Make Six Trait Writing Fun
Sandra O'Berry
Don't need convincing, go straight to Writing and Art activities.
Reasons to Think about Making Writing Fun
When everyone needs a break from using picture books to teach narrative writing, make writing fun for both teacher and students by adding an art component to some of your writing activities. Students need to practice the kind of writing required for state testing programs, but there are many ways to prepare them for the test and help them acquire the skills they need.
Art is a natural activity to accompany writing for several reasons. The developmental stages of each process parallel each other from the time a child begins to scribble until he or she is able to organize written vocabulary into stories and visual images into pictures.
Compare the Developmental Stages of
Writing and Art--terms very young children use interchangeably.
Scribbling | Scribbling |
Learns to print letters in name | Learns to make symbols to represent objects |
Uses letters in name to write everything | Repeats symbols to represent everything |
Environmental letters are added (Recognizes words like Wal Mart, McDonald's) | Adds symbols from objects seen in environment |
Recognizes that letters make words and words make stories | Recognizes that symbols can be organized into pictures |
Both processes use the same thinking
skills:
The creative thinking that structures a storyline is the same thinking that structures a work of art. Both processes ask the same question: Where do I go from here?
Preparation for any topic in writing or art should be established through a discussion of who, what, when, where, and how or why.
Multiple Intelligences are at work:
In Envisioning Writing, Janet Olson explains how to weave drawing and writing together in the classroom. She believes that drawing provides additional information to words for a visual learner, and words can add additional information to pictures for a verbal learner. One informs the other, and a child switches the processes back and forth to gather detailed information for carrying out ideas.
Art and writing activities are fun ways
to introduce the six traits.
Materials: Crayons, markers, Sharpies, pens, colored pencils, any and all kinds of paper, lined sheets. Use whatever you have available. There is no reason to go overboard with supplies. The simpler the better--too many things to work with can be more hindrance than help.
What are lined sheets (Print sheet here, or use computer to make your own, so you can adjust the spacing and thickness. Sets of lined sheet transparencies are sold for calligraphy use. The darker the line, the better it shows through the paper. Make enough copies for your class and plan to reuse them. Make sure students know not to write on the lined sheets.)? Presentation counts (Six Traits Plus 1--Presentation), so start here. Use lined sheets under thin white construction paper or copy paper when going from the rough to the finished draft. Lined sheets (almost) keep the writing straight on the paper and don't interfere with illustrations. Just as you would model the writing process: practice using a lined sheet and model that too. Tell students not to trace the lines, just use them as guides for writing straight.
What kinds of activities work best? Start simply and teach revision as you go. Use stems and
frames, so the student can focus on the important content. Each
activity will be individualized as students self-select topics
and details. Later on, take away the
scaffolding and let students create the whole piece.
Revision is overwhelming to beginning
writers if they start out and only write narratives. Use the following as a guide for building revision
skills:
For introductory and creative activities, start with small pieces of the writing to revise and move to the more complex issues:
Words: add or delete, move, substitute an active verb,specific noun or defining adjective.
Sentences: combine, vary beginnings, vary lengths.
Add information: specific details, sensory images.
Remove information: weak words, unnecessary words or sentences.
For narrative writing, move on to:
Paragraphs: varied length, moving sentences around, taking sentences out, transitions.
Beginngs: Back to the picture books, use the models.
Endings: Back to the picture books, use
the models.
These lessons can be used to introduce or enhance the six traits (main idea, supporting details, organization, sentence fluency, voice, and conventions) and to help students gain confidence as writers. Presentation is particularly important when work is to be displayed.
Do not limit your students to just these particular activities. Use them as they are, or as springboards for creating activities that go with your own curriculum or class needs.
Give each student
a piece of white paper and have them fold it in half by folding the short
sides together. Choose one of the stems below and have them write
and illustrate the first part on the left side of the paper. Use the right
side for the second part of the stem.
I used to be _______, but now I'm _________.
I seem to be ______, but really I'm _________.
I'm good at _______, but I'm not so good at ________.
Another way to do
this is as a poem, just put several lines together:
I used to be young, but now I am old.
I used to be thinner, but now I am not.
I used to have brown hair, but now I am blonde.
I used to be a beginning teacher, but now I am near retirement.
I used to have some energy, but now I don't.
Other stems:
Don't you just hate it when . . . ?
A friend is . . . .
Read If The
Dinosaurs Came Back by Bernard Most. Have students draw their own
dinosaur pictures and come up with ways to use them.
If the dinosaurs came back, __________________________.
Write and illustrate
cinquains. Keep the illustrations as simple as the poems by cutting
out a shape which represents the subject of the poem. Copy the cinquain on
a white sheet of paper. Put the shape under the paper and color it with short
"paperless" crayons. Direct students to use the side of the crayon and just
color over the shape until the outline is clear. Tell them not to outline
the shape! The shape can be moved so it is repeated in a pleasing design,
random or planned, all over the page. Students may elect to use one color
or two, but too many different colors will take away from the design. Small
details may be added to each shape, but too much detail detracts from
the words.
Write and
illustrate sentence pyramids. This is a good exercise for adding details
and expanding a thought.
I saw a clown.
I saw a funny clown.
I saw a funny clown juggling.
I saw a funny clown juggling bowling pins.
I saw a funny clown juggling bowling pins in a parade.
I saw a funny clown juggling bowling pins in a Christmas parade.
Have students
draw self-portraits as they look today, but dressed
like they will dress for their chosen profession when they are adults. They
can include some background that indicates their work place. Have them write
about where they will go to school and what they will study to prepare
themselves. This activity provides an enlightening and amusing look at your
students.
Have students cut
out an article of clothing such as a T-shirt or sweatshirtand decorate
it. The design can be made up or taken from a favorite piece of clothing.
Write a story with the article of clothing describing a day in its life.
Have students fill
out a Report Card on the Teacher. If you are brave, ask them to draw
a picture, but this is one activity that is just fun for students and no
art is necessary. This is a very humbling experience. The students have to
give you a grade in several categories and write an explanation telling why
they think you deserve this grade and give an example to support their thinking.
If you are the perfect teacher, never make anyone mad, never show any sign of displeasure, you will get only glowing remarks. Congratulations! Otherwise, you will find that you need to work on some things--and many of the suggestions students make are right on target. Most students, depending on age, will direct their remarks to your mother--just like the ones they read on their report cards: Mrs. O'Berry is a good teacher, but she needs to work on. . . .
Read When
I Was Young in the Mountains by Cynthia Rylant, an exceptional model
for writing memories and introducing memoir to students. Talk about how the
memories from Rylant's childhood are of relatively unimportant events in
her life, yet they stand out in her memory enough for her to include them
in the book. Ask them to think of specific events to write and illustrate;
they don't have to be major--like a trip to Disneyworld. Students may choose
to use a different stem for their memory: You may want to introduce group
and phase memoirs as well. If students only want to write about the spectacular,
that is okay. It is their choice in the end.
When I used to live in . . . .
When we lived in. . . .
When I was in the Third Grade . . . .
When I was young in kindergarten. . . .
When I was in Mrs. _______'s room. . . .
When we went to visit. . . .
Drawing and
illustrating idioms helps
young children "see" and undertand what they mean and how to use them
apporpriately. Make a list of idioms and allow students to choose one to
illustrate. Students will write the idiom on the paper, draw the figurative
meaning and write the literal meaning underneath. Put these in a class book
for students to read and think about.
Read
Goodnight, Moon by Margaret Wise Brown, an old favorite
that most students are familiar with, and recreate the book for the new
millennium. Have students draw a bedroom and include items found in children's
rooms today: TVs, Nintendo, skate boards, posters of rock starts, etc. I
teach baseline and simple perspective with this activity.
Students will choose one or two items in their illustrations to wish
"goodnight." Compile the pages into a class book. With luck and careful
arranging of pages, you MAY achieve the rhythm of the original book.
Read "The Toucan"
by Shel Silverstein, found in Where the Sidewalk Ends. Explain
and discuss the pattern in the poem. Let children make up additional lines
and add them to the poem as a whole class activity, a good opportunity to
model revision. Make a large copy of the poem and surround it with toucan
collages: tear the bird's body, then cut the rest of the bird parts and the
background. The whole thing can be cut or torn, but the torn shapes create
a nice textural interest in the pictures.
Read
The Important
Book by Margaret Wise Brown.The pattern is an easy one to adapt
to many subjects. Let children create individual books about things that
are important to them, such as family members, pets, friends; or do a cooperative
learning project to correlate with a unit or theme being taught in the classroom.
The example is the last page of a book about outer space.
The first line identifies the object and tells why it is important.
The next 3 lines describe the object.
The last line repeats the first line word for word except for the word But at the beginning of the sentence.
Read
When I Was Young: Memoirs of a Four-Year-Old by Jamie Lee Curtis,
yes: the movie star. The illustrations in this book are great. After reading,
have the children write their own memoirs (after explaining what a memoir
is and how it is different from an autobiography) in an accordion book. Four
pages is enough to have a title page and relate/draw 3 memories of what life
was like when they were younger.
Read
Abiyoyo by Pete Seeger, yes: the musician. Abiyoyo
is adapted from a South African lullaby and folk story, and the children
love it--so do I, and so will you. It is fun to read out loud. After reading
the story, have the children imagine the most awful giants and illustrate
them. A writing component is part of this activity.
Frame for Abiyoyo:
I am the meanest giant of all, meaner than Abiyoyo, because I ____________________ and ___________________, but the worst thing I do is __________________________.
Children need to do the writing first and illustrate what is in the last blank of the frame. Let them write the frame across the top or bottom of the illustration.
Most teachers
use Cloudy With a Chance of
Meatballs for their weather unit, but it is can be used for health
and nutrition as well. Food falls from the sky in the little town of
Chewandswallow. The forecast changes daily and people take to the streets
with plates, etc. until one day. . .
Weather Unit: Writing can be in the form of a weather bulletin.
Nutrition: Create a menu for a healthy, balanced meal (breakfast, lunch, or supper). The example is not my idea of a balanced meal.
I use this activity to talk about horizon lines, simple perspective, creating shapes to fit a particular space such as a giant slice of pizza draped over the roof of a house, doughnuts looped around a chimney or in piles.
Teach metaphors
by having children write and illustrate a poem comparing themselves to different
items, such as a car, piece of furniture, animal, fruit, or vegetable. Metaphors
connect two different ideas, persons, places, or things. They make you see
things in new ways. Metaphors do not use "like" or "as;" similes do that.
Use a stem to get the poem started: (In the spring, water, classroom, etc.)
In the morning, I am a bear,
Grouchy in my cave of sheets and pillows,
Growling at the ringing of the alarm clock,
Swatting at the button to make it stop.
Read
"The Tyger" by William Blake. You won't understand
it, and neither will the students. This is not even important--to me anyway.
The link that accompanies this activity will send you to the poem and pages
of literary discussion that just to look at, not even read, will show that
no one really understands it. It is basically about an imaginary conversation
with a tiger. This poem has been made into a wonderful picture book, and
students like the idea of being introduced to such sophisticated poetry (I
tell them they probably wouldn't hear this poem until high school otherwise;
they sit right up and listen.) After reading the poem and talking about what
we think it means, I ask them to think of an animal they would like to have
a conversation with. What would they ask the animal? What would they like
to know about how it feels to be an animal? Use any questions that will help
them generate information. We use picture books about animals to help with
this.
After gathering information, the students turn their ideas into poems like Blake's--somewhat. Factual information may not be included; it depends on how the student frames the poem. And specific factual information does not lend itself to poetry, so it is discouraged. Pictures are drawn of the animals to accompany the poems. We use craypas on black construction paper and cut them for mounting on white paper.
Sometimes I do this as an alphabet book using a set of ABC animal posters, so every letter is represented. Students are encouraged to use pictures as resources for drawing, like artists do, but not to copy the work. A lesson in copyright laws can be inserted in this discussion.
Read
Someday by Charlotte
Zolotov. After reading the book to the students, go back through the pages
noting the importance of the stem word Someday and how it is depicted
in many different lettering styles. Let students write and illustrate their
own pages for a class book. Older students can make individual books if time
allows. Model sentences like the ones used in the book: long sentences. Encourage
the use of words like "and" and "but" to expand the sentences beyond simple
statements like: Someday I will drive my own car. A better sentence in this
case would be: Someday I will drive a Grand Cherokee loaded with all of my
friends, and we will cruise the Grand Strand at Myrtle Beach. This is more
specific and gives them more to work with when they draw.