Punjabi
Women-Socio Religious and cultural practices
Section
1: Introduction: Theory and Concepts This
study is an attempt to analyse the
existing literature on the social, cultural and religious
customs regarding
Punjabi women. The first part
is theoretical which deals with the significance
of the social, cultural and religious
customs and the roletbey
play in the lives of communities. The second part examines the
literature of the British period which includes administrative and official
records on social, cultural and religious
customs of the various tribes, castes and communities. It will also
observe the role of customs and mores in the behaviour
and attitudes of the people.
The third part of this study analyses
the literature which
was produced after the partition of 1947 with the intention to Irighfight
the cultures of the various provinces of Pakistan. The fourth part is
based on the reports of the •various
women's NGOs, who have either published
or prepared reports on the different aspects of the Pakistani women.
However, the paucity of material and the need for a systematic study
is greatly felt, Before
discussing the definition
of socio- cultural and religious
customs, it is necessary to understand the framework in which these
customs originated and which
consequently undermined the status of
women in society. 'With
the patriarchal family we enter the field of written history'
(Marx, Engels: 234: 1976).
The monogamous patriarchal
family ^was the first form of the family
based not on natural but on economic
conditions, namely
on the victory of private property over
original naturally developed, common ownership'
(Marx, Engels: 239: 1976). Simply
defined patriarchy is the rule or
control oTthe father over women, young
girls and boys. Maria Mies extends the
definition of patriarchy by
saying that today male dominance goes beyond this rule of the father
to include husbands, male bosses, ruling
men in most societal institutions in
politics and economics. She contends that historically patriarchal
systems were developed at a particular
time, by particular people in particular
geographical regions. Their main
mechanisms of expansion were robbery, warfare and conquest (Mies:
37:1994). There
are two interpretations regarding the emergence of patriarchy: the
Marxist and the Feminist. Engels points
out that the emergence of surplus and growth of male
inheritance transformed the relationship between men and women. The
system of private
property transformed women's role 'from
an equal partner to a subordinate wife'.
Class exploitation and sexual repression emerged together to serve the
interests of propertied class. Strongly
influenced by evolutionist thinking, Engds
separates earlier stages as pre-history
from actual human history, which, according to him, begins only with
civilisation. Tins means that it begins
with fully-fledged class and patriarchal relations. Engels
is not able to answer the question how humanity then jumped from
pre-history to social history, moreover,
he does not apply the method of dialectical
materialism to the study of these
primitive societies which have 'not yet
entered history'. He thinks that the
laws of evolution prevailed up to the emergence of private
property, of the family and the state. Moreover, the Marxists conceive
of the 'production of new fife'
as a ^naturaT and not an historical
fact. On the other hand, the feminist interpretation
is that patriarchy is the outcome of an historical phenomenon. It
contests the Marxist view by saying that the social
relations of patriarchy emerged when the
mother gave birth to achild and reared the «hild;
giving birth to a child and feeding it was a truly human i.e.
conscious social activity. Patriarchal
relations developed
with women's and men's object-relation to nature. Women's relationship
with nature was productive while that of men was destructive. Tools
such as spear, bow and arrow, axe and hammer, used by men were purely
for killing purposes, whereas women used tools such as a hoe or a
digging stick to cultivate land and to gather plants
(Mies:50,
53: 1994). Historically,
vath the emergence
of patriarchy the social status of women was subordinated to men.
Historical evidence suggests that men
dominated women with their coercive weapons. When the pastoral nomads
domesticated and bred animals, they discovered a new
mode of production. Female animals were
subjected to sexual coercion to increase
the herds. The institution of private
property completely enslaved women; they became responsible for producing
heirs to the property and keeping the family line in continuity. Their
work was to procreate, nourish and train the male issues for the sake
of the family, she was regarded as
cattle, as breeders. It is plausible
that the establishment of harems, the
kidnapping and raping of women, the
patriarchal tines of descent and inheritance were part of the new mode
of production. The agriculturists used
female slaves for they were productive in two ways; as agricultural
workers and as producers of more slaves. The feudal and capitalist
systems modified the means of violence and replaced them with
institutions like the patriarchal family and the state, the manager,
and also powerful ideological systems. Above all
patriarchal religion, law, medicine have defined
women as part of nature to
be controlled by domination of men. New lands were acquired by feudal
lords and the bodies of women did not belong to themselves but to
their lords. Women were the inexhaustible reservoir of human energy.
Under patriarchy the socio-cultural and
religious customs were developed to further family interests, to
exploit women and to use them politically (Mies:
36: 1994 & M. Ali:
1996). Thus
'the victory of private property'
led to the formation of the monogamous
family where man reigned supreme and the
property, by producing an heir^ remained
within the confines of the family. But
marriage was also 'a burden, a duty
which had to be The
institution of marriage was fully utilised for the sake of
the preservation of the family where girls were forced
into undesirable Tnarriages to maintain
amiable relations with an enemy family.
This was possible because of the various sacrifices made by women.
However, these sacrifices failed to raise the status of women; they
remained subordinated. History is replete with examples of royal
princesses being married to the conquerors after
defeat in order to inaintain diplomatic
relations. For example, Baber's sister, Khanzadah,
was married to the Usbekidng Shaibani
Khan in a deal to allow the besieged Baber
to escape from Samarqand.
Also, Mary Louis, the Austrian princess married Napoleon against her wishes
to save the kingdom from his hands.
Women were also given as gifts, especially conquered
tribes presented their girls to the victors. In the Eskimo tribes
there was a custom to allow the guests to sleep with the wife (
M.AII: 9,
10; 1996). Patriarchy
moulds itself according to respective cultures and communities.
Patriarchy also creates a division between the public and the private,
between 'world'
and 'home'.
It is actually a gender division, the
public world being male and the private world being female and it is
one which affects women most profoundly.
Patriarchy underestimates the capabilities of women. It pays them less
for doing the same work. It tells them that girls are difTerent
from boys in every way, not only biologically
but also temperamentaHy. It also places
a high value on virginity and purity. It Imposes
chastity ^n women as the highest virtue.
And yet it is patriarchy that tells men
that they can beat, abuse and rape women. In fact it tells them that
it is their own fault if they are raped, beaten or abused
(Abeyeskera: 14, 15: 1995). Patriarchy
has established a system ^f control
over the world that places more men than
women in positions of power and
authority. Patriarchy is visible in the structures of the institutions
that guide and govern our lives-within the family, at school
and universities, in church, temple and mosques; in marriage and the
work place, in the factories and in the fields, in
the state and in the institutions of
local government; in the armed forces
and in the civilian defence squads; in the mass media,
in the courts oflawdbid). Patriarchy
socialises women so that they accept hierarchies and other structures
of power and control without ever daring
to question them. Patriarchy uses-violence
and the threat of violence in many overt and covert ways in order to
maintain its hold on power (Ibid). Concepts: Socio-cultural
practices evolve in a community to maintain
unity and cobesiveness among the
members. They are based on social Ties,
economic relations, environment, climate and gender differences.
Shared social customs are transmitted
from generation to generation, ^hich
provides an imbroken channel of
continuity with past (Darling.'3:1980).
Customs make a community
organised for a purpose. Social
practices are mundane and basically
pragmatic. A society, by keeping its
customs in practice, produces and sustains primary
values, benefits, attitudes and motivation (Darling^,
4:1980). However, some of the customs have class
interests to subjugate lower classes and castes. Male culture is
presented at the expense of individuals,
especially female. Socio-
cultural practices have more appeal for the
people than religious customs or laws. Especially in the case of
conversion, the foreign origin religions fail
to change their behaviour. For example, "The Musalman
RaJput, Gujur,
or Jat is for all social, tribal,
political and administrative purposes exactly as much a Rajput, Gujur
or Jat as his Hindu brother. His social customs are unaltered, his
tribal restrictions are unrelaxed, his
values of marriage and inheritance are unchanged....
The fact is that the people are bound by social and tribal customs far
more than any rules of religion" (lbbetsan:
14; 1986). Sometimes a compromise is made
to amalgamate religious ceremonies and
symbols in socio-cultural customs. In other words, customs and
religions interact and reproduce each other. There
is a difference between customs and laws. Customs originate within a
community and the whole community
participates in their formation. Customs
evolve in
a society through social activity of the people. Laws, whether divine
or secular, need an authority to implement them;
the implementation often relies on coercive
methods. Laws also vary from government to government, whereas
customs are formed over a period of centuries and
are thus enduring. Hence, customs have
more power, influence ^nd respect among
people than laws. ff anybody raises a
voice against them, be/she is
boycotted, expelled and excommunicated. In the Medieval
period it was a serious crime to question
a custom and inade the member
defenceless against all odds. Survival of the
individual without the help of the
community would be difficult. History suggests that laws were unable
to have any effect on social practices.
For example, when Akbar passed the law
against the custom of sati, it remained
ineffective. However, the Brahmo Samaj
movement against sati in Bengal, led by
Raj Ram Mohanroy, was successful in
abolishing the custom and hence made the law passed by the British
government against sati effective. Customs
and Identity: As
each community evolves its own socio-cultural
customs, they become its essential part. By maintaining and following
the customs, the community members feel proud and sometimes
distinguish from others. This sense of identity provides a source of
unity and integrity. Abner Cohen
remarks.' "Ethnicity
awareness will produce homogenisation of
internal society and cultural
values in order to increase interaction within the group while
resisting homogenisation with other
groups. This requires the creation and
utilisation of myths , beliefs, pressures
and sanctions. Diflerent
elements are employed which become so interdependent
that they seem an integrated ideological scheme" (quoted by S.
Latif: 6: 1990). Whenever
a tribe or caste asserts its identity, socio-cultural customs and
traditions are revived and strengthened.
Especially in the process of modernisation,
when all
socio-cultural differences
are merging in a global culture, the fear
of losing identity creates an
urge to preserve particular customs. Under
such pressures some old, outdated and defunct customs are reborn to
keep identity intact. Thus, identity and
socio-cultural customs have deep affinity
with each other and women become symbols of culture and tradition and
identity. Women
and Customs: As
most of the socio-cultural and religious
customs are related to women, they become the custodians of these
customs. Owing to meagre or no access to education and lack of
exposure to the external environment, old customs and practices are
deeply embedded in the psyche of women and men. They trace their
legitimacy from the past. Any change is regarded as blasphemous and
an insult to their ancestors, who bequeath those customs to them.
To abolish them means to end the continuity and to deprive them of
their identity. These socio-cultural
practices provide motivation and
inspiration to them. This makes them defenders and protectors of their
customs, especially those which are
related to rituals and ceremonies such as birth,
betrothal and marriage. It also helps in creating
female bonding. Change
of Customs: However,
socio-cultural customs never remain static. They change in
spite c^ efforts
to preserve them. "Human beings sought to preserve a familiar
stage of lif^ unless change
was forced on by factors that were beyond their control" (Trigger;
290: 1993).
As earlier pointed out, every society
contains within itself the forces of
change and resistance. This antagonism of factors produces energy that
forces society to alter its norms and
mores. The internal and external forces
of change disintegrate
established customs and either completely wipe them out or drastically
change them. Changes occur as a result
of technological development;
demography and the economic relations which affect the concepts of
property, family life, laws, practices, customs and beliefs. However,
it is evident from history that the pace of change is much more rapid
in urban centres than in rural areas where change is resisted and old
practices and traditions are preserved.
Thus in any society change is uneven. Some areas become more developed
while others remain underdeveloped. Accordingly, socio-cultural
and religious practices vary from area to area. Tribes
and castes who identify themselves with their traditional practices conserve
them in order to retain their individuality. The tribes which are
located in remote areas and have less contact with urban areas adhere
to their old practices. Their folk tales and stories gloria
customs and institutions. Even anthropologists, historians and
intellectuals cherish their traditional
values. In
Punjab there is a difference between
urban and rural areas in observing socio-cultural practices. Rural
areas are more conservative than urban areas. However, recently, there
has been a resurgence of tribal identity,
which is evident from the inclusion of tribal names as surnames
and reconstruction of tribal history. It is in the interest of the
feudal lords and tribal chiefs to preserve and solidify
existing practices because in doing so they retain their privileges
and leadership in the tribe or community.
The customs are evolved in their favour to maintain their overlordship.
Therefore, they give importance to those socio-cultural practices
which were dormant or obsolete. The retention
of tribal pride becomes a cause to revive the old practices. As a
result, women become the victims of the new revivalism. After
conversion to Islam, most of the non-Arab nationalities kept their
ancestral socio-cultural practices intact A crisis was created wJien
there was a clash between Shariat and the customs. Tlie
orthodox ulema condemned the customs
known in Arabic as 'Urf
and exhorted people to abandon them as un-lslamic.
In most cases this appeal was unheard since those customs were
strongly ingrained in the psyche of most people. In
India there was a long unresolved conflict between Shariat and the
local customs. Not only the local Muslim
converts but the foreign origin Muslims also adopted the customs,
especially the customs which were observed at the time of birth,
marriage and death. Women technically observed them in spite of the
warning of the ulema. Throughout
Muslim rule in India, the ulema
lamented against the Hindu practices which were adopted by the Muslims
(All: 146: 1996). la spite of all their
efforts, the ulema failed to purify religion from Indian customs. Customs
and Legislation: As
most of the socio-cultural practices in
India evolved under patriarchal systems, they were detrimental
to women and undermined their role in
the community. In spite of the Muslim
rule in India, the rulers never made an
attempt to implement Shariat fully and
preferred to observe secular principles in
organising the State and its policies. However, the various local
converted tribes, castes and communities restored their customs
concerning women and their social organisation. These
practices were not in favour of women, deprived them of their basic
rights and made them completely dependent on men. No attempt was made
during this period to improve the condition of women. However, in the
British period reformist
movements among the Hindus and Muslims
highlighted the plight of the Indian women and concentrated their
efforts to reform the customs through
legislation. The
dilemma of the Muslim community
is explained by the census report of India 1901. "The
feeling among the Muslim communities was
that due to the assertion of customary laws, the right of Muslim women
had been eroded. However, there was no
clear consensus within the community on how this could be resolved. "(
Latif: 63; 1993) As
a result of this variation, some of the regulations which were passed
in favour of women were not fully appreciated by the different Muslim
communities. For example, the Shariat
Act of 1937, which overrode customary laws and gave right of
inheritance to Muslim women, was not accepted by the majority
of the Indian Muslims.
They continued to settle the matters of
inheritance according to the local
practices and conventions (Lakhandwala:71:19^7).
^Similarly, the case of early marriages
was supported by them and it was claimed^
that it was not against the Islamic
teachings and therefore should not be legislated against. They further
argued that the spread of education and social awareness would
automatically raise
the age of marriage. Hence, legislation
was not required to change the age old practices. The same thing
happened to the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act 1939. State,
Custom and family collude against women. Thus,
the attempt to abolish those customary laws which were against the
basic rights «f
women, was not replaced
with social legislation for two reasons. Firstly few Muslim
communities preferred to abandon the customary laws and ignored the
legislations as antithetical to their
traditional
system. Secondly^
women were not in a position to assert their rights and demand the
implementation of the laws. However, it was one step forward as these
legislations recognised some of the basic rights of women. Section
II: Colonial Period Customary Laws: The
British administration, after its annexation
of the PunJab in 1849, briefly
described the socio-cuUnral and religions
practices in the Village
Administration Papers. Later on due to their administrative requirements,
a detailed study of customary laws of each district of the Punjab
was needed. These reports were based on the questionnaire which was
used by the administrators to examine
the customary laws of the Hindus and the Muslims
separately. They were revived from time to time to study the changes in
them. As
these customary laws were the basis of the social organisation of the
tribes, castes and communities, the policy of the British government
was not to interfere m them. According
to Shahida Latif:
'Those measures were designed
to ensure the preservation and expansion of British interest by streamimingthe
administration and recasting it to the convenience
of the new
rulers' (Latif:23:1993). The
failure of the Reform policy of the British administration
of the 1830s and the occurrence of the 'Mutiny'
made them very sensitive to making any attempt to change these from
above. The motive of this study^
however, was to understand the different patterns of customary laws
organising tribes, castes and communities in the Punjab.
It helped them to administer and rule over them. The
customary laws relating to women which
are mentioned in these reports are: betrothal, marriage, divorce,
dower, resumption of marriage, number of waives,
widow, inheritance, rights of daughters and their issues, sisters and
their issues, abduction, special property of females, wills and gifts.
Hindu and Muslim communities shared some of the customs but there were
dilTcrences as well. The author of
customary law under xxi, observes: "The
Muhammadan law governs questions
relating to marriage and divorce. The Musalmans'
and the Qazi's decision in these questions
is absolute, although the details of marriage ceremonies
and betrothal are based on customs. But in all
questions relating to property, customs based upen
i^er^tance by ^gnatjc
relationship is followed" (Kaul:
10:1908). The
information on the customary laws, which is collected district
^s^, ^ conietee
and brief. No attempt is made to discuss the historical
evaluation of t^^
^peio-cultural practices and their
positive and negative impact on the Kfie
of comi^wnity. In the revised edition,
if change in any practice was related,
it was simply pointed
out without analysing the reason for the
change. We also find the differeire^s
¹ practices and customs from district
to district but these differences
were minor and'ftfrt radical. The motive
of the British administration to compile these customary laws 'appears
to be
to understand the social set up of
communities in order to formulate their administrative policies. By
the Punjab Laws Act of 1872 customs
govern all questions regarding
succession, betrothal, marriage,
divorce, the separate property of women, dower, wills, gifts,
partitions, family relations such as adoption and guardianship, and
religious usages or Institutions,
provided that the custom be not contrary
to justice, equity, or good conscience. On these subjects the Mohammadan
or Hindu law is applied only in the
absence of customs, From
the study of this compilation it also appears
that the socio-cuUural and religious practices
and customs upheld the hierarchical system and strongly retained the
bond of kinship. Under this system, women
remained undermale tutelage throughout
their lives, from their birth to death. The structure of the family
made them dependent upon their male guardians. In
the case of betrothal it was recorded that in every district it was
the practice that the elders of the family decided the fate of the
^iri. Only
in the case of a man, if his father was not alive, could he consent to
about his betrothal. The girl, in any
circumstance, was not allowed to express
her consent (C.L.
aii:8:1916).
Betrothal could take place at anytime after the birth of the girl. The
only condition was that the girl should
be younger than the boy (I bid: 8). Girls
were generally married within a family.
The concept «f
a family consisted of a group of agnate
descendants from a common generation through
males. If a girl married outside the
family, she severed her relations with her
father's family and became a part of her husband's.
Descendants of females were not included in the parental family (C,L.
voLxii: 3:1908). Girls
were married from age twelve to fifteen (C.L.voLxx: 3:1903). Marriage
with a brother's or sister's son was preferred in order to safeguard
the property (lbid:3). It
was also a practice that on the death other
husband, the widow usually married his
brother. If there was no brother, she
married someone from the 'biradari'
(lbid:24). In this case differences of age played no role. The
practice of 'Watta Satta'
(exchange of girls) was prevalent in afl
districts of the Punjab. The custom in
MuzafTargarh was known as the Ambo
Samhava, in which each party betrothed
his girl to the boy of the other party's family.
The second was known as Trebhang, in
which three brothers were married in exchange with one another. The
third was known as the^hobhang, in which
four brothers were married in exchange
for their sisters. In the case of 'Watta
Satta' it was customary to make a
contract on the basis of equal status of families (C.L.vol.-xx:
15; 1903). There were also some relaxations in 'Watta
Satta'. If the other party had no girl
in the family, the cash payment was made instead (C.L.xx:2:1903). In
the case of divorce, religious
and local practices were exploited. The
husband had the right to divorce his wife according to Islamic
practices, but the wife also had the
right to ask for divorce in case of her husband's impotency, or the
contraction of some incurable disease. In the case of change of
religion by either party, marriage was dissolved without formal
divorce. In the local practice if a
woman required divorce, she had to relinquish her 'Mihr'
(dower) or pay some amount to her husband. This practice was known as 'Lunda'.
There were instances that in such cases Rs
50 or 40 or an acre of land was given to her husband (C.L.
xx: 18,22-23:1903).
A divorced wife had no claim against her husband either for
maintenance or for a share in the
property (C.L, xiii:17:1916). There
were variations in matters of 'Mihr'.
The amount also varied. It was either according to Shariat
or one gold 'Mihr'
or more. The wife had the right to
demand it whenever she liked. It was
customary that ornaments which were
presented to the wife at the time of
marriage were taken as Mihr (c.l.xh:
17,18:1908). In
matters of inheritance, religious laws were not followed. Women were
excluded from property inheritance. According to the customary law
report on Lahore district: the Sayyids,
Sheikhs and Kashmirs
of Lahore and Khojas
of Kasur, who had no landed property,
followed Islamic regulations in matters of
inheritance. Otherwise in the presence of male descendants,
daughters were excluded. A widow was not
allowed to have any share if her sons were alive. If the sons were not
alive, or she had no sons then she would inherit the property of her
husband. If she remarried then she had to relinquish her property
rights. She also lost her right ifitwas
proved that she was unchaste (C.L. xiii:
31, 32: 1916; C.L.xx:4, 5:1903). In
practice a widow could become the guardian
of her minor children as long as she did
not remarry. Even marriage -withm
the family retained her right, but in case of marriage outside her
family, she ceased to be the guardian (C.L. xiii :23:1916). As
far as adoption is concerned, there is no scope
in Islamic law, butJn some districts
the Muslim communities were also allowed adoption to safeguard
their ancestral properties. The
mention of two important practices is missing from these reports: the
custom of 'jehez' (dowry) and the
observance of 'purdah'
(veiling). However, it mentions the practice of accepting bride price. In
1854 a census was conducted in the Punjab which covers, besides other
information, prevailing socio-cultural
and religious customs. Later
census reports in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries contain more
information regarding the society of the Punjab. Glossary
of Tribes and Castes: In
'A Glossary of the tribes and castes of
the Punjab aad
North- West Frontier Province', which is
based on the census report forthe
Punjab 1883, there is a chapter on 'Rites
and Ceremonies' separately dealing
with the Hindu and Muslim
communities, It
deals with those socio-cultural and
religious practices which were associated with birth, betrothal,
marriage and death. These practices were common in both Hindus and
Muslim communities. But the Muslims differentiated their practices by
inserting Islamic elements. The most important stage in a woman's life
was to giv« birth to a child. From the
beginning, women had to go through several rituals
to give safe birth to a child, and -to keep the new born away from
evils. The birth of a child was a symbol of fertility in an
agricultural society. The high rate of infant mortality and lack of
medical
care gave rise to rituals and ceremonies to protect women and
children. Superstitions and religious
practices were integrated to give them sanctity. The glossary reports
that, 'As among
Hindus, delivery is usually affected on
the ground, the mother being made to lie
on a quilt with her head to
the north and her feet to the south. She thus faces Meeca'(Glossary:763:1911). The
reaction to the birth of a boy was
different to that of a girL In
the case of a baby girt
some grain was put in a black "handi"
(pot) and it was given to the midwife. However in case of a baby boy,
she was given a rupee( Ibid:
763). Just after the birth, a "mullah" was caHed
to say "Azan" in his orherTight
ear and "takbir" in his w
her left ear. Even after that the mother
was not relieved, but remained under
strict supervision. ' For six days themotherisTiever
left alone, partly to keep away the evil spirits. Amongst the well to
do a lamp is kept burning continuously for forty days'dbid:
765). Sometimes
just after birth, girls would be betrothed. In this case the mother of
the boy would drop one rupee in an
earthen pot (thikri). This
made the engagement irrevocable. It was known as "Thikri Ki
Mangni" (lbid;7(>8).
The motive behind this practice was, probably, to strengthen the
relations between the two families. There were a number
of cultural practices which followed the birth of a child. The mother
and the child had to undergo all these rituals for the sake of safety. The
ceremony of betrothal played a very important role in a family.
It signified the transfer of a girl from the parent's family to the
husband's. TherefOTe, several rituals
and practices were observed to make the
girl a part of the bridegroom's family; to confirm the agreement, a
ring, a ^chadder", and some
ornaments were given lo the girl. They
were Imown as "Nishan".
After confirmation "Dua-i-Khair"(prayer
for goodness) was Tecited. The mingl]^g
of these cultural religious practices made the occasion sober as well
as coloui^i)(Jfoid:
808). The
"irikah" was solemnised according
to religions tenets. It followed a number
of social and cultural observances. For example, 'on
the morning after the "nikah"
the bridegroom and "shahbala"
with their companions are feasted on "khir",
a usage called 'Kanwar
Kalawa'. This follows another ceremony,
"After this sugar on a plate is set
before the bridegroom and he puts some Tnoney
into the plate- an observance called 'Sulu
Arta'. The bride and the bridegroom then
sit before each other and an earthen plate full of water is put
between the pair which contains a silver ring, a nut and some
coins." Both then scramble for their rings in the plate and the
one who gets the ring wins. 'This was
known as 'Juwa Khelna'
or to gamble' (Ibid:
815). The
ceremony of 'Aina Mashuf
was mingled with religious symbols to give sanctity to its
performance. 'When the pair sits down,
a covering of silkw shawl is spread
over them. First of all an open 'Quran*
is put Into their hands as a token of
blessing. Next a looking glass is given
to the pair and for the time they see each other's face in if (lbid:831-32). The
practice to display the dowry wasa^
common. The contents of the dowry were
dependent on the financial status of the
parents. Rich and well to do parents ofTered
more to show their wealth and family
pride. 'Rich folks, th
order to be well spoken of, give 101 clothes, 40 pieces of
cloth, Rs
100 in cash, a palanquin, a box, a small wooden box, utensils, gold
and silver ornaments'(lbid: 827). There
is no evidence that the bridegroom demanded the dowry of his choice.
It depended on the resources of the bride's family
to present what they considered best for their daughter. Most
of the socio-cultural practices
originated from the agriculturist society of the Pui^ab.
The rituals, ceremonies, and customs which were observed at the time
of betrothal, marriage, and birth
indicated their significance in society. They led to the setting up of
another family with the expectations to have more children for a
prosperous life. The fertility of the"
woman was regarded as important for the
family. Infertility was shameful for the woman. It was her
responsibility to produce heirs for the family. Most
of the religious practices observed were intended for blessing and
sanctity. The motive was to make the match successful in life.
Those ceremonies and celebrations also
provided an opportunity to teHthe
members of the bride to participate, to bwy
their differences and to strengthen the bond oflanshap. TJie
impact of those socio-cultural and
religious practices on the woman was to
determine her status, which was decided by the society^ndlegitinrisediJy
rituals and ceremonies. She^iad to
depend on male protection and bad no rights. It appears that divorce
was very rare. The reasons
were^he involvement of families,
expenditure, and, most important
of all, the submission of women. The other factor in the prevention of
divorce was the opportunity for a man to marry again and to have two, three
or four wives. The first wife had to accept her fate as she had no place
to go. Moreover, religion allowed polygamy to which women could not
object Also, family honour restrained
her 'Khula' from demanding. Financial
consideration also forced her to accept her fate. The
chapter on 'Customs and observations' in
Wikeley's book 'Punjabi
Musalmans' (1915) deals with some of
these practices which are not mentioned in the Glossary of Tribes and
Castes. Regarding marriage he observes that either
marriage took place within the family or in case of outside the family
or tribe, higher status was chosen, especially, the husband's family
should be either equal or higher in
status (Wikeley;35:1915).
High status of the male guaranteed the nobility of the family. Although
there were no restrictions on solemnising a wedding, it was forbidden
during the month of Moharram,
on the Ids, during the first thirteen
days of the month of saflar, and 3rd,
8th, 13th, 18th, 23rd and 28th days of other months (lbid:39). Widow
marriage among the higher castes and families was not regarded as
favourable and considered a 'sin of good
hearing' (lhid:30).
Although religion sanctions widow marriage, social practices overruled
it. This highlights the power of patriarchy and property. 'Purdah'
(veiling) was observed among the affluent families; the Sayyids
and the Qureshis were particular
to maintain it in their family (lbid.'40). The
Muslims followed Hindu practices in relation to inheritance.
Succession of landed property was regulated
by two rules. Pagribund, when the
property was divided equally among the sons; 'Chadarband\
when the property was divided among the
wives so that the offsprings of each "wife
could get an equal share. However this
was in the case where the deceased had more than
one wife. The practice prevented disputes among the heirs belonging to
different wives. When
a widow didn't have any son, she could
inherit the property which later on would ^o
to the daughter or to a distant
collateral male line. The daughter
rarely got a share in landed property. Only
in cases when the father gave her a share during his life or she got a
piece of land in her dowry did she have
property (I bid: 42,43). This shows that if ever she got a share it
was not because of her right but as a favour. The
Imperial Gazetteer of India (Punfab vol.
l&
2) and the District Gazettes of the Pui^ab
also contain material on socio-cultural
and religious practices. The Gazetteer of the Lahore
District describes the confinement of^vomen
in their houses and their entanglement in household
work, which has become a part of social
norms. On the position of women ^nrongthe
agriculturists it isinentioned that 'they
are used more as domestic servants than
as companions of their lords and masters; their
time from morning till night is fully
occupied in sweeping the house, grinding corn,
milking
the cows,
churning butter, warming it to convert
it to 'ghi’, cooking
and carrying food to their relations working
in the fields, fetching water, making thread
from raw cotton for home consumption, sewing,
picking cotton from
the plants, collecting vegetables; and in the harvest time
they often thrash the corn for daily use, manufacture
fuel by drying cowdung in cakes, carry
flour to large villages, where they
barter it for chillies, salts etc.; these and various other
occupations take their entire time, and it
is a rare thing to find a cultivator as a bachelor, for without such a
helpmate, his work m the field would be
much retarded. The higher functions of the wife, however are not
unknown. In addition to the duties already detailed, she generally
keeps the household purse and endeavours in every way to prevent her
lord from extravagance. She also has the management of family
marriages; and if a clever woman, her husband, if only for his
comfort, has to keep her in good humour'
(Gazetteer of the Lahore District 1883-84:1989). Parakash
Tandon's 'Punjabi
Country'^1961) interestingly points out
the transformation of the traditional Punjabi
society up to the colonial period.
Although the detail of the socio-cultural
practices is related to the Hindu society,
it gives an insight into how change has taken place in the Puiu^b. Denzal
lbbetson's 'Punjabi
Castes' is a mine of mformatioa
on the social structure of Punjabi
tribes and castes. It provides an insight into the evolution of socio-culturai
customs in different tribes and castes and how different branches
of these tribes retained their traditional customs even after
conversion to Islam. The information also leads to the conclusion that
once socio-cultural customs become a part of tribal social
organisation and a matter of pride, it becomes difficult to change
them. Religious sanctions and different acts passed by the government
failed to uproot them. 'Muslim
women in Punjab' (1872- 1947) by Dushka
Sayyid is under the process of
publishing by the ASR publication Lahore
and is expected to be ready by 1996-
1997 It appears from the brochure of ASR a women's NGO,
that it deals more with the women of upper class and middle class
rather than rural or peasant women. It also looks
into the process of the politicisation
of women «nd their struggle against the
socio-cultural and religious practices which hampered
their emancipation. The
socio-cultural and religious practices which prevailed in the Punjab
during the 19th and early 20th centuries
are carefully recorded in the reports.
They help us to understand the status and subjugation of
women in society. We find that traditional family
structure was hierarchical and
male-dominated which curbed the
independence and rights of"women.
It was generally believed that the male-elders had more wisdom as they
were more experienced and knowledgeable. Therefore, it was incumbent
upon young girls and women to recognise their authority and follow
their decisions.
Women were expected to be virtuous,
submissive and obedient, so in the case of their betrothal and
marriage, they played no role. Everything was decided by their elders.
Restrictions and the rigidity of the family
structure strangled their intellectual
growth so much so that they accepted their status as natural. The
custom of early marriage proved a great impediment
in a woman's progress. She got no opportunity and time to educate
herself or to be professionally trained.
Education was thought to be useless for a woman as she had to stay at
home dependent on men. Illiteracy and lack of social awareness led to
her domestication. The birth of children
at an early age affected
her health. Housework confined her horizons to the walls of the
home. Even the sources of enjoyment and
amusement were limited and rarely could
she express her joy freely. It
has been argued that lack of education
is one of the main reasons for a successful marriage. As an uneducated
woman she is unaware other rights and so
accepts male dominance without any challenge. Under the fear of
violating the socio-cuitural practices,
she succumbs to the desires and authority
of her husband. The marriage might appear successful from the outside,
but the insidious details are often not ascertained. Divorce and
separation were dishonourable acts and put a woman through immense
torture. A divorced woman had no place to go. Neither the father's
family nor the husband's family would accept her after divorce. In
the practice of 'watta-satta' a woman is
regarded as a property. Its purpose was to strengthen the relations
with the other family and the woman was given in exchange like a
commodity. The practice perhaps
originated in those tribes where the ratio of women was less than men.
In some cases it was the only way to get a wife in exchange for his
sister or some other girl from the family. Generally in watta-satta
the age of both the boy and girl was not important. However, the
exchange took place between families of equal status. The
family following the practice saved cash, which they had to pay if the
girl was not available in the family.
However, evidence suggests that girls in both families
were regarded as hostages. In case of maltreatment
of one, the other had to counter it. The practice of 'watta-satta'
definitely put the fate of the two wives in serious jeopardy.
Unfortunately the practice has not yet taught any lesson and it is
still followed with its negative results. Socio-cuitural
and religious practices never provided financial support to women. 'Mihr'
(bride money) which was fixed at the time of marriage gave no
guarantee for financial independence to women. Generally
Mihr was fixed in the light of religious
practice which is a negligible amount. Only the well-to-do kept high
mihr to show off their wealth. It was also a general practice that
gifts and jewellery presented to women were considered as part of the
mihr. In practice, however, mihr was
rarely paid to the wife. She was persuaded to forego her right in
favour of her husband which was regarded as a virtuous act. Though
religion allows the deduction of the amount
of 'Mihr' from the deceased
husband's property, sociat
pressures forced her to surrender her
right upon the death other husband. As
far as inheritance was
concerned, she
was disinherited, although religion
allows her a share in the property. But
here social practice was followed. In an agricultural society land, is
the source of production and wealth. It keeps the
family's identity. As a girl were not considered a part of the
parent's family but that of the husband's family, as an 'outsider'
she was not allowed to take her share outside the family.
It was also in the interest of the British adnnnistration
to keep landed property undivided and therefore
the Land Alienation Act (1901) protected landed property and saved the
feudal class
from annihilation. Hence the feudals
supported the British interests. In the absence of a male successor she
got the legal right over the property but had no social recognition.
Even mere possession of a piece of land gave her no control over its
resources (Agarwal: 14:1994). The
argument put forth rests on the fact that the stability of the tribal
Punjabi kinship depended on the exclusion of women from their father's
property. This social structure served the British interest so they
defended it As Agarwal points out women's interests were subordinate
to political interests (Agarwal:228:1994).
Even the introduction of the Shariat Law
1937 which abrogated the prevailing
practices and customs in favour of the Muslim Personal Law,
excluded from its purview the agricultural land which continued to be
governed by social customs and practices
(Agarwal;230;
1994). Section:
III Post
Colonial; As
pointed out earlier,
the codification and assessment of the socio-aittaral
and religious practices and institutions was done during the Colonial
period for administrative Teasons.
It was required that after the tndependence
a new study should be made to restructure society. It had the intention
of bringing reforms regarding women who were the victims
of these practices. The only worthwhile book is written by Irshad
Punjabi entitled ^Punjab
Ki Auraf
(Punjabi Women). Irshad Pui^abi
was not a historian nor was he a
sociologist or an anthropologist. He was a man of letters. He collected
immense material regarding socio-cultural
and religious practices which are prevailing
in the PuBQab with the
help of folk lores'
songs, and proverbs. Irshad Punjabi's weakness is his romanticism.
He adores every custom, glorifies every ceremony and abhors change.
He firmly believes in the preservation of traditional values. Whenever
he observes change he laments. He does not want the romantic village
life to disappear. The result of this romanticism is that he fails to
detect the plight, misery and woeful
condition of women. He accepts the role of women in society, which is
determined try
traditions. He sees everything from a distance and romanticises
it. To him, the songs sung by women in the early
morning while they are grinding wheat appear beautiful. But he fails
to consider the agony of women in waking up early in the morning to do
their tedious work, which is considered shameful for men. He is not
pleased with flour mills
"which replaced the 'chakki'
and relieved women from hard and boring labour. He
supports patriarchy and considers the tutelage of a male important
for female protection.
Brothers give 'Dupatta* to their sisters
to signify their support. A girl
with seven brothers is known as 'Sat
Barai' (seven
brothers), and it is a matter of pride.
Girls without
toothers
are regarded
as being
protectionless (Pumabi:
176:1976). He prefers to use the traditional term of 'Poke'
instead of 'Mefee', the family of girls' parents,
because 'Poke'
represents father which is more natural
than meke which
identifies with mother (lbid:417). There
is great detail of those customs and practices which give a realisation
to girls that they are a burden to their
families. Tlie
birth of a girl is not "welcomed as
is indicated by two Punjabi proverbs: '
daughter js
an unwelcome guest'
and 'as
soon as a giri is bwn
you hear lamentation from every side'.
She is regarded as 'amanat'
or the property of others. She is guarded and protected so as
to hand her over to her
filture husband as a blameless
virgin (Punjabi:
314:1976).
She is trained in household work and deprived of education. Education
is considered a bad investment since the family doesn't get any
benefit out of it It
appears from PHujafci's descriptron
that parents have to give something to
their daughter on all occasions even
after marriage. These practices
are known as 'Maldaway', "Tarwenday',
and 'Satwendy'. Parents have to give
either in cash or something in kind.
Another such practice is called 'Wartan
Bhanyi' in which all
the relatives of the girl give something according to their status
in relation to the married girl (Ibid:
147,149). If the family of the girl ^ives
more gifts, she is called 'a girl
having strong back' to mean background
(I bid; 150).
These practices even though they keep girls in
contact with their families, become an unbearable
burden for the parents; especially if they are poor. The girl's status
In law is also determined on the basis
of what she gets from her family.
Traditions do not allow accepting
anything from the daughter. Even parents and brothers avoid eating at
her house (Ibid: 164). The
socio-cultural practices observed on
the occasion of marriage indicate the status of women. As soon
as the girl is betrothed she is called 'Mang'.
It means that she has been reserved for somebody. After the fixation
of the wedding date red, white and yellow threads are sent to the relatives to convey the
message of their ties. Once the date is fixed, the girl is not allowed
to leave the house. This was known as 'Sahe
Bandhi'. In dowry the girl is
always given things which are required for household use. The display
of dowry is known as 'Khat Dikham'
(Ibid; 40). Landed property is not transferred
to her name.
There is no limit in 'Mihr'. Besides
cash sometimes animals, such as ftorses,
buffaloes and cows are fixed as Mihr.
Sometimes a part of land is also
transferred; she becomes the owner and has the right
to sell, mortgage or transfer it (Ibid; 148,150,307,318,332^3). Punjabi
gives one more reason for the practice of^Watta
Satta' which we mentioned earlier.
He says that in the case of a boy who is stupid and useless and nobody
is ready to give the hand of his
daughter to him, he can be married by 'Watta
Satta' (lbid.'329). The purchase of the
bride is called 'Take'.
In this case a part of the amount is given before the wedding and the
rest is paid afterwards (lbid:33). The
^Sohagan' (whose husband is alive)
plays an important role and takes part in different
ceremonies. She is regarded as fortunate
and her blessings are given
to the newly wed giri. For example,
seven 'Sohagan' women rub 'hena'
on the palms of the liride and at the
time of bride's segregation before marriage '(Mayun)'
again seven 'Sohagan'
women help to organise this ceremony
(lbid:312,352). A widow is not allowed
to be present on these ceremonies. She is condemned and cursed. It is
common to say that she devours her husband.
Tire bride is expected to produce
children to increase family strength. Such women are proudly called 'sat
pati' or the mother of heroes. Women
observe 'pwdafr'.
They- bide
their faces'
either with
a- 'D«patt»'
w'Chadder'. Generally
they don't appear without covering
their faces before their father- in- law or other male relatives. It
is not considered respectable to go
outside the house and those women who
visit their neighbours frequently are sarcastically called 'Cat
of Seven houses' (lbid;581). It
is considered a matter of shame for women to eat their meals before
men. This practice indicates the secondary'
position of women. The same practice is followed in feasts and on
other occasions (lbid:517).
This practice could have malnutrition effects particularly on girls. A
girl receives less food than her brother. Poor nutrition as a child,
and later at puberty, can result in anaemia, a normal condition for
most Pakistani women. Social
customs and practices strengthen the patriarchal system and form the
character of a woman in such a way that she can successfully play the
role of a subordinate human being. It is argued that in patriarchy a
woman is protected and it is man's responsibility to earn and provide
finances. She remains unpolluted from the worries and miseries of the
outer world. However, it is a heavy price for such a security which
secludes a woman and makes her dependent on her male protector. This
reduces her role and importance in worldly
matters. In
the rural areas girls are regarded as the honour of the village and
are called 'Dhai Dhiyani'. If there is
a conflict between two parties and a girl comes in between and asks
them to resolve their differences, they
immediately make peace showing their respect to her interference. On
the other hand, cultural practices also play a positive role in women's
lives. They are a source of enjoyment for them. Dance, songs and other
cultural activities bring them together in one place and relieve them
from the agony of a segregated life. These cultural practices not only
allow them to participate but also to express their creativity. They
compose songs, rhymes, and invent new types of dances. In the cultural
domain they rule and resist any interference. In spite of the pressure
from orthodoxy against these cultural
practices women continued to defy them. The
changes which have taken place in the socio-cultural
structure of the Punjabi society are discussed in 'Culture,
class and development in Pakistan: the emergence of an Industrial
bourgeoisie in Punjab' by Anita
M. Weiss
(1991). The restructuring of the social values indicates the emergence
of a wide gap between the rural and urban areas. Analysis: After
the partition of 1947 the social structure of the Punjab changed. The
province was divided into two parts. Unprecedented migration took
place which excluded Muslims from the Eastern part and Hindus from the
Western. This exclusiveness had an impact on Punjabi society. In
western Punjab, i.e. Pakistan, Muslim identity which remained dormant
during the colonial period w^as
awakened and reinforced by the communal riots of 1947. This made
ground for the political parties which were relying on the religious
factor for the mobilisation of people in order to grasp power. It
also encouraged religious elements to launch a movement against un-lslamic
practices and replace them with religious customs. Since
the partition, a number of changes took place which transformed the
Punjab completely. The communication system has affected the social
structure. The linkage of rural areas to urban centres exposed them to
new ideas and concepts. Villages and cities not only absorb the new
comers but also weaken their tribal and 'bradari'
roots. The religious parties offer a sense of security to the poor,
jobless and identityless people. This
security, religious identity and pride on piety place them higher than
the affluent elite class. They have contempt against the rich who
imitate western culture. They derive their pride from religious
institutions and traditions. They are the ones who fight against the socio-cultural
practices which are un- Islamic and
propagated pure Islamic teachings. The
other trend is the resurgence of Punjabi nationalism which revived
tribal identities. Under its influence old sauce-cultural practices
are becoming fashionable. However there are a number of other factors
which are constantly changing the life pattern of the Punjab. The
growth of population, economic problems, and political and social
awareness are other factors of change. The
important social institution of the joint family system is breaking
apart. Once the extended family was a source of social control. Girls
living in a joint family were watched and it was not possible for them
to rebel, break, or abandon the socio-cultural customs which were
regarded as family honour. It was their duty to observe them. The
break up of joint family system relatively liberates women from this
vigilance. The
institution of 'purdah'
is an effective tool for segregation in both public and private
places, and excludes women from the public eye. The distinction
between the public and private spheres has meant that women have less
access to information, education and employment as their activities
are confined to the private sphere, i.e. their home. 'Purdah'
has become a symbol of social status and confirms
the dominant social status of the man. Most Pakistani women do not
have their own identity, and they derive their position from a man
whose wife, daughter, sister, or mother they may be. The culture in
which they are immersed dictates that all 'decent'
women remain in their houses and be completely covered from head to
foot if they go out. The
custom of 'Purdah'
is also losing its grip. Peasant women could never afford such a
restriction since they work outside the house from dawn to dusk. Their
daily routine of work has not changed since time immemorial. The 'purdah'
they observe is to hide their face, not the whole body. It is unlike
the custom in upper classes where seclusion and segregation from the
basis of 'Purdah'. The
practice of 'Purdah'
is related to family honour and protection of property. It reduces
women access to education, deprives them of the control of their
property, rules
out divorce or remarriage, and thus reduces their economic
independence (Latif: 77:1993). However,
the practice of 'purdah'
is weakening under economic and social pressures. Except for the top
notch feudals who keep their women
under strict 'purdah',
the other sections of the society are relaxing it. There are
co-educational institutions where girls and boys from upper and middle
class study together. Gradually girls are entering different
professions and are competing with men. There
is change in the practice of dowry. Initially there was no demand as
to what should be included, but now the family of the bridegroom
demands a number of things in dowry. In the family of the bridegroom
the wife's respect depends on the size and cost of her dowry.
Sometimes it leads to insatiable greed when the husband and his family
continue to demand even after marriage. Brides are burnt if they
cannot keep up with the dowry demands of the bridegroom's family. The
number of such incidences is increasing rapidly. Rajarawan,
writing on the custom of dowry, observes that it has become strong
when the house work of women, their child bearing and capacity to
increase family income is outweighed by consumption costs of feeding
and clothing. Dowry is the 'value of
the cost supporting a woman over a life time if female earnings drop
to zero' (Mies: 158:1994). Maria Mies,
reflecting on this argument WTites, 'Historically
and structurally, dowry has nothing to do with compensation for
providing the bride with her life long subsistence. It is indeed a
kind of tribute from the bride giving family to the bride receiving
family. The tribute is demanded to give the honour to admit the girl
in their family' (Mies: 160:1994). She
further writes that dowry shows unequal status. One side commands (the
woman, goods, money, services, offsprings) and the other side has to
supply those goods. ' All the giving
side receives is the honour of having given the daughter to such and
such man' (Mies: 161:1994). To
get more dowry new concepts have evolved by the interested parties.
Some argue that what they invest in the education of their sons they
should get back in the form of dowry. This is the reason that doctors,
engineers, and civil servants demand more in comparison to others.
However, parents' investment in girls and boys education is becoming
the same, therefore if girls have the same qualifications as boys, the
argument to give dowry is refuted. With the rising pressure of dowry,
educated girls in urban centres buy their own dowries after getting
employment so they don't become the burden on their parents. These
customs create enormous financial and social problems in the family.
Sometimes fathers, after retirement spend their entire Gratuity or
commuted pension on dowry and face poverty and starvation for the rest
of their lives. Thus women are viewed
as financial liabilities with nothing to contribute towards the
welfare of the family. Before marriage a woman is kept in trust by her
family where she attends to the washing and cleaning and taking care
of younger siblings. Marriage becomes
the only vocation in life for most Pakistani girls. In fact the view
that marriage will give women greater freedom is widespread. Marriage
is therefore viewed as the only outlet, and young girls are given in
marriage at an early age, even though legislation prohibits the
marriage of girls below the age of
sixteen. The practice of child brides combined with dowry has resulted
in many parents getting into heavy debt. The
marriage pattern is also changing. Boys prefer to marry educated girls
who are as qualified as they are. If education can raise the status of
women, there is no need of any dowry. In the urban centres changing
economic conditions have wrestled with traditional mores to produce a
new matrix of socially acceptable behaviour. A minority of women have
worked their way up into the higher echelons of government. By
breaking new ground, such women have helped change attitudes towards
women in general. But these women form only a small minority whose
privileges stem from their class background and its attendant
opportunities. The status of women is undermined as a result of a
strong patriarchal system and mere qualifications
cannot raise their status without uprooting patriarchy. The
argument in favour of dowry is that what the parents give their
daughter they get back when their sons marry (Mies:
158:1994). The question arises where somebody has no son? Moreover one
evil cannot be replaced by another evil. It is evident that the custom
of dowry makes a daughter burdensome and that's why the birth of a
girl is considered unwelcome. The
custom to get money for a bride is not common in the Punjab, however
it is still practised in some families. According to Maria Mies, it
originated from matrilineal traditions
and is regarded as compensation for the loss of women's contribution
to family income (Mies: 161:1994). In families it is a disgrace to
give the hand of the girl without
anything. To prove that she is worth something a sum is demanded
according to the status of the family. This matrilineal tradition was
reversed under patriarchy. It is just like a deal between masters and
slaves. It subjugates a woman to those who paid for her. She becomes a
commodity. The bride money makes her completely subordinate to the
husband's family. In
the feudal families girls are excluded from the property on the plea
that they get their share as dowry. After marriage the dowry becomes a
part of the husband's household and she becomes financially
viable. Empirical
studies show that 70"/o - 80°/o
of rural women work in recognisable economically productive tasks but
in the division of economic power this is hardly apparent. Women are
not counted as agriculture workers because land is never leased out in
the name of a woman. Moreover, when women are employed as agricultural
labour, e.g. during the peak season, the male head of the family
receives all the payments for the labour of his wife and children. The
Agricultural Census Data and Labour Force Surveys point to a rising
proportion of women in agriculture. Surveys of female participation in
family farms indicate that the labour force participation rates for
female aged ten years and above increased from 39"/o
in 1972 to 54% in 1980. More recent labour statistics show an upward trend
in the category of agriculture workers from 14.5**/o
in 1984-85 to 16.6 in 1987-88. This
upward trend is attributed to the 'feminisation'
of agriculture and reduction in the available male labour for
agriculture. This is due to the migration of males to urban areas and
to the gulf region, as well as men increasingly taking on non-
farm occupations. In this way women were left with the responsibility
of managing farm production and taking care of the family. Women
not only remain within the least skilled, low level, jobs, but they
are also discriminated against in being denied access to more skilled
jobs. Even in a factory women are allotted jobs such as packing and
sorting, while men are responsible for handling machines as this is
considered to be a 'heavier'
job. The menial jobs done by women, however, are often physically 'heavier'
than operating a machine. Women are also not allocated supervisory
jobs as men do not accept supervision from women. Women
workers are employed in the informal sector as cleaners, sweepers,
domestic servants, attendants and so on. They are unprotected by
legislation, their sen-ice is insecure
and their hours of work are not regulated. This work has remained
invisible and no data exists as to its extent or the degree of
exploitation of workers in this sector.
Women may work in private homes as sendee
personnel, but no woman works in a Pakistani restaurant. Women are
also absent from vegetable and cattle markets. Women are precluded
from being exposed to men and from participating in financial
transactions in their work. These disabilities are justified by
quoting cultural norms and the household responsibilities of women. The
increasing importance of cultural norms can be seen as the main reason
in the low representation of women in jobs that involve contact with
men. Although, inroads are being made, progress is very slow. Educated
women are concentrated in 'respectable'
jobs such as teaching or medicine. Others prefer to forgo the income
and remain within the respectable confines
of their homes to avoid the loss of status associated with female
employment in most jobs outside the home. In
rural areas in particular the facilities available for a girl to
pursue education are virtually non-existent. Parents have to send
their girl children to neighbouring villages if they want them to be
educated. But this rarely happens and it is attributed to an attitude
towards education. There the privilege
of gaining knowledge and power is not considered necessary for girls.
It is feared that education would expose them to undesirable ideas. A
girl's labour is viewed as being required in the home. Besides most
girls stop going to school when they reach puberty. Such views
and practices are believed to be a part and parcel of Islamic culture. 'The
educational provisions of the Shariah
Bill are an insidious way of reproducing the class cultural power of
the dominant classes and ideology of subordination for the
underprivileged' (Pakistan:72,
73, 74:1990). Section:
III NGO Reports: After
studying the socio-cultural and
religious customs and practices we pose a question: do past customs
and practices continue to exist or do they change in their structure?
As far as religious customs are concerned, they remain unaltered; for
example the procedure ofNikah, Talaq,
Khula and lddat
is the same. However, there are some changes in socio-cultural
practices such as child marriage which is becoming rare, remarriage of
a widow is now acceptable, and purdah or seclusion of women is losing
its ground. But still women are excluded from landed property anil
are rarely given their share according to Shariat. In
Muslim society the conflict between Shariat and socio-cultural customs
still exists. In the Punjab socio-cultural customs maintain their
superiority over Shariat. This is because the social structure of
rural Punjabi society was controlled by feudals,
tribal chiefs and the elders on the basis of their ancestral and
traditional customs. The 'Mulla' or the
'Mualvi' had no power and influence in
society and was regarded as a 'Kammi'.
He had no courage to issue any Fatwa
against the social norms of the society. Even in the urban centres his
social status was not high. Therefore, in 1961 when the Muslim Family
Laws ordinance was implemented the ulema
failed to counter it. However,
as a result of political instability in the 1970s the situation
changed in the country. Huge funding from the rich Arab states was
presented to religious parties, associations, 'madrassas'
and individual 'maulvis' which made
them an active force in society. In Zia
ul Haq's
reign they found a patron who was enthusiastic to implement Shariat
and support them in their efforts to
convert the institutions of the state into religious ones. The Hudud
Ordinances, which were promulgated during this period, greatly
weakened the position of women. Cases of violence against women, rape,
acid burning, stove burning, beating and kidnapping increased and
became more frequent. Therefore,
keeping these changes in view, there is a need to study socio-cultural
practices verses statutory laws. Unfortunately, so far no
comprehensive study is conducted by any NGO. Shirkat
Gah published a 'Chart
of Customary Practices in Pakistan in Comparison with Statutory Law'
(1995). This study compares the customary practices of the four
provinces of Pakistan with the statutory laws. The study lacks
analysis of the practices, historical background of their origin,
development and change. However, the study could be useful for the
present project as the customs in the context of colonial Punjab have
already been discussed and the changes could be pointed out by reading
the chart, especially the resurgence of religious practices as a
result of the increasing influence of the 'Mulla'.
For example, in the rural areas, the consent of a girl is still not
considered in the selection of her husband;
in the urban centres, on the contrary, the majority of educated
families allow girls to express their consent in choosing their life
partners. In the countryside marriage within the tribe or castes is
common, but in the cities the custom to marry on the basis of 'Kafu'
is losing its strength and caste or 'zat'
is not an important factor. The economic conditions of the family and
the moral character of the boy are two important considerations which
persuade a girl's family to accept the offer. Owing to financial
constraints, polygamy is not practised and is only confined
to feudals and rich people. Divorce
and 'Khula' are not common in the rural
areas because both families are involved and 'Watta
Satta' also restrains them. In the case
of adultery, either the husband divorces immediately or in some areas
of Southern Punjab where the Baluch
tribes are populated, 'Karo Kari'
is practised in which the accused man and woman are killed.
Restrictions on widow marriage are also relaxed. There is a
continuation of tradition in w^hich
young widows are married to their brothers- in-law. It is also pointed
out that the religious practice of 'Hilala'
is rare in the Punjab. Women
are still excluded from inheriting the landed and immovable property,
but like Sindh, in the Punjab girls are
forced to marry the Holy Quran which is
called Haq Bakhshwana.
In some cases they are not married at all. This is done in order to
save property. Generally,
women are not allowed to go to the mosque to pray or to become an Imarn'
or 'Muzzam'. However, within their own
circle they are free to perform those religious practices. Violence
against women is rapidly increasing due to psychological, social, and
economic reasons. The Hudud Ordinance
has proved most degrading for them. The Law does not protect women in
case of beating or sexual harassment.
In case of murder or suspicion of adultery the man is protected by
social norms and his actions are justified,
even glorified at times. In the case of rape, the man is set free if
four witnesses are not produced, while the woman is punished because
she fails to produce evidence. The vulnerability of a woman makes her
an easy victim of violence. This is evident from the daily newspapers
which publish news about violence against w^omen
in every part of the Punjab. The
Simorgh, a collective women's NGO,
recently published a report In the
Court of Women' (1995). It consists of
the tribunal proceedings held in 1993-94 at Lahore which heard the
testimonies of those women who became victims of different sorts of
violence including violence in the name of socio-cultural
and religious customs. In the case of Pakistan, Hina
Jilani's observations expose the extent
of violence which women suffer. The
Punjab is no exception. As
we have seen in the Reports of Customary Laws, Glossary of Tribes and
Castes and 'Punjab ki
Aurat, divorce is mentioned, but it is
not practised generally because it
involves the families of the boy and girl. This deters the couple from
divorce. Among the respectable families it was very rare. Among other
castes it was resorted to the case of adultery. In some tribes if a
man was caught having an illicit affair with a woman he would be
pardoned if he paid a heavy fine (C.L.xxi:6:1908). As
there was no break up of the family, the custody of children never
arose as a crucial problem. Similarly,
the cases of 'Hilala' are not
mentioned. In some parts of the Punjab, Kidnapping of women occurred,
but the kidnapped women were accepted by the family or tribe. Among
the pathans of Mianwali
districts, 'If a man abducts a virgin
or a widow he is liable to give two 'sharams'
(girls) in return,'
if the abducted person is married he has to give her four '
sharams' (girls) with or without
damages. In case of the abductor having no woman in the family to
give, he has to pay compensation in cash'
(C.L. xxi:
13:1908). Socio-cultural
customs and practices have deep roots and deviation from them is
tantamount to rebellion. Therefore, whenever there is a challenge to
customs by enacting statutory laws in order to curtail their influence
or abolish them, ways and means are invented to continue their
application; for example, when the display of dowry was banned, people
started sending it before the wedding ceremony to the bridegroom's
house. Similarly, when the number of guests was limited at wedding
feasts, food was offered in groups to avoid the ban. Whenever
social customs are attached with 'honour'
it becomes difficult to get rid of them. There is pressure from the
family, 'biradri',
and from the whole society to follow the practices, in spite of
personal dislike. Therefore, to fight in order to abolish out-dated
and backward customs, a two pronged policy could be applicable: by
educating people and by enforcing laws forcefully. Thus to change the
attitude and behaviours of a society and to shape the mind of young
generation, primary and secondary education is very important. To
change the education system there is a need to write new text books,
keeping in perspective gender roles and exposing those socio-cultural
practices which are antithetical to progress. The
other factors for effecting social change are radio, T.V,
theatre, cinema, newspapers and general books. Political parties and
pressure groups can also assist in the mobilisation for change.
Pressure from the government to pass laws which are against the
interest of women and their strong implementation is needed. Bibliography: Section
1: Introduction: Theory and Concepts Ali,
Mubarak: (1996) 'Tarikh
aur Auraf
, Lahore. Darling, F:
(1980) 'Westernization of Asia'
, Schenkman. Engles,
F: (1951)'The Origin of Family', The
Women Question, Selections from the writings
of Marx, Lenin, Stalin and Engles. Abeyesekera,
Sunila: (1995) 'On
the Violence of Patriarchy', In: In the
Court of Women, published by Simorgh,
Lahore. Latif,
Shahida:(1990)'Muslim
women in India; political and
private realities', Zed Press
London. Lokhandwala,
S.T:(1987)'The
Position of Women under Islam';
introduction: Status of
Women in Islam, edited
by Asghar Ali Engineer, Ajauta
publication, Delhi. Marx,
K :(1976) Collected works, vol. II, Moscow. Mies,
Maria: (1994)'Patriarchy and Accumulation on a World Scale'
, Zed Press London. Trigger,
Bruce G.
: (1993) 'A
History of Archaeological Thought',
Cambridge Universuity
Press, Britain. Section
II: Colonial
Period Bolster,
R. C:(1916)'Customary
Law of the District Lahore' ,
vol. xiii, Lahore. Dushka,
Sayyid: (forthcoming) 'Muslim
Women in Punjab' ,
ASR Lahore (1872- 1947). (1989)
Gazetteer of the Lahore District
1883-1884, Lahore. lbbetson:
(1978)'A Glossary of the Tribes and Castes of the Punjab and
North-West Provinces,
Lahore. •_
(1986) 'Punjabi Castes' Lahore. ____:
(1883)'Punjab
Census Reports', vol. 1<&lll,
Calcutta. (1989) Imperial Gazetteer of
the Lahore District 1883- 84 , Lahore. Kaul,
P.H.K: (1908) 'Customary'
Laws ofMuzafTargarh District',
vol. xx, Lahore. __________
:(1908)'Customary
Laws ofMianwali District',
vol. xxi, Lahore. Rose, H.A.:
(1983) 'Rites and ceremonies of Hindus
and Muslims' , New Delhi. Tandon,
Prakash: (1961) 'Punjabi
Century, London. Section
III: Post Colonial Period Ghazali,
A. : 'Sandal
Bar , Lahore (N.
A). Punjabi, Irshad :(1968)'Punjabi Nama'
, Lahore. _____
: (1976)'Punjab Ki
Aurat, Lahore. Pakistan: (1995) Published
by Friedrich Ebert
Stiftung Islamabad. Weiss,
A.M :(1991)
'Culture, class and development in
Pakistan: the emergence of an Industrial
bourgeoisie in Punjab', Bonder,
Colorado, Westview. Section
IV: Reports Shirkat
Gah / WLUML,(1995)
Women and Law Pakistan Country Project: 'Chart
of Customary Practices in Pakistan in Comparison with statutory Law'
, S.P at
Creative Design, Lahore. Simorgh:(1995)
'In the Court of Women'
, the Lahore Tribunal on Violence Against Women
1993-94, Lahore. Legal
rights of Women, Report of a Seminar and Worldnet
Dialogue organised by the USIS, ed.
by David H. Kennedy, published by United
States Publishing Service ,
Islamabad (1992).
|