IB CSL PSYCHIATRY
PSYCHIATRIC SYMPTOMS
Dr Eric Chen
Psychiatry
Fri 13-09-02
ASSESSING PSYCHIATRIC SYMPTOMS
Emphasis on forms (vs. contents) of abnormal experience
- Form = eg. Auditory hallucination; important for Dx; result of imbalance in brain
- Content = message of voice, identity of voice; important for understanding illness; influenced by different cultures
Phenomenological approach
- Suspension of everyday interpretations
- Focus on raw description of experience (Ie. Restrain from making interpretation from an event (eg. Attempted suicide), and focus on what that person is feeling)
- Counter-intuitive and requires disciplined practice (even if you are disciplined; Pt and family will try to interpret experiences, therefore need to facilitate them in concentrating only in actual experience, not interpretation of experience)
- Reference: Karl Jasper's General Psychopathology
2 Ways of Understanding
Verstehen
(Put yourself in Pt's shoes and simulate his experience -> eg. Empathy, rapport)
- Intuitive
- Empathic
- Individual
- Semantics important
- Use personal frameworks
Erklaren
(Look at Pt as object
® eg. Stats, prognosis, Tx)
- Explanation "from outside
- Scientific
- Objective
- Use of impersonal, non-semantic explanatory principles
- Both are important in medicine/ psychiatry
- If use only Verstehen: will get burnt out; will only be able to help a few (but have ignored the facts/ stats - Erklaren - which suggest a poor prognosis)
Process in Descriptive Psychopathology
1. Experience of Symptom
2. Reconstruction of Symptom
These should be as similar as possible - but there are many barriers to achieving this
- Language: ask question in a way the Pt understands?
- Retrieval: Pt to retrieve experience from memory
- Translation: into language to give response to Dr's question
What if: experience is so unusual that we do not have the vocabulary to express it - eg. Auditory hallucination with a dog's voice
If problem is inherent, this information may never be overcome
Also: when we reconstruct experience, we do not use only primary information from Pt; we also fill in gaps with our own ideas (we should refrain from doing this)
GROUPS OF SYMPTOMS
Disorders of Perception: interpretation of external stimuli
Disorders of Thought: cognitive functions
Disorders of Language
Disorders of Memory: remember and recall information from past
Disorders of Consciousness: level of awareness of surroundings
Disorders of Emotion: emotional response to things that happen around us
Disorders of Movements
DISORDERS OF PERCEPTION
Sensory Distortions
(Change in one particular dimension of the perception)
- Changes in intensity: eg. Mania: everything becomes brighter
- Changes in colour: uncommon on its own in psychiatric symptoms, xanthopsia in digoxin poisoning (everything has yellow tinge)
- Changes in size
Sensory Deceptions
Hallucinations
- Definition: perception without an object (Esquirol)
- Application to any sensory modality
- Subjects reacts to them as if they were true perceptions - except for Pt's who have been having hallucinations for many years; they learn to recognise them as an illness
Auditory Hallucinations
- Most common/ important in psychiatry
- Simple hallucinations and unintelligible noises
- Verbal Hallucinations
- Simple: Brief phrases or names
- Complex: lengthy, structured sentences
Verbal Hallucinations
- Second Person VH - eg. "You are totally useless (talking to the subject)
Third Person VH: eg. "Why is he not going to work
Running Commentary: "He is getting up now… (highly distressing, loss of control, feeling like someone else knows everything that's going)
Thought Echo (Gedankenlautwerden) (all your thoughts are spoken aloud, no privacy, people can hear everything you think about other)
Imperative (instructions to subjects): "Go and kill yourself with a knife - First Rank Symptoms of Schizophrenia
[If 2 or more are present, highly likely to be schizophrenia (if just one -. Mania, depression)]
Current theory of verbal hallucinations
- Inner speech hypothesis (fail to ID inner thoughts, mistakenly believe that they come form the outside world)
- Laryngeal EMG correlates with subjective experience of hallucination (laryngeal muscles active at subthreshold level) - sometimes mouth moves, make soft sounds (not speech)
Visual Hallucinations
- Elementary: Organic states
- Complex: Confusional state or Functional psychosis
- Combined auditory and visual hallucinations (rare): in TLE (temporal lobe epilepsy), also suspect malingering
DIAG: complexity of visual hallucination and association cortex
- Information from primary visual cortex goes to the visual processing areas
- Ventral system: runs around inferior occipital and inferior temporal cortex -> analysis of shape and ID of object
- Most elementary analysis (shape, colour, movt) occurs in early areas
- More complex ID of shape occurs further along direction
- Reach temporal love proper: neurones respond only to very specific shapes (eg. Of hand, face)
- Therefore, neural system becomes more specific to complex information as it cascades into temporal lobe
- However, limbic system is inside medial surface of temporal lobe (therefore, end chain of visual processing ends in limbic system)
- Most functional psych disorders are related to abnormalities in limbic system
- Functional psychosis: these areas affected - results in more complex abnormal experience
- If more simple abnormal system, pathology further away from limbic system and closer to primary visual cortex
Eg. Tinnitus: perception of auditory tone in absence of stimulus (therefore, technically can be classified as an auditory hallucination) - but problem in primary auditory area, therefore unlikely to be accounted for by psychosis
Note: hallucinations around time of sleep very normal (eg. Going to sleep, on waking up)
DISORDERS OF THOUGHT: DELUSION
- False (not essential: eg. Delusion of jealousy)
- Unshakeable (most important characteristics): not open to contrary evidence, discussion (therefore Dx delusion: ask Pt how he came to form these ideas; then challenge Pt: under what circumstances would he revise he thoughts)
- Out of keeping with social and cultural background: soft and dangerous definition (eg. Religion is unshakeable and there is no proof, but not a delusion because many other people believe in it) (political dissidents in Russia and China have ended up in mental institutions)
- Usually self reference: content of delusion wrt Pt himself
Contents of Delusions
- Delusions of persecution: belief that someone is going to harm you
- Delusions of reference: belief that something is related to you, when in fact it is not (eg. See someone talking on other side of street, and Pt thinks they're talking about him). Note: "cocktail party phenomenon" - ability to filter out what is connected to you and what is not. Milder form: idea of reference (eg. self-conscious person believes people are looking at them, but they are not)
- Delusions of influence: belief that something that has happened that is unrelated to you has been caused by you (eg. Pt believes he caused an earthquake by thinking a particular thought)
- Delusions of love/ erotomania: belief that someone is in love with you (more common in females; target is prominent male - including doctors)
- Delusions of jealousy: believe that spouse is being unfaithful; can lead to domestic violence
- Delusions of grandeur/ grandiose: belief that you are of high status (extreme cases: eg. Believed that he is the Messiah)
- Delusions of ill health: belief that you have serious/ fatal illness (can happen in serious depression). Note: someone doesn't have any symptoms (cf. somatic complaints) thinks they have illness
- Delusions of guilt: belief that you have done something wrong and deserve very heavy punishment (eg. Heavy depression). Note: need to check if Pt has done that thing, and if it's serious
- Delusions of negation (nihilism, Cotard syndrome): belief that already died, everything in body rotten, bowel blocked (esp. in depression in elderly)
- Delusions of poverty: belief that you have no money
Description of Delusions
Primary / secondary
... To other psychopathology
- Eg. Pt with auditory hallucination (running commentary) and based on belief that there is a hidden camera -> Secondary delusion (ie. If belief of camera was not there, Pt would not have running commentary)
- Primary delusion: can not be accounted for in context of rest of Pt's symptoms
Pervasive / encapsulated
- Pervasive: affecting most areas of that Pt's concerns and function
- Encapsulated: has delusion when you talk about a particular topic (when you talk about another topic, Pt is normal). Eg. Pt believed that old neighbour wanted to harm him, has had Tx since, new neighbours, so is OK
Fragmented / systematised
- Structure of delusion
- Fragmented: many different abnormal thoughts, relationship of which are not logic
- Systematised: one complicated story which hangs together all anomalous experiences (systematised in intact neurological function)
- From structure of delusion: can deduce natural history of evolution of that delusion, pathology of delusion
Action based on delusion
OBSESSIONS & COMPULSIONS
- Cannot get rid of a content of consciousness
- Senseless
(key difference cf. delusion: fully believes in delusion. In Obsessions: realises that it is nonsense, but cannot stop it), repetitive, distressing, resisted
DISORDERS OF THOUGHT
Thought Alienation
- Thought insertion: someone physically inserting thoughts into your mind (thoughts totally alien to yourself)
- Thought withdrawal: thoughts being removed from your brain
- Thought broadcasting: thoughts are being spoken aloud (element of hallucination) and broadcasted over a large distance Pt believes everyone 'knows' about him- therefore has ideas and delusion of reference
All First Rank Symptoms of schizophrenia
Disorders of Tempo of Thought
Flight of ideas
- Thought follows each other rapidly
- No connection between successive thoughts
- Divertable by external stimulus and superficial associations
- Clang associations: association based on phonetics (similar sounds); Pt rhymes words
- Because thoughts enter mind so fast, no time for meaningful association, so can only associate sounds
Retardation of thinking
- Slow train of thought
- Eg. Depression
- Very difficult in examination!
Disorder of Continuity of Thinking
Perseveration
- Mental operations persist beyond the point at which they are relevant
- Common in organic disorder: generalised or prefrontal (many functional psychoses affect frontal lobe)
- Eg. Ask Pt how old they are: they reply '50yo'. Go on to ask other questions: Pt keeps replying '50yo'
Thought blocking
- Very rare
- Normally experience thought as a continuous stream
- Sudden arrest of a train of thought
- Characteristic of schizophrenia (believe that thought withdrawal has occurred)
- Distinguish from anxiety: 'mind goes blank'
DISORDERS OF LANGUAGE
Formal thought disorder
- Blending of incongruous elements
- Loosening of Associations: similar to flight of ideas, previous idea not related to next idea
- Different degrees
- Mild: circumstantial thinking - topic being expressed drifts from one to next for long time before returning to original topic (direction not focused, only relatively normal if conversation goes for a long time)
Examples of FTD
- Loosening of Association (even smaller units of language are not connected - eg. Beginning of sentence does not match with end of sentence (severe; grammar not preserved)
- Derailment: specific but rare (trains of thought derail and shift to a different train of thought;
- Tangential thinking: less specific for schizophrenia (sentences not abnormal, paragraphs drift and content drifts off and fails to return to normal path)
- Neologisms
Difference between flight of ideas and FTD (speed)
- Flight of ideas: accelerated speed; mechanism: speed so fast, content so rich (eg. Mania)
- FTD: speed normal but things still don't connect; mechanism: abnormality in planning and processing speech ideas (eg. Schizophrenia)
DISORDERS OF MEMORY
Amnesias
(1) Psychogenic
- Anxiety-related
- Dissociative: Pt forgotten entire past life
(2) Organic
Organic Amnesia
Damage to memory of circuits of brain
- Retrograde amnesia: before time of damage
- Anterograde amnesia: failure to remember things since the accident
- Transient global amnesia
- Ribot's law: recent event lost before remote events (applies to amnesia, dementia) (if amnesia does not fit into this pattern -> psychogenic, malingering)
Confabulation
- False description of past event
- Could be influenced by the examiner (suggestibility)
- Occurs in amnesic syndrome and other organic conditions
- Construction based on inadequate data (influenced by what stimuli are around him)
- Lack of insight and critical faculty
2 phenomenon fail for confabulation to occur
- Intrinsic tendency to come to interpretation
- Counter-checked by additional supervisory system
- Missing information (up till now: normal)
- Supervisory deficit: Pt doesn't know that he doesn't have the information (up till now: amnesia)
- Confabulation: pools together what data he has to construct an answer
Eg. Head-injury Pt.
- Ask what he did this morning. Pt 'involved in Korean War' (can be very strange/ odd) (in this case, English Pt, Asian doctor, which may have influenced his answer)
- Confabulation: depends on what is presented to the Pt
- Delusion: fixed
Eg. Corpus callosum cut (epilepsy)
- Split-brain subjects
- Experiment: funny cartoon presented to Pt's left visual field
- Images present to left visual field end up in right visual cortex
- Because of operation, that information was not available to left hemisphere
- Right hemisphere received information -> person laughed
- Dr asked Pt why are you laughing?
- Pt: because you look funny
- Doctor's question: verbal message, language centre in left hemisphere, L hemisphere has to respond to information without information of cartoon, but has information about facial muscles contracted in laughter
- Therefore, Pt aware that he laughed but not aware of cartoon, but could only see investigator, therefore said 'because you are so funny'
Brains natural tendency to construct solution to problem
Distortions of Recognition
Deja vu
- Spurious familiarity
- Found in temporal lobe epilepsy and in normal individuals
Misidentification
- Capgras syndrome: emotionally related person as double; in schizophrenia, depression
- Fregoli syndrome: a familiar persecutor identified in strangers
Ventral visual recognition system exists: chain of processing information to increase specificity of processing from occipital cortex to temporal cortex
More dorsal system that connects to hypothalamus and emotional system
There are these 2 pathways for processing, therefore some illnesses can affect one pathway more than another
Eg. Can recognise face of wife, but fail to get familiar feeling (therefore person concludes that wife is an impersonator)
Eg. Problem selectively affects perceptual information. Occipital-temporal lobe affected. Pt unable to recognise familiar faces but has familiar feelings (measured autonomic response of Pt - increased emotional response/ arousal)
DISORDERS OF EMOTION
Anxiety
- Autonomic component: Palpitations, tremor, sweating etc
- Motor component: Muscle tension
- Psychological component: Fear, dread
Phobia
- Phobia: Fear directed to specific objects or situations
- Free-floating anxiety: Pervasive and not bound to situations
Depression
Biological component
- Early waking, diurnal fluctuation, anorexia, lethargy (sleep and appetite controlled by hypothalamus - therefore hypothalamus affected)
Motor component
- Psychomotor retardation: Pt can become immobile/ stupurous
Psychological component
- Pessimism, self-blame, suicidal ideation
Note: with Tx, motor component improves first, but psychological component takes time, therefore high-risk time for suicide
Elation
Biological component
- Insomnia, increased appetite, increased energy
Insomnia of depression: Pt cannot sleep, distressed, think sad/ regrettable things, becomes very tired
Insomnia of mania: Pt feels he doesn't need to sleep, energetic
Motor component
Psychological component
- Confidence, grandiosity, disinhibition
Mood Descriptors
Emotional lability
- Excessive or inappropriate emotional response
- Rapidly changeable
Blunted affect
- Lack of sophistication and sensitivity in emotional expression
- Not the absence of emotion
- Loss of refinement of complexity of emotional expression
- Eg. N = subtle, co-ordinated changes (like orchestra); Blunted affect: monotone one instrument only
- Seen in chronic schizophrenia
Restricted affect
- Opposite of lability
- Lack of responsivity of emotional expression
- Incongruous affect
- Inappropriate emotional response
DISORDERS OF CONSCIOUSNESS
"Clouding of Consciousness"
- Decreased contact with environment
- Often accompanied by disorientation
- Found in acute confusional state (eg. Metabolic derangement, stroke)
- Most important: orientation to time, place, person
- However, dementia has decreased orientation to time, but no clouding of consciousness
Stupor
- Patients conscious and alert (not a coma)
- Akinetic mutism (no motor verbal response)
- May be organic or psychogenic
DISORDERS OF MOVTS
Overlaps with neurology
Voluntary movements
- Goal directed: mannerisms (Eg. there is meaning in the movt - chronically ill Pt's directing traffic in the middle of hosp ward - inappropriate, but complete movement complex)
- Non-goal directed: stereotypy (less organised, cannot see meaning of movt)
Involuntary movements
- Tremor
- Dyskinesia: irregular movt
- Dystonia: abnormal position/ contraction of muscle groups
Catatonic Syndrome I
- Waxy flexibility: e.g. psychological pillow
- Stupor
- Echopraxia and Echolalia: Environment dependence syndrome
- Perseveration
- Mannerisms and Stereotypies
- Ambitendency: inability to complete motor programme due to fluctuation between opposite motor directions
- Mitgehen and automatic obedience: Excessive compliance to instruction
- Gegenhalten and negativism: Excessive resistance to instruction
Motor and Sensory hierarchy
Environment dependency syndrome