IB WCS 32
AETIOLOGY OF PSYCHIATRIC DISORDERS
Dr Ronald Chen
Psychiatry
Wed 25-09-02
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
- Understand psych disorders as brain diseases
- Understand the roles of bio-psychosocial factors
- Understand the study approaches for identifying etiological factors
- Understand the stress-diathesis model
- Learn about clinical formation
CONCEPTUAL ISSUES
Subjective vs. Objective
Functional vs. Organic
- Organic: gross pathology inside brain, seen with imaging studies, CN examinations
- Functional: no gross pathology inside brain, minor findings (eg. Enlargement of ventricles) - impair brain in cognitive processes, abstract, subtle
Mind vs. Brain vs. Body
- Body (including body systems + organs) affect brain function
- Brain generates ideas/ integrates sensory input -> behaviour + emotion
- Brain is basis for some behaviour, but not all
- Brain is not origin of mind
- Psych: interpret symptoms as arising from brain (eg. NT)
Genetic vs. Environment
- Environment: psychological, stress, interpersonal
- Significant role in aetiology of psych disorders
Psychotherapy vs. Medication
- Continuous psychotherapy - can change NT system/ neural pathway as learning process
DIAGNOSTIC ISSUES
Phenomenological & syndromal approach
- Try to capture symptoms (rely on Pt) that cluster together and form a syndrome (whether fits into a particular disease pattern)
Overlapping disease entities
- Eg. Schizophrenia Pt can also have depressive symptoms
- Eg. Manic-depressive disorder may include psychotic symptoms
- Esp. overlapping in neurotic disorders - eg. Panic with agoraphobic, anxiety and depression
Lack of laboratory confirmation
Name of disease category may not reflect pathogenesis or aetiology
Rely on classification systems - eg. ICD-10; DSM-IV
- Standardised, mutually agreed upon
- Operational criteria to label a particular disease (based on phenomenological approach without no confirmation from biological/ laboratory)
BIOLOGICAL FACTORS
GENETICS
Demonstrate problem clusters in family (family studies) - prevalence rate within family members is higher if a particular person has a disease cf. with general population
Twin studies: can not exclude environmental effects
Adoption studies
Family Studies
- Study aggregation of affected members in a family as compared to the general public
- Cannot distinguish genetic or shared environment (diet, living environment, parenting, social class specific infection within the same family)
- Familial vs. inheritance
Family Study of Schizophrenia
Risk of schizophrenia with family Hx as follows
- 1 parent 13%
- 2 parents 46%
- 1 sibling 10%
- 1 child 6%
- 1 grandparent 5%
- Nephew / niece/ uncle/ aunt 3%
- Cousin 2%
- General public 1%
Every country, culture
Family Study of Affective Disorder (Primary Relatives)
Bipolar proband
Unipolar proband
General population
- 1% bipolar
- 3% unipolar (severe hospital patients)
Twin Study
MZ Twin
- Split from 1 fertilised egg
- Identical - 100% genetic sharing
DZ twin
- From 2 fertilised eggs
- Just like sibling - share 50% genes
MZ > DZ concordance - due to genetic
MZ concordance not equal 100% - environmental factor is also important
Still cannot distinguish genetic from shared environment
Twin - Schizophrenia
- MZ concordance 45%
- DZ concordance 15%
- Equal risk for offspring of both affected and unaffected MZ discordant twins!
- Unexpressed genes?
Twin Affective
Bipolar
- MZ concordance 72%
- DZ concordance 14%
Unipolar
- MZ concordance 40%
- DZ concordance 11%
Indicates interaction bet genetics and environment
Adoption Studies
- Divide biological parents into mentally ill + healthy ® adapted away children have higher incidence of mental illness
- Adopted offspring as proband ® adopted offspring divided into mentally ill and healthy; biological parents have higher incidence of mental illness
- Points towards genetic causation (not purely environment)
Summary
- Family, twin and adoption studies consistently show that major mental illness (eg. Schizophrenia and affective disorder) are inherited in nature
- Next stage will be ID abnormal genes
- Intermediate phenotype important but difficult to find
- NEUROCHEMISTRY
- Dopamine
- Serotonin
- NA
- GABA
- Glutamate
- ACh, etc
Serotonin Pathways in the Brain
- Raphe nucleus - fibres to limbic system/ cortex/ spinal cord
- Important for emotional control/ mood/ appetite/ expression/ anger
- Problems in depressant/ anxiety disorders
- Drugs act on this system
Molecular level
- Release serotonin from nerve terminal, bind to receptors, trigger post-synaptic events
- SSRI (eg. Prozac): bind to serotonin transporter (serotonin in XS in cleft due to decreased uptake into nerve terminal)
- Amine hypothesis of depression; too little serotonin in synaptic cleft
- NEUROPATHOLOGY
- Structural neuroimaging - MRI
- Histopathology
- To show abnormal cell organisation/ neuronal death
SLIDE: Schizophrenia in MZ Twins
- Discordant
- 3rd ventricle larger in affected twin (robust finding for chronic schizophrenic illness)
- Clinically, may not be able to detect this enlargement of ventricle (only statistical finding) - can only tell when compare to unaffected twin
- NEUROPHYSIOLOGY
- Cognitive event related potentials - when they hear tone, press button (cognitive engagement) - measure EEG response as measure of brain activity
- Functional neuroimaging - fMRI, SPECT, PET
DIAG: Schizophrenic illness (PET scan)
- Frontal lobe has less metabolism in Schizophrenic Pt's
- Use twins: should share same genetic material, brain structure more or less the same (better than disease vs. control)
PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
Early life experience
Psychodynamic
Cognitive-behavioural factors
- EARLY LIFE EXPERIENCE
- Loss of parent
- Sexual or physical abuse
- Any other events which may be crucial to the formation of personality
- Formed attitudes towards other people/ the world in general (stress - suppress formation, uneven formation) - eg. Paranoid, impulsive
- PSYCHODYNAMIC FACTORS
Unconscious
- Instinctual forces that are not accessible to awareness (eg. For food, want power but not aware of this)
Conscious
- Part of the mind which is accessible to awareness (eg. Want power but know it's not the right time)
Ego
- Executive function of the mind which provides a sense of self
- To withstand external challenges the ego uses defence mechanism
- Tries to satisfy both urges and super-ego
- Super-ego: don't do that - unethical/ violate religious beliefs/ law
Commonly used defence mechanism
- Denial: process of rejecting unacceptable thoughts, feelings or impulses
- Regression - returns to earlier stage of developmental functioning
- Rationalisation - superficially logical but invalid thinking to avoid stressful reality
- Displacement - redirection of feelings to another object to reduce the threat of real feelings
- Projection - blaming others for one's own fault
- Sublimation - transformation of socially unacceptable feelings or thoughts to socially acceptable ones
- Reaction formation - transforming unacceptable thoughts or feelings to its opposite
- COGNITIVE BEHAVIOURAL FACTORS
Based on learning theory
Through classical, operant or modelling an individual acquires responses to the internal and external environment
- Classical: association, conditional response
- Operant: +ve or -ve reinforcement (reward/ punishment), behaviour depends on whether consequence was good or bad
- Modelling: modelling others; model parents when young, if parents defective (mental illness, substance abuse) children will model this behaviour
- Psychiatric disorders or psychopathology may arise due to a limited and maladaptive way of viewing the self or the environment (eg. If gloomy person, and small problem occurs, think problem is hopeless and contemplate suicide, etc.)
SOCIAL FACTORS
Socio-economic status
- Unemployment
- Poverty
- Job-related stress
- Family structure
Social network
- Friends
- Relatives
- Colleagues
- Organisation/ institutions (church, school)
Life events
- Variable
- May not appear important to you, but may be very important to that person
STRESS-DIATHESIS MODEL
Threshold exists
Combination of stresses + propensity to develop that disease
Stress (environment, biological)
- Eg. Biological - infection
- Eg. Psychological - finance
Diathesis (vulnerability, risk to develop a particular disease)
- Eg. Biological - genetic
- Eg. Psychological - personality
Eg. Recovering mental illness - get viral infection - relapse of mental illness
Additive model: have propensity plus stress -> mental breakdown
CLINICAL FORMATION
|
|
Biological |
Psychological |
Social |
|
Predisposing |
1 |
2 |
|
|
Precipitating |
3 |
|
4 |
|
Perpetuating |
5 |
6 |
7 |
- Mother suffered from depression (Pt lived for long time with depressed mother; will eventually develop gloomy/ negative attitude)
- Negative cognition about self
- Influenza (mild illness may trigger depressive episode)
- Lost job (cause social and financial difficulties)
- Poor adherence to meds (without meds to correct NT - difficult to Tx completely)
- Conflict with siblings
- Owes friends money (financial difficulties from lost job)
NOTE
- Cannot just give meds
- Must know other factors - eg. Psychological stresses keep NT in imbalance
- No matter how much drug Tx you give to Pt, you cannot correct NT imbalance
- Therefore, understand different biological, psychological, social factors - organise drug/ cognitive/ social support for Pt