 |
Executed by the State of Texas |
Just the Facts | On February 3rd of 1998, the State of Texas executed
Karla Faye Tucker Brown for her part in 2 extremely brutal murders
committed in 1983. Media coverage of her execution centered on
several factors:
Yes, we got to know quite a lot about Karla. We should not forget the victims in this case: Jerry Lynn Dean and Deborah Thornton. Their lives were cut short by Karla and her accomplice in a most brutal manner. While I am philosophically opposed to the death penalty, I can easily understand why the jury sentenced Karla to die. Had "that Karla" existed today, few people would have mourned her execution. But 15 years passed between Karla's sentencing and her death. In that time, I believe Karla had rehabilitated and was no longer a threat to Society. With all due respect to the victims and their families, at the time of her execution no civilized benefit was derived from Karla's death. Karla desired mercy from Texas. She wasn't asking for freedom; only to spend the rest of her life in prison working her very special ministry to inmates. Karla was refused mercy and her life was extinguished. This website serves to highlight the injustice of her execution as well as being my humble attempt to honor the person Karla had become: a caring and giving person... a mentch. Her vehicle was Christianity and, although I am not Christian, I respect her journey. I triumph in her self-transformation and deeply regret her death. The world is a sadder place without Karla Faye Tucker. |
People close to the situation speak out after the execution
My thoughts on Karla Tucker's execution
This cartoon (which appeared in the Dallas Morning News) expresses many of my feelings
Return to Paradise - my thoughts after seeing this movie.
Other
Karla Faye Tucker websites and resources
o Karla Faye Tucker Brown
Memorial - a wonderful and thoughtful site
o
The Clarke County Indiana Presecuting Attorney Office has a detailed webpage with many facts about Karla's crime, execution, and the people surrounding the case.
o Ronald
W. Carlson's website - Ronald W. Carlson is the brother of one of the
victims. (expired)
o The 700 Club - interviews with Karla by
reporter Kathy Chiero (expired)
o Karla Faye Home Page - A
rich site from the Family Life Training Center (expired)
o Crossed
Over : A Murder, a Memoir - a book by Beverly Lowry based on her interviews
with Karla (1992) (out of print)
o CNN Headline News - CNN news coverage of Karla's execution
Other Interesting Death Penalty
websites
The Debra Jean Milke Case - An
innocent woman on Arizona's deathrow: stunning reading.
President George W. Bush Publicly Mocked Karla's Clemency
Plea
In early August 1999, then Presidential candidate
Governor George W. Bush mocked Karla Tucker's plea for clemency during an
interview with Talk Magazine. Bush mentioned that he had watched Larry
King's interview with Karla Tucker from Texas Death Row.
"I didn't meet with Larry King either when he came down for it," Bush told the magazine. "I watched his interview with (Tucker), though. He asked her real difficult questions, like, `What would you say to Governor Bush?' "
The Talk reporter asked how she GOP Presidental Primary Opponent Gary Bauer critisized Bush for these
comments. Houston Chronicle, August 11, 1999
Current Method of Execution: Injection of a chemical mixture of
pancuronium bromide, potassium chloride and sodium thiopental.
This biography is still under construction. Sources: Application/petition for thirty day reprieve from execution of
death sentence and for commutation of sentence to imprisonment for life
At about 15 or 16 years old, she moved in with Steven Griffith (they later
married). They took care of the child of a friend for the 5 years they were
together. Four months after breaking up with Griffith, Karla took up
prostitution and continued nearly up to the time of the murders. All this time
she was taking drugs.
Karla has known Shawn Dean (wife of Jerry Lynn Dean) since her band
travelling days. After breaking up with Griffith, she moved in with Shawn and
Jerry Dean.
The crime was committed on June 13, 1983.
Tucker had spent to previous 2 days using drugs and alcohol along with
several other people: Danny Garrett (her current boyfriend), Kari Burrell,
Ronnie Burrell (Kari's ex-husband), and James Leibrant. The Burrells left the
previous evening. The morning of June 13th, the remaining three (Tucker,
Garrett, and Leibrant) decided to go to Jerry Dean's home and steal Dean's
motorcycle: Tucker having lived with Jerry Dean and his wife, Shawn, in the
past. Shawn Dean had left Jerry Dean 2 to 3 weeks previously because Jerry
had punched her and was living with Tucker.
They entered Dean's apartment using a key the Tucker had taken from Shawn
Dean's pants (while doing laundary). In the apartment, Tucker sat on Dean (who
was lying on a mattress on the floor). Dean recognized her in the dark, and told
her, "We can work it out. . . . I didn't really file charges on Shawn. . . ."
Tucker and Dean wrestled, and then Garrett intervened, hitting Dean over the
head repeatedly with a hammer.
Tucker found and turned on the lights to see Dean lying face down on the
mattress, his body "gurgling." Wanting to "stop him from making that noise,"
Tucker took a nearby pickax and hit him in the back with it four or five times.
Leibrant apparently witnessed some portion of this and left the crime scene.
When Tucker told Garrett that Dean was still "making that noise," Garrett
repeatedly struck Dean with the pickax and the noise stopped.
Tucker then discovered that someone was "underneath some covers laying up
against the wall by the door." She swung the pickax and hit Deborah Thornton in
the shoulder, not being able to discern whether Thornton was a man or woman at
that moment. Thornton rose up and struggled with Tucker, grabbing the pickax.
Garrett came in the room, grabbing the pickax too, and separated Tucker from
Thornton. Tucker testified that she then went into the living room at that point
and carried boxes out to Garrett's car. She then returned to the bedroom where
she saw Garrett kill Thornton with the pickax.
After obtaining the motorcycle frame, she and Garrett left: Garrett in his
car, and Tucker driving Jerry Dean's vehicle.
In a tape recording played in court (recorded by police utilizing Doug
Garrett, Danny's brother), she bragged to friends that she got sexual thrills
while pick-axing Dean. At trial, though, Tucker testified this was not true:
that it was "big talk" to impress her friends. It should be noted that, at her
trial, Tucker appeared remorseful for her crime and gave clear candid testimony.
Tucker was convicted of the two murders and received the death penalty.
Garrett, who also was sentenced to death, died in prison of liver disease in
1993.
The two victims are picture below. This section is still under construction. On 9/13/83, Karla was indicted for capital murder and entered a plea of not
guilty. Jury selection began on 3/2/84 and concluded more than 1 month later on
4/9/84. The trial began on 4/11 and 4/19. A guilty verdict was handed dwon that
same day.
The punishment phase of the trial began on 4/23 and lasted 2 days. The jury
came back with punishment of death after taking into account Texas Prisoner Number: 777
There was a tremendous amount of media attention: locally as well as
globally. Europeans were especially troubled that Texas was going to execute
Karla.
The "Larry King Live" show had two revealing shows.
Karla's Austin and Houston attorneys filed with the
State of Texas an application/petition for thirty day reprieve from execution of
death sentence and for commutation of sentence to imprisonment for life.
This document is not available for viewing on the Internet but contains a wealth
of information about the judicial history of Karla's case as well as compelling
testimonials from important people asserting Karla's full rehabilitation. For
example, Charley Davidson (a prosecutor of Karla's accomplice, Garrett) publicly
stated (Jan. 1998)
While they are not required to meet with the prisoner, Victor Rodriguez
did meet with Karla Tucker and reviewed the facts of her trial. At this
time, it is my understanding that no questions or weight was put on Ms. Tucker's
behavior on Death Row following her conviction and sentencing. Mr.
Rodriguez is quoted as saying that "commutation of a death sentence should be
granted for only two reasons: actual innocence or a lack of due process."
[see a sample
letter to the Paroles Board by Aboliton Now]
On Feb 2nd, the Paroles Board unanomously voted to deny Karla's clemency
request: 16 nay, 2 abstains (one person always abstains). "The board felt
... that given the information that we have about this case, that it ... does
not recommend commuting the sentence from a death penalty to a lesser penalty,"
board chairman Victor Rodriguez told reporters at a news conference in
Austin. He also said that the gruesome nature of the case "carried a lot
of weight" in the board's decisions. Responding to the fact that
Karla's and 16 previous clemency bids (in 1997) did not receive even a single
vote for clemency, Mr. Rodriguez said, "No one has yet to make a strong enough
case for commutation,"
Without a majority recommendation, Gov. Bush was denied any opportunity to
commute Karla's sentence. The Governor does have the authority to grant a
one-time 30-day stay of execution to let the Paroles Board reconsider it's
decision.
Karla's
letter to Gov. George Bush asking him for a 30-day stay of execution
The US Supreme Court rejected without comment an appeal by Karla's lawyers
to stay her execution. Gov.
George Bush's statement denying a 30-day stay of execution Last Meal Request: Banana, Peach and Garden Salad with Ranch
Dressing Karla Faye Tucker was executed by the state of Texas on February 3rd by
lethal injection. The sentence was carried out sometime after 6:30pm and
she was pronounced dead at 6:45pm.
Richard Thornton, husband of one of Tucker's victims Katheryn Thornton, stepdaughter of Deborah Thornton George "Mac" Secrest, Tucker's lead attorney from Houston David Botsford, Tucker's Austin attorney Allan Polunsky, chairman of the Texas Board of Criminal Justice
" `Please,' Bush
whimpers, his lips pursed in mock desperation, `don't kill me,' " according to
the magazine.
Here's
the relevant clip of the interview from the September 1999 issue of Talk
Magazine.
"I think it is nothing short of unbelievable that the governor of a
major state running for president thought it was acceptable to mock a woman he
decided to put to death," Bauer said of Bush.
Send email to the webpage owner
The Death Penalty in
Texas: Some Facts
[back
to top]
Karla's Early Life
Date of birth:
11/18/1959
Race: white
Height: 5' 3"
Eyes: brown
Hair:
black
Native of Harris County, TX
Education Level: 7 years
Weight (at
time of offense): 121 lbs
Age (at time of offense): 23
Karla dropped out of school before completely the 7th grade. While
living with her father and 2 older sisters, she started shooting heroin. At 12
years old, her mother helped her "kick" her heroin addiction. At age 13, she
began traveling with the Allman Brothers Band on tour and experience cocaine
use.
The Crime
Here is a brief
synopsis of the crime and it's circumstances.
The Trial
Sources:
Application/petition for thirty day reprieve from execution of death sentence
and for commutation of sentence to imprisonment for life
1) was her
crime deliberate.
2) does she pose a continuing societal threat.
Pre-Execution Media
Attention
Larry
King's interview with Karla on death row
Larry
King's interview with key people about Karla's fate.
Plea for Clemency
"The Karla Tucker who killed Jerry Dean and Debra Thornton
cannot be executed by the State of Texas because that person no longer exists.
The Karla Tucker who remains on death row is a completely different person
who, in my opinion, is not capable of those atrocities. I am comfortable
enough with this belief that, if possible, I would welcome Karla into my house
to meet my family. If the purpose of the death penalty is to execute an
individual solely for a crime they have committed, then Karla Faye Tucker
should be executed. However, if the purpose is to execute an individual
for what they have done and what they now are, then Karla Faye Tucker
should not die. She is no longer a threat to society. As such, even though she
will not ask for it herself, I believe Governor Bush should commute her
sentence to life. Based not only on what she did but what she has become, I
feel justice would have been done."
By Texas law, the
Governor can commute a death sentence only with the recommendation of a majority
of the Board of Pardons and Paroles. There are 18 members of this board
which is chaired by Victor Rodriguez. The Parole Board members
receive by mail information regarding the bid for clemency and mail in their
votes. By law, their job is only to review the facts of the criminal case
to ensure the prisoner received a fair trial.
The Execution
On the day of her execution, the governor's
office received 12,519 calls about the Tucker case running about 4-to-1 against
executing her.
Karla's
Final Statement prior to execution
Texas Execution Number: 145
"Justice for
Deborah ... is complete."
" ... Fourteen and a half years ago, Karla Faye
Tucker exploded my family. Fourteen and a half years later, she brought my
family back together again. I have nothing but sympathy and sorrow for her
family. They are now going through what we have been through. My religion
says to forgive, turn the other cheek. I'm not a perfect man. I've tried very
hard. I still cannot do it. I don't believe her Christianity; I don't
believe her conversion. I never did; I never will."
"As she was
dying, I did ask God to have mercy on her soul. It was the right thing to do.
And her dying also was the right thing to do. I cannot forgive her, but I
have asked God to."
"(In) my
last visit with her as her lawyer, her spirits were excellent. She never
faltered in any way about her faith. She told me over and over again how much
love she had for her family members, certainly Dana Brown, her husband. ...
typical, vintage Karla Faye Tucker Brown. She was at peace as (much as) one can
be in that circumstance. And about four minutes later, the state of Texas got
its way."
"The state of Texas
killed a good person today. Karla Faye Tucker will forever live in our hearts,
our souls, our minds. She is in a better place tonight than she was today."
"The issues here were not religious conversion or gender, but rather
culpability and accountability. Karla Faye Tucker brutally murdered two innocent
people and was found guilty by the court and afforded all legal processes.
Although I believe she finally found God, her religious awakening could in no
way excuse or mitigate her actions in the world she just left, but hopefully
will provide her redemption in the world she just entered."
