| Wantlist Year 5 |
| So Soft Ponies Angel Crumpet Taffy Bangles Twilight |
| Twinkle-Eyed Ponies Mimic |
| Twice As Fancy Ponies Love Melody |
| Flutter Ponies WIngsong Tropical Breeze Wind Drifter Cloud Puff |
| Princess Ponies and Bushwoolies ~No Princess Ponies~ Friendly Eager Cheery Chumster Wishful Hugster |
 |
| Want to go back home? Jump on! |
| Baby Ponies with First Tooth Baby Fifi |
| Big Brother Ponies 4-Speed |
| Newborn Twins Sniffles Snookums Milkweed Tumbleweed Nibbles Doodles Noodles Rattles Tattles Jangles Tangles |
| Sea Sparkle Baby Sea Ponies Surfy Sea Spray Dipper Sea Breeze Salty |
| Pony Friends Creamsicle the Giraffe Zig Zag the Zebra Spunky the Camel Kingsley the Lion |
| Ponies who came with Playsets/Accesories Baby Crumpet Satin Slipper Sweet Shoppe Pony Purse |
| Soft Sleepy Newborns Sweet Dreams Hushabye Pink Dreams |
| Slumber Party Gift Pack Pillow Talk Pink Dreams Nightcap Sleepy Head Sleep Tight |