahas
1979 - James Fairben
1980 - John Gehring
1981 - John Bilardello
1982 - Kenneth Lynch
1983 - Richard Maickel
1984 - Kenneth Fairben
1985 - Richard Jacobs
1986 - William Green
1987 - Francis Cantreva
1988 - Michael Ostipwko
1989 - Philip Friedman
1990 - Frank Wakely, Sr.
1991 - Tom Slattery
1992 - Hugh Berta
1993 - Kevin Greene
1994 - Randolph Holmes
1995 - Lou Scialabba
1996 - John Florio
1997 - Venard Brooks
1998 - Michael Greene
1999 - Charles Zuba
2000 - Paul Szymanski
2001 - Charles Rassiga
2002 - Raymond Neufeld
2003 - Robert Kloepfer