| Archived Guest Book No 3 - 2003 The most recent message is the first one Back To Main Page Back to Archived Guest Book No 2 Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : all of you that are on here saying that organ donation is bad have no idea what you are talking about. there are over 80,000 people waiting for an organ. how dare you potentially deprive Comment (second 35 words) : over 80,000 people from seeing their children grow up, grow old with their spouse, see adulthood, have a family of their own, etc. god help you if you or anyone in your family need an Comment (third 35 words) : organ. you would think twice in a life or death situation. if you go on unos.org you would see all the common diseases that could cause organ failure that even you could get. Name (optional) : blah Address (optional) : blah Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : miss connie you should really learn how to spell. I mean how many misspelled words can you have in 3 sentences? Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Maybe you have had experience in being at the removal of organs from a brain dead person. Comment (second 35 words) : Do you have a forum where others could read of this experience as we only have sensational accounts from magazines to go on - and they make it seem bad. Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : sam Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : it really doesnt matter to me if you believe me or not ...thats your perogative,i do have experience in donation as said ...on both sides. After my cousin died we donated his bones and someone has benifited from that.... Comment (second 35 words) : in the same term you say MDs are killing people for their organs have you been there first hand to see this or just relying on the media???? i would just put money on the fact if you child or family needed an organ to live MANY people would take it and no Comment (third 35 words) : everyone is entitled to have their own opinion that is 100% fine...but surely it is better to be based on the fact and not myth....and dont be hypocritical if you ever need an organ 1 day and be prepared to recieve one!! Name (optional) : sam Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : miss connie...whos voices are you saying dont get heard? your posting left me a little confused Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : miss connie Address (optional) : Email (optional) : croozzen@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : You say thank god for Organ donors. Well dont thank god. Thank the MD who murdered a person to obtain the kidney so he can keep supporting not only his mistress but his wife. Dont letem fool you. But we know that outcome dont we? Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : miss connie Address (optional) : Email (optional) : croozzen@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : It seems as the voices will never be herd. But thanks anyway for the truth. I have learned that people are more ignorent and closed minded than I thought. Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I doubt if you have been on an organ recovery. Any bozo can just leave a short message saying he or she has. Where is the evidence. Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : sam Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : yes i have seen a recovery and have also been on te other side as a donor family. Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Kevin G. Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I am not sure if the writer has. I have not. Have you? Is there a written record of your experience? I am interested. Comment (second 35 words) : There was a page linked to this page about a liver removal but I cant remember where it is. It was sensational tabloid journalism. Comment (third 35 words) : A more sober recollection would be useful. Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : it means... has the person ever witnessed/accompanied a professional in the process of an organ recovery Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : What the hell does that mean...going out on an organ recovery. Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : sam Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : has the writer for this web site actually ever been out on an organ recovery i wonder? as this is not the experience i had encountered Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : A friend Address (optional) : Nebraska Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I was referring to the websites authors implied accusation of greed towards those receiving necessary organs and the professionals around them... Comment (second 35 words) : ...rather than me accusing a single person, in this case you, of greed. Comment (third 35 words) : You do make a good point about how each of us would react when faced with the fact of chronic, even terminal, illness and the possibility of worldly redemption via an organ transplant. Name (optional) : nic Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : A Friend unfortunatley with the minimal space this guestbook allows, to rebut the point is hard (or more so the prove the info is wrong). And do not see how using profanities makes me greedy????? Comment (second 35 words) : i am proud of the work i do as an RN so when someone is misrepresenting my profession i stikes a cord. Comment (third 35 words) : I just wonder if this person ever needed and organ would he refuse? Name (optional) : A Friend Address (optional) : Nebraska Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : You are falling into this websites trap. They may skew the facts, but they do it rationally, quoting authorities and studies. Comment (second 35 words) : You respond with words like shit and crap and come out looking as stupid and greedy as the writers of this site imply you are. Comment (third 35 words) : Develop an argument. Base it on proven and proveable science. Dont rely on mass belief. The Net has destroyed that. Name (optional) : darren Address (optional) : Email (optional) : ksl1980@cox.net Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Thanks Nic...Can you believe some of the crap on this guys web site. So sad to see someone so bitter to the world. Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : nic Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I am at a loss for words after looking at this web site...your information is utterly incorrect. For a RN of 10 years i have NEVER read so much CRAP in all my life. Comment (second 35 words) : You have so many misrepresented pieces of info it would take a thesis to correct all aff te things you have said that are incorrect. I would suggest all who read this to treat is with the contempt it deserves.. Comment (third 35 words) : You have insulted me personally and professionally, I dont give a shit if you have a donor card in the ER..its the last thing i think off Name (optional) : darren Address (optional) : Email (optional) : ksl1980@cox.net Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Thank God for organ donors. I recieved a kidney on 8-21-2002. Almost a year. I am perfectly fine. Anyone who wants the truth about transplantation from someone who has been through it instead of some jackass doctor who thinks he knows everything Comment (second 35 words) : feel free to email me at any time. And to this jackass doctor, I will continue to sign your guess book every year Comment (third 35 words) : and let you know how perfect my life and new kidney are doing. You are a selfish JACKASS. Name (optional) : darren Address (optional) : Email (optional) : ksl1980@cox.net Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Thank God for organ donors. I recieved a kidney on 8-21-2002. Almost a year. I am perfectly fine. Anyone who wants the truth about transplantation from someone who has been through it instead of some jackass doctor who thinks he knows everything feel free Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I am sad to have happened upon this website. I have been LIVING with a heart transplant for 5 and 1/2 years, and I do mean LIVING. I have enoyed seeing the birth of Comment (second 35 words) : my two nieces, have graduated from college, and done several things that I have dreamed about and never thought were possible, and without complication. While I see Comment (third 35 words) : your argument, Im afraid it sounds like that of a disgruntled, bitter person. Shame on you for trying to steal our joy. Name (optional) : Norm Address (optional) : Email (optional) : gumflat88@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Those finding this guest book too small and wishing to publish their detailed comments on this site are welcome to email them to gumflat88@hotmail.com Comment (second 35 words) : Put “Email comments” in the subject box to distinguish your message from spam. Your name and email address will not be published unless you specifically provide permission Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Lady New Orleans Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I work in a hospital and have always felt strong contempt against organ harvesting. While you freely choose to donate which is what THEY want you to do, what happens when if in the same instance you NEED a transplant? One hospital demands ,000 up front Comment (second 35 words) : Another unasnwered question: How exactly does know when one is TRULY brain dead? Did not just recently, a man in the U.S wake from a 30 year coma? I personally believe that measures to save a donars life is secondary when the window of opportunity opens t Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Laura FRom Mora Address (optional) : 21 D Kenwood Email (optional) : lfm@ncis.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Thank you for your insite on the issue or organ donor. I am doing a college thesis on Biomedical Ethics. I must laugh....this has given me a whole new outlook! There are always two sides to every story! I beleive no one can judge, if they do not know all Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Ashes Address (optional) : http://www.expage.com/teensoup Email (optional) : aBuddwalk@yahoo.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : This is an interesting site.It informed me in on alot of info Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Miss Connie Address (optional) : Email (optional) : croozzen@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Why would a dead person need and Anostesologist for pain? Why wasnt the (organ truste) not informed about the need for an anastesologist until after the fact. Comment (second 35 words) : Why would a beloved daughter (not me) would pay all the medical bills except the anasteologist. (Yet remains in total inocent)And doest want to talk about it.... Comment (third 35 words) : Well I mailed my mom a hard copy of the info I believe will piss her off... But oh well, I have a habit of doing that... we will see... from CA CB ... email me with any info please... cb Name (optional) : Connie Address (optional) : Real Road, Email (optional) : croozzen@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : My computer crashed, now I am back. My memory tells me that there is an interest in publishing my story. Regarding, The Harvesting of my Fathers Organs. I am interested. Comment (second 35 words) : If there is a block on put on your site not alowing me to accept your e-mails. I didnt put a block on your site. I would like to tell my story. Maybe, it will waken up the ignorent and closed minded to a real issue. Comment (third 35 words) : I am not worried about being quiet about what I know and have experienced. I also know I am not getting hard copies of solid evidendce with open hands. YOUR INFORMATION IS TRUE AND REAL... It is sad but it is all true...cb Name (optional) : mark blackshaw Address (optional) : sydney Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Unfortunate that so many nameless people, including donor coordinators are unwilling to identify themselves. That says a lot to me ! So many ill informed Comment (second 35 words) : pro transplant lobbyists. From one who knows , whose sons body WAS violated and harvested of all his organs (inclduing skin) without my consent. Comment (third 35 words) : Keep bringing these matters to the attention of people. Its not as rosey at it all seems. Name (optional) : cb Address (optional) : Email (optional) : croozzen@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I am now seeking legal advise. If there is a human out there that can give me some awncers it would be helpfull. First Q.. Comment (second 35 words) : Is there a statute of limitations on murder How hard would it be to prove neglegence by not telling the surgons that the man was under the influence before they cut him up? Comment (third 35 words) : and what is the statute of limitations on FORGING MY SIGNATURE on the concent to harvest forms and if this would staND ANY PRESIDENCE... Name (optional) : cb Address (optional) : Email (optional) : croozzen@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : HEY ALL YOU NEGATIVE PEOPLE WAKE UP. THIS IS A SITE THAT HOLDS WHAT YOU DONT WANT TO BELIEVE... IT IS TRUE. MONEY , KILL ONE SAVE TWO OR MORE. THIS IS BIG STUFF. AND UNTIL YOU WALK IN MY SHOES YOU ALL NEED TO SHUT UP... THIS SITE IS THE BEST THING TO OPEN Comment (second 35 words) : THIS IS BIG STUFF AND UNTIL YOU WALK IN MY SHOES YOU ALL MEED TO SHUT UP... THIS SITE IS THE BEST THING TO COME ALONG TO OPEN UP THE EYES OF THE IGNORANT...CB Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Connie Brown Address (optional) : 420 Real Road Apt. 6-D Email (optional) : croozzen@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Moto-accident man colides w/dear in late PM hour. found breathing/unconcions. Year 1992 Declared brain stem death on July 11th. Recorded July 12th. After they harvested. recieved a bill from anastesologist 10 grand. He had been drinking all day no one to Comment (second 35 words) : He looked like he was sleeping, his body was warm and he shed tears. When they told the family he was breain stem dead. I left the hospital in disbelief. Later to find out ... Comment (third 35 words) : that my signature had been forged. The prepreation for harvest began. The mortition was so upset because there were so many holes in him they couldnt embalm him. I believe that he was murdered. And Antalope valley hospital profited of my father. Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : let me put it this way how could you sit there and creat some thing so horrible i am soon going to get a licence and i want to be a doner i am now scared of it you are a sick fuck Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Louise DeLise Address (optional) : Email (optional) : h2oworks@earthlink.net Comment (holds up to 35 words) : We live in a non-perfect world. Liver Tx 9-25-2002 Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Dr P Murphy, PhD. Address (optional) : London Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I am incensed. You promote a biased perspective based on the flawed analysis of data and highly emotive language. Many of the opinions are at odds with the great majority of researchers and clinicians? Is your stance a moral/religous belief? If so at leas Comment (second 35 words) : This site is a scientific disgrace and disrespectful to donors and recipients alike. Liver transplantation has extended and improved the lives of many thousands of people. We DO NOT kill people to harvest their organs. Comment (third 35 words) : Donors and their families are treated with the UTMOST respect. To suggest otherwise is virtually libellous. Name (optional) : Robbie Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Shocking! I need to seriously rethink my status as a potential organ-donor now that I have read your writings. And I did read every single page. Comment (second 35 words) : Thank you so much for the information. I will be forwarding this URL to friends and family. I really wish this had been made more public before now. I had no IDEA. Simply SHOCKING! Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Shaz Address (optional) : SA Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : If I end up brain dead, I wont care what my body looks like or what happens to it. I might as well help save others lives by donating organs. Comment (second 35 words) : Do you have an alternative to organ donation or do you think sick people should just die because you dont want to be disfigured after death? Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : stacy Address (optional) : Email (optional) : sgunnells@atl-apt.org Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I SECOND THIS: Comment (second 35 words) : YOU OBVIOUSLY HAVE NO IDEA THE PAIN INVOLVED IN HAVING A FAMILY MEMBER ON THE WAITING LIST FOR A DONATION. HOW DARE YOU TRY AND TAKE AWAY THE ONLY HOPE THAT WE HAVE. Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Stacy Address (optional) : Email (optional) : sgunnells@atl-apt.org Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Shame on your for such a horrible website. You are LYING to people and in the process, you are deterring them from giving the gift of life. You should be ashamed of yourself, but Im sure youre not because you are a heartless person. Why are you working ag Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Liz Address (optional) : Email (optional) : grilledlizard@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : im doing a school project on organ doning and found your site fascinating, it really revealed to me the bad side to organ doning. Comment (second 35 words) : i used to think it was perfect but now i am going to use alot of your info in our class debate on whether the process is good or not Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Scott Taylor Address (optional) : Email (optional) : taylorsj@bigpond.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : What an irresponsible site you have going here. As an ICU nurse I am APPALLED at what you have written. What experience do you have relating to organ donation? Comment (second 35 words) : Im also amazed you have not provided an email address so myself (and many other people) can contact you for a more detailed explanation. Comment (third 35 words) : I have provided my email address above so you can write to me via email. Name (optional) : Graham Harrison Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I wonder what has motivated you to put such a site together. Is it a personal first hand experience, or are you a well read expert? As a donor father and friends to may recipients - I thinks you have no idea. Comment (second 35 words) : For those having stumbled across this site, why not visit www.transplant.org.au Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Cam Address (optional) : Eureka, California Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : transplant mania is devolution into cannibalism. mad witch doctors with their spin doctors poisoning children with entreaties to cannibalistic attitudes Comment (second 35 words) : listen to your conscience. accept the flow of life and death. do not degrade yourself by preying on the dying Comment (third 35 words) : brave site Name (optional) : Samantha Address (optional) : Ingle Farm SA Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Love the sober and precise language of your main star, Dr Evans. Refreshing change from sensational and entertaining writing. Comment (second 35 words) : Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Samantha Address (optional) : Ingle Farm, SA Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Organ donation staff visit schools. They persuade 14 year olds to sign donor cards. Informed consent. Comment (second 35 words) : No parent consent needed to sign and carry card. Rules say next of kin (mummy or daddy) must give consent to donation if child becomes brain dead. Comment (third 35 words) : Donation staff use school donation card to persuade mummy or daddy that dearest wanted to donate. Clever, eh? Name (optional) : Norm Address (optional) : Email (optional) : gumflat88@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : In response to message below. Actually, Kim, most of the site has been vetted or based on the studies of medical professionals. Comment (second 35 words) : However, if you can specify the points that you disagree with, I be pleased to check them over and get back to you. Comment (third 35 words) : Regardless, thanks for you considered viewpoint. Name (optional) : Kim Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : This site made me nauseous. I have been an ICU nurse for 14 years and have cared for several brain dead, donor patients. Never, ever, until brain death is actually established, Comment (second 35 words) : is the patient in any way treated as an organ donor. It is preposterous to say that organ donors receive substandard care. People do not understand that brain death means they are already dead. Comment (third 35 words) : I will donate my organs, even my childrens, if, God forbid, it ever came to that. It is so sad that this misinformed site is swaying lay people who have no medical knowledge. Name (optional) : Stavros P. Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : Professor Nancy Scheper-Hughes Organ Watch, University of California, Berkeley http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/biotech/organswatch/ Comment (second 35 words) : This group has quite a detailed and respected knowledge of organ trading around the world. Nancy testified to a Congressional Hearing even. Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : adriano Address (optional) : Email (optional) : organresearch@hotmail.com Comment (holds up to 35 words) : i am conducting research into the illegal trade and trafficking of body organs. i am especially interested in the former east european region. Comment (second 35 words) : does anyone have any information? Comment (third 35 words) : Name (optional) : Address (optional) : Email (optional) : Comment (holds up to 35 words) : I AM LOOKING FOR INFORMATION ON ORGAN DONATION AND INADVERTANTLY CAME ACROSS YOUR WEBSITE, WHICH I COULD NOT READ Comment (second 35 words) : YOU OBVIOUSLY HAVE NO IDEA THE PAIN INVOLVED IN HAVING A FAMILY MEMBER ON THE WAITING LIST FOR A DONATION. Comment (third 35 words) : HOW DARE YOU TRY AND TAKE AWAY THE ONLY HOPE THAT WE HAVE Back To Main Page Go To Archived Guest Book No 1 (the oldest) Go To Archived Guest Book No 2 |