| Jason Penny HOH: The Great Moa HOH: Baby Hewy HOH: Madman Jason Penny HOH: Dr. Payne HOH: Mr. Jason Penny HOH: CrackerJack HOH: The MasterMind HOH: Lone Composer HOH: Ironman J.P. HOH: Vinnie Paul HOH: Masked Man #1 HOH: Masked Man #2 HOH: Jenna Jameson HOH: Mrs. Penny HOH: Jenny McCarthy HOH: Carmen Electra HOH: Crackerman HOH: General Sikorsky HOH: Dutchman's Pipe |
| Brian Hitchens HOH: Thugged Out Assassin HOH: Mike Massacre HOH: The Destroyer B.C. Hitchens HOH: Lunatik HOH: Madman Brian Hitchens |
| Nate Jendrick Dead Romeo Andrew the Disciple Lil Wayne Guiding Vision Jim Vettori |
| Gene Boyer Eradicator Xavier Storm Annihilator Aaron Bailey Silent Rage Sam Jackson The Mimic The Hitman Chris Spencer Cain the Crucifier Armageddon Apocalypse Oakley Bro.: Psycho Blade Oakley Bro.: Raven Youngblood The Realist Johnny Darkness The Stretcher Von Schmidt Hardcore King G.B. Brutal Gary McAdams "Simply Ravishing" Ryan Johnson The Nightmare Bad Boy Billy Black |
| Harry Maitland HOH: Amish Thug Ezekial Jebaniah HOH: Hardcore King H.M. Brutal HOH: King of Violence HOH: Next Level Nick Trabone HOH: Road Hog HOH: Lumberjack Rex Brutal HOH: Johnny Manhattan HOH: Destruction HOH: Inner City Psycho HOH: Hardball Mike Havoc HOH: B-Boy Apostle HOH: Mat Master Mick A |