A Romance of the Melungeons
Mysterious Racial Group in East Tennessee,
Descendants of Phoenicians of Ancient Carthage,
Subject of Dramatic
Story Found in Memoirs of Late Judge Lewis Shepherd
- Drama and
Heartbreak
Attended Early Lawsuit in Which Chattanoogan Won His Spurs -
By
T. A. Rogers
June 21, 1936
Editor’s
Note–Romance, drama and heart-break, holding all the interest of a
Hollywood moving picture thriller, are contained in this story of “The
Melungeons,” a tale of the early days of Chattanooga, as told by the
late Judge Lewis Shepherd, for many years a leading member of the bar
here. This story , along with many other interesting narratives,
appears in ‘Personal Memoirs” in which Judge Shepherd told of striking
and important cases in which he figured as a young attorney and in
later life. For the most part the stories in the book were
originally written for the Times by Judge Shepherd.
-------------------------------------------------
Many years
ago, when Tennessee was being settled by white people, there came to
this section from Virginia a wealthy man with his family and his
slaves. He bought a large and valuable tract of land a cleared it
up and converted it into a farm. This tract was situated in the
bend of the river, now called Moccasin bend and much of it was very
rich and fertile river bottom land, where vegetation of all sorts grew
in rich and luxuriant abundance.
The man died after awhile, leaving a widow and three sons, the widow
married again and raised a family of three girls. The young men
grew up to be good business men, and each of them had a fine farm
inherited from his father. Two of them died without having been
married, and their estates were inherited by the survivor. The
survivor, the hero of this story, rented his land and hired out his
slaves, and he himself entered into the mercantile business in the town
which grew up on the south side of the river. It was at first
Rossville, but is now the flourishing city of Chattanooga. After
several years of life in the town he was attacked with severe
spell of fever; he recovered but the disease affected his mind to such
an extent that he was temporarily deranged. He recovered his
mental faculties about the year 1848 and thereafter, for several years,
managed his property very successfully.
Old Soldier’s
Beautiful Daughter
He had on his farm a tenant who had been a United States soldier in the
War of 1812, having joined the army in South Carolina, where he lived
at the time. This old soldier had a daughter who was famed for
her beauty, her grace of manner and modesty. She was a dark
brunette. She had a suit of black hair, which was coveted by all
the girls who knew her. Her form was petite, and yet withal was
so plump and so well developed as to make her an irresistibly charming
young woman. She was most beautiful of face, and had a rich,
black eye, in whose depths the sunbeams seemed to gather. When
she loosed her locks they fell, almost reaching the ground, and shone
in the sunlight or quivered like the glamour which the full moon throws
on the placid water. She was the essence of grace and loveliness.
Our hero fell in love with this delightful young woman;’ she
reciprocated his affection, and they obtained the consent of their
parents to be married. His mother and half sisters heard of his
attachment and engagement — to which they were much opposed. They knew
if he married, their prospects of some time falling heir to his
property would be destroyed. They notified the clerk and his
deputy, whose duty it was to issue marriage licenses not to issue a
license, claiming that our hero was incompetent to contract a marriage,
and that there was a legal disability to his inter-marriage with this
girl and they threatened to bring suit for damages against him and his
bondsmen if he issued him a license to wed this young woman.
Love Laughs at
Obstacles
When our hero, several days afterward applied to the clerk he was
refused a license. He was a young man of resources and was not to
be outwitted in this way. He took his bride elect and crossed
over the river and secured the aid of Ab Carroll and John Cummings,
both of whom were young men, and they entered joyfully into the
plot. They were fond of fun, and they readily agreed to promote
the marriage, since there was a romantic feature connected with
it. They took the young people desperately bent on getting
married to the house of squire Clark in Dade county, Georgia, and sent
to Trenton and secured a marriage license. Squire Clark performed
the marriage ceremony in due and proper form, and made return of the
license, properly indorsed by him under the law of Georgia, the
proper court in Trenton, the county seat of Dade county.
The happy bridegroom, with his charming bride, returned to his home
that afternoon, duly and legally married, much to the discomfort of his
relatives who had tried to thwart the marriage, it never having
occurred
to them that a Georgia court would grant a license and a Georgia judge
perform the ceremony.
They immediately went to housekeeping on the bridegroom’s plantation in
a comfortable home which he had previously furnished and prepared for
his bride, and they started out in life happily and auspiciously.
The marriage took place on June 14, 1856, as shown by Squire Clark’s
return on the license.
The first child of the marriage was a son, who died in his
infancy. The second was a daughter, who was born in the latter
part of they year 1858.
Insane From
Grief
Eight days after her birth the mother died, which event was such an
overpowering shock to the father that he went violently insane and had
to be taken into custody and kept under guard for a long
time. He never recovered his mind, but he got to be in such
condition that he was entirely harmless. He was permitted to live alone
in his house and his meals were furnished him by his guardian, who
looked carefully and closely after his welfare.
He was like Judge Alton Parker in one respect-he took a plunge into the
creek, or river, near his house every morning, no matter how cold or
how hot it was. In the winter time he frequently had to break the
ice in order to take his plunge. He would not allow a hair to
grow anywhere on his body, head or face; he plucked them out as soon
as they made their appearance, and he fancied that evil spirts would
invade his house and destroy him unless he kept himself surrounded by a
circle of cats, which he always did. His cats were numerous and
were exceedingly well trained for their work.
The mother and half sisters of the crazy man procured a maternal aunt
of the child “Aunt Betsy” either by threats or bribes to take the
infant clear out of the country and exacted a promise from her that she
would never return to this country, and she took her away and settled
in Illinois in the swamps of the Mississippi, seventy-five miles from
Cairo, and the child was completely forgotten by everybody in this
country, except Mr. Samuel Williams, who knew all the fact and knew
that some day there would be a reckoning. He secretly arranged
with “Aunt Betsey” to have a letter written to him once in a while to
keep him posted as to the whereabouts and the welfare of the child, and
this she did. Whenever she changed her place of residence she
promptly caused Mr. Williams to be notified and informed of her new
habitation.
She had the forethought when she went on her journey to take the
child’s father’s family Bible, which contained a record in his own
handwriting of his marriage and the birth of the children, which
proved to be a valuable item of evidence in the great chancery court
suit which afterward arose out of these matters.
Shortly after the man went crazy William H. Foust was appointed
guardian of his person and property. Mr. Foust was one of the
best men in the country; was successful and prosperous in his own
affairs and made a careful and prudent guardian of his ward’s property
and of his person. He kept his lands rented and carefully collected and
preserved the rents until he had a fund of many thousands of dollars,
loaned at interest and well secured by deeds of trust on real
estate. Mr. Foust allowed the man to live in his own house,
but employed one of the tenants on his estate to feed him and look
after keeping his house and clothes in proper condition, and in this
way he was comfortably and amply provided for.
Fight for
Estate Opens
In 1872, while the Hon. D. M. Key was chancellor, the two surviving
half-sisters of our man and the children of the deceased half sister
brought suit in the chancery court, by which they sought to surcharge
and falsify the settlements made from time to time by Mr. Foust of his
guardianship; they charged that he had mismanaged the estate and wasted
its assets, and had loaned large sums to insolvent persons and had
taken inadequate security from the borrowers, and sought to make him
account for the assets, which he ought, by prudent management, to have
on hand.
Another feature of the bill was that Mr. Foust’s ward was an incurable
and permanent lunatic, rarely having a lucid interval, and that
complainants were his heirs apparent and would certainly fall into
possession of the estate. The prayer of the bill was that the
guardianship be revoked and the ward and his estate be turned over now
to them, they agreeing to give bond and security that they would
provide for all his wants. They also prayed the court to
pronounce a decree adjudging them to be the heirs apparent to the
estate.
Mr. Samuel Williams and Col. John L. Divine were the sureties on Mr.
Foust’s bond as guardian, and they were sued in order to make good the
decree which the complainant expected to recover, and Mr. Williams
concluded that now was the proper time for him to make use of the
knowledge which he had of the existence and whereabouts of the rightful
heir apparent, and sought a lawyer to whom his secret would be
entrusted and who could represent the girl in the assertion of her
rights. He found on inquiry that all the experienced lawyers in
town had been employed either by complainants or Mr. Foust, one of the
defendants. VanDyke, Cooke & VanDyke Judge D. C. Trewhitt and
Maj. Mose H. Clift were the array on the complainants’ side while Key
& Richmond and Col. W. L. Eakins represented Mr. Foust.
Young Lawyer
Recommended
A friend of Mr. Williams advised him to consult a young lawyer
(Shepherd) who was just starting out in business. Mr. Williams
acted on this advice and communicated all the facts in his possession
to the young man and placed the entire matter in his hands for
such action as he might deem necessary and appropriate. Mr.
Williams agreed to serve in the capacity of next friend to the girl and
become responsible for the costs and thereupon a bill was filed for
her, asking that she be adjudged the child and heir apparent to the
crazy man and that she be supported and educated out of his estate, her
education having been sadly neglected while she was in exile.
This bill created a big sensation; it was like a clap of thunder out of
a clear sky. The complainants were extravagant in their
denunciation of the bill as a tissue of falsehoods and slanders.
They claimed that it was a fabrication of old man Williams, and that
the girl was an impostor. They even denied that there was any
such person as she in existence; they denied her identity as the child
of the lunatic, married to his alleged wife and claimed that if he had
gone through the form of marriage it was void for numerous reasons, and
the issue of such marriage was illegitimate.
In this condition of affairs, Mr. Williams on the advice of the counsel
he had retained for the girl, went to Illinois and after much
persuasion , he induced her to return to Chattanooga with him. He
brought back with him the old Bible which “Aunt Betsy” had carried away
with her when she went to Illinois.
He had to promise “Aunt Betsy” that he would fetch her back to
Chattanooga as soon as she could dispose of her belongings, which
promise he made good. When Mr. Williams got back to Chattanooga
the girl was nearly 15 years old. She knew nothing about the ways
of the world. She was totally ignorant of the prevailing fashions of
dress, she did not know what a corset was or how it was worn, whether
over or under the dress. She had spent the most of her life in
the forest along the banks of the Mississippi, where she and her aunt
had made their living by cultivating a small patch with hoes and by
cutting cord wood and selling it to the steamboats which plied up and
down the river and which used the wood for fuel. She knew nothing
whatever of the arts of fashionable women in making for themselves
attractive forms and figures by skillful lacing. She was
simply an uncouth , unsophisticated, unmade-up, natural girl from the
backwoods; a girl, withal, possessed of a strikingly beautiful face and
a figure which , by proper development and dress was capable of being
molded into a form that would please the most fastidious.
Hoe Girl to
Heiress
She was very much like her mother, and possessed all the charms and
graces she did, but they were undeveloped. Mr. Williams took her
to a milliner and had her proved with a wardrobe suitable to her
changed surroundings. She very readily adapted herself to her new
surrounding and her new life out in the midst of civilization.
She was kept at the Williams home and sent to school from there for
about two years.
She had to start from the very beginning but, being ambitious to get
some education she studied hard and learned very rapidly and in the
short time of her school days got a very fair and practical
educations. She afterward married her teacher, who was a splendid
young man and became one of the leading men in the community and
managed his wife’s affairs very successfully and added considerably to
her fortune. At the time of his death, which occurred about
twenty years ago, he was a prominent official in the county and in
conjunction with Blev Thomspon, represented the Hill City district in
the county court.
The case was energetically prepared for trial; upward of sixty
depositions were taken on the various issues raised in the
pleading. The fact of the marriage was easily proved; Squire
Clark, who officiated, was still living; as were John and James
Cummings
and Joel Cross, all of whom were eye witnesses to the performance of
the ceremony and remembered it well. In their depositions they
stated as a reason for remembering the occurrence so well the unusual
circumstances that when the ceremony was said Squire Clark, the bridal
pair and witnesses were all standing in the big road in front of Squire
Clark’s house. The record in the old Bible established the date
of the birth of the child.
The point made that the man was incapable, by reason of being non
compos mentis, of entering into a contract of marriage was settled by
the ruling of the judge that a marriage which was voidable could not be
questioned by anybody except one of the parties to be contract; in
other words, that such marriage could not be attacked collaterally; so
that it was at all relevant to take evidence on that point.
The great battle ground was the allegation in the answer that the
marriage was void because in contravention of a statue of Tennessee
prohibiting the intermarriage of a white person with a person of Negro
blood to the sixth degree it being alleged that the mother of this girl
was a person of mixed Negro blood within the prohibition degree, and
upon this issue a large volume of proof was taken.
What the Proof
Showed
The evidence completely exploded this theory. It was
satisfactorily established in the proof that the family of this woman
was in no way allied to, or connected with, the Negro race; that there
was not a feature of herself or ancestry that was at all similar to the
distinguishing characteristics or features of the Negro, except that
they were of dark color, about the color of a mulatto. They had
high foreheads; long, straight, black hair; high cheek bones, thin
lips, small feet, with high insteps and prominent Roman noses, while
the features of the Negro and mulatto were exactly the reverse of these.
In truth, these people belonged to a peculiar race which settled in
East Tennessee at an early day and in the vernacular of that country,
they were known as “Melungeons,’ and were not even remotely allied to
the Negroes. It was proven by the tradition among these people
that they were descendant of the ancient Carthagenians; they were
Phoenicians who, after Carthage was conquered by the Romans and became
a province, emigrated across the Straits of Gibraltar and settled in
Portugal. They lived for many years and became quite numerous on
the southern coast of Portugal, and from thence the distinguished
Venetian general, Othello, whom Shakespeare made immortal in his
celebrates play, “Othello, the Moor of Venice.” These were the
same people who fought the Romans so bravely and heroically in the
Punic wars and whose women sacrificed their long, black hair to the
state to be plaited and twisted into cable with which to fasten their
galleys and ships of war to the shore.
About the time of our Revolutionary war, a considerable body of these
people crossed the Atlantic and settled on the coast of South
Carolina, near the North Carolina line, and they lived among the people
of Carolina for a number of years. At length the people of
Carolina began to suspect that they were mulattoes or free Negroes and
denied them the privileges usually accorded to white people. They
refused to associate with them on equal terms and would not allow them
to send their children to school with white children, and would only
admit them to join their churches on the footing of Negroes.
Race Holds Its
Own
South Carolina had a law taxing free Negroes so much per capita, and a
determined effort was made to collect this of them. But it was
shown in evidence on the trial of this case that they always
successfully resisted the payment of this tax, as they proved that they
were not Negroes. Because of their treatment, they left South
Carolina at an early day and wandered across the mountains to Hancock
county, East Tennessee; in fact, the majority of the people of that
country are “Melungeons,:” or allied to them in some way. A few
families of them drifted away from Hancock into the other counties of
east Tennessee and now and then into the mountainous section of Middle
Tennessee. Some of them live in White, some in Grundy and some in
Franklin county. They seem to prefer living in a rough,
mountainous and sparsely settled country.
One peculiarity of these people is that the dark color cannot be bred
out of them; they do not miscegenate or blend in color. It
frequently happens that a white man marries a “Melungeon” girl and
raises children by her, but the children always partake of the color of
one or the other parent; some of them will be white, like the father,
and some of them dark, like the mother. Sometimes the women bear
twins by a white sire, and one will be white and the other one
dark. The spectacle has often been seen of a mother suckling twin
babies, one white and the other dark. This is not true of a cross
between a white man and a Negro woman. A mulatto is always half
white and half black, and an octoroon can hardly be told from a
pure Caucasian, the Negro blood being so completely bred out.
While this is true, our southern high bred people will never tolerate
on equal terms any person who is even remotely tainted with Negro
blood, but they do not make the same objection to other brown or
dark-skinned people like the Spanish, the Cubans, the Italians, etc.
the term “Melungeons” is an East Tennessee provincialism; it was coined
by the people of that country to apply to these people. It is
derived from the french word ‘melange’ meaning a mixture, or medley,
and has got into the modern dictionaries. It was applied to these
people because at first it was supposed that they were of mixed
blood-part white and part Negro.
This name is a misnomer, because it has been conclusively proven that
they are not mixed with Negro blood, but are pure-blooded
Carthaginians, as much so was Hannibal and the Moor of Venice and
other pure blooded descendants of the ancient Phoenicians.
Fight at Every
Step
It was proven in the case that the grandfather of this girl was
accorded full right of a citizen while he lived in Hamilton
coutry. He was allowed to vote at all elections at a time when a
Negro could not vote and was allowed to testify in the courts when a
Negro was an incompetent witness.
Once, in Marion county, a white man named Perkins killed one of the old
man’s grandchildren and an indictment was found against him, with the
name of the old man marked as prosecutor. A plea in the
abatement was filed by the defendant, averring that he had no capacity
to become a prosecutor because he was a Negro. The defendant was
convicted and sent to the penitentiary for a long term.
The old man applied to the government for a pension on account of his
services to the country in the War of 1812. At the time of his
enlistment a Negro or a mulatto could not become a soldier in the
United States army at all. He had some difficulty in finding a
witness who could testify that he was in the army in that war. He
had put his case in the hands of a local pension attorney, who had
exhausted his resources in an effort to find satisfactory evidence in
support of his client’s claim.
Knew Company
Roll by Heart.
Someone told him that the old man could call the roll of his company
from the captain down to the last private on the list. He had
learned it from hearing the orderly sergeant call it over at roll
calls, and his habit was to repeat it as a sort of song or
medley. The attorney called him in and had him call the roll and
while he called the attorney wrote down the names. The old many
had forgotten the number of his regiment. All that he could tell
was that it was a South Carolina regiment. The attorney sent this
list of names to the war department at Washington, and a search was
made in the archives among the South Carolina regiments, and sure
enough, the muster roll of his company was found, containing the names
from the captain down, just as the old man had called them over to his
attorney. From this clue as a starting point he had no difficulty
in making out his case to the satisfaction of the pension commissioner.
This was a very important piece of evidence to defeat the Negro
imputation, because it was utterly impossible for a Negro to be an
enlisted man at the time. He might be hired as a teamster or a
cook, but could not be a soldier.
While the testimony was being taken some old-time Negroes were
introduced to prove that the Boltons, for that was the name of the old
man referred to, were kinky-headed Negroes. They were promptly
swore to this and said that the whole bunch of them had kinky hair,
just like a mulatto Negro.
Missing Witness
Appears
On being cross-examined they were asked if all of Bolton’s daughters
had kinky hair and that our girl’s mother had the same sort of
hair. They did not know that Betsy was in the land of the living;
in point of fact, the parties and attorneys on the other side did not
have a suspicion that she was any nearer than her Illinois hut in the
swamps of the Mississippi; but she was then on Williams island, having
been brought back here by Mr. Williams in pursuance of his promise to
her when he got her to let him fetch the girl back.
Notice was immediately served that on the following Saturday the
deposition of Betsy Bolton would be taken at the residence of Samuel
Willliams, and it was so taken. She was asked to cut off a lock
of her hair and pin it to her deposition. She reached up to her
topknot and pulled out her old-fashioned tucking comb, and a monstrous
mass of coal black hair as straight as the hair of a horse’s tail, fell
down to the floor. It was about four feet long and perfectly free
of a kink or a tendency to curl. She exhibited with her
deposition a fair sample of her magnificent hair, which
completely destroyed the depositions of the Negroes taken on the other
side to prove that the Bolton people were Negroes.
The case was patiently tried by the learned chancellor, who gave the
solicitors free scope to argue it as much as they pleased.
The decree was in favor of the girl and adjudged that she was the heir
apparent of her father and entitled to be supported and educated out of
his estate and to inherit his estate after his death. He directed
the guardian to provide liberally out of the funds in his hands for her
education and maintenance and to pay the young lawyer, who had fought
her battle single-handed against the most experienced and best legal
talent that could be found, $5,000 for his services. The young
man thought that was a pretty good fee to earn in his first year’s
practice.
His Memory Good
At one time Mr. Williams got alarmed at the splendid array of lawyers
that were pitted against his inexperienced solicitor, and he
contemplated sending to Knoxville for Col. John Baxter to take the
leading part in the case, but on reflection he decided that that would
be unjust to his solicitor, who had borne the burden of the preparation
of the case for trial; he thought he was entitled to the glory and the
compensation in case of success, and he therefore abandoned his purpose
engaging Col Baxter.
One of the funny incidents of this case was the following:
Joel Cross testified that he witnessed the marriage and that it
occurred in the big road in front of Squire Clark’s residence on June
14, 1856; he was closely examined by Judge Trewhitt, who thought that
he could catch him on his swearing so particularly to the date of the
marriage. He asked him how he was able after such a long lapse of
time, to swear to the precise date of the occurrence. His answer
was;
“Well judge, that was a notable day with
me; several things happened on that day to make me remember it.
While we were at breakfast that morning the report was brought to us
that a Baptist preacher who was carrying on a revival in the
neighborhood had got drunk and the meeting would have to be broken up;
a little later some young horses that were plowing in my field ran
away and tore down several acres of fine growing corn; and then, about
the middle of the afternoon, this marriage performed in the big road;
and lastly, we had a fine baby girl born at our house that evening and
I set down the date of her birth and her name in the Bible, and that is
how I know the date.”
The decree in this case was affirmed on appeal to the supreme court and
by this final act a great wrong was righted and a worthy girl was
vested with the title to a large fortune of the benefits of which she
had been deprived for many years.
