RVRHS Discussion Phorum

 New Topic  |  Go to Top  |  Go to Topic  |  Search  |  Log In   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 
 A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Don Lewis (1972) (---.proxy.aol.com)
Date:   03-21-03 20:36

Having been born and raised in and around Montreal, I have been a Habs fan all my life (and I'm pushing 50), even since I left Montreal for good in the mid 70's. No more.

The despicable display of the Montreal fans booing the American anthem at the Islanders game showed that they, the fans, are not only moronic, but have no class- and as corrupt a city as Montreal has always been- I always thought they had class (I guess there are no class houses there). It's bad enough we have a PM who can embarass the country to no end (and continually does)- now add the mindless fans of the most storied hockey team in history to that...shame, shame, shame...

Free speech is one thing- boorish behaviour is another- go Oilers!

Regards...

Don Lewis

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Kim (---.ipt.aol.com)
Date:   03-24-03 17:05

Bravo! Well said Don. I am a former RVR grad and ex-resident of the Montreal area and so is my husband. We consider ourselves to be "political refugees" and left the area quite some time ago to carve out a life for ourselves with our "English" last names! We have spend the last 15 years living in the states and have enjoyed a very good life here. We have made wonderful friends, enjoyed running our own business & were blessed with an "American" son! As a parent can love 2 children, I believe it is possible to love two countries..and I do!

As a Canadian I was embarassed to hear about the Canadians booing the American anthem! Those guys were there to play hockey and not personally responsible for the things going on in Iraq, to treat them like that was extremely ignorant and rude! If you want to protest the war, there are other venues in which to do it people!

Kim

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Tania Fell (---.qc.sympatico.ca)
Date:   03-24-03 20:33

Dear Don and Kim,

As a resident of this province, I was equally embarassed by the events at that hockey game. How "fans" can go in and boo a National Anthem, is beyond my comprehension. Given the state of this world that we live in right now, those "fans" should be thankful that they have a place to go and view such events, without the threat of having the entire arena blown up. (If they continue with antics like that, they probably will). But to then have Jean Beliveau go on the screen to ask the fans NOT to boo the National Anthem........come on folks, get a life. If you don't like the Americans, then voice your opinons at a rally, or a demonstration. These "fans" should take into consideration that there are other fans who really do want to watch a game, and might be hurt by the booing of the anthem. As I have family in the U.S., I find the past week a very difficult one to face. I'm not going to tell you if I'm "for" or "against" the war. I will never forget when I had to call my American clients, and they asked how it was to be a Canadian after having the boos in the Bell Center: embarassed.

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Glenn (209.47.49.---)
Date:   03-25-03 09:11

Anybody remember when the Detroit Piston fans booed the Canadian national anthem last year, for no apparent reason? It sparked a round of booing wars.

While I could never do this, remember, sports fans are often boorish. I was impressed in a way that many actually knew what was going on in the world enough to boo and show discontent with America.

I will always be a Habs fan, one that will never boo an anthem. It's difficult being a Habs fan these days, because the team is terrible, but I'll always cheer wildly for them.

Proud to be an RVR grad, proud to be a Habs fan, proud to be from Quebec and proud to be Canadian.

-Glenn

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Tom Wright (67.69.132.---)
Date:   03-25-03 16:11

I must say that it was embarrassing to see something of that nature occur at the game that night. No one likes to see that kind of reaction for whatever reason. However at the same time it is something that is equally practised in American cities as well after our anthem. There is quite a rich history of each country taking shots at one another whenever the opportunity arises. We have to remember that it was at a sporting event and alot of the times it is just a small group of drunken fans that start it and then it is just a chain reaction after that. Let's not let this blow out of proportion. (having said this I do not support what they did) I happen to love the United States and I believe that they are truly acting in everyones interest across the world. They are the leaders of the free and civilized world and we should all be thankful that we have a nation that is there to step into these types of situations and take the bulk of the load on their shoulders. If you believe the absolute nonsense propaganda that they are there for their own interests only ( oil or whatever the naive of the world believe) then you should wake up and smell the coffee. Nobody wants war however sometimes as our history shows us it is necessary. In this case I believe it is necessary. I will still remain a HABS fan though and always will be and also a supporter of the war in Iraq.

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: michel malin (4.43.100.---)
Date:   03-31-03 14:26

I agree, the booing was out of line but please lets not kill ourselves over this!! Booing is just a form of expression...no one got hurt. Maybe we should find out who the "booers" are, and boycott their work places!.. Sounds moronic doesn't it?! Sort of like Americans boycotting French products because of their different opinion? Or Americans not buying Dixie Chicks CD's because of their stance against the war?!! Isn't this what the war is suppose to be all about? "freedom" to speak, to live, to choose....

PS
Just in case you are wondering...
I'm for the war..
I live in the USA
I'm married to an American and have 2 American children

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Kevin Rankin (---.163-200-24.mtl.mc.videotron.ca)
Date:   04-01-03 06:39

Like everyone else here, I wasn't too impressed with the booing of the American national anthem at the hockey game, but I also agree with the points that M.Malin brought up.

It is a form of free speach and unfortunately we don't always agree with other peoples views.

Let's not forget that the Canadian national anthem has also been booed numerous times at both The Canadiens and Expos games. I remember several years ago, ( I think it was during the last referendum) that the Canadian anthem was booed at 2 or 3 games in row at the Olympic stadium. I think that was preceded by a Quebec flag being stomped on somewhere out west.

It seems that it has become a tradition here to boo the anthems to voice your displeasure with the government of the day.

Again, I don't agree with the booing of any National anthem, but you have to admit that it was effective. I don't see any thread on this website talking about any anti-war rallies in Vancouver, Toronto, New York or in any other city. The people at the forum just voiced the same opinion that other people voiced at those rallies.

I also didn't hear the American Ambassador to Canada talk about any of these rallies but we certainly heard him talking about the events at the hockey game.

In the event that the PQ wins the next election, calls a referendum and wins it, I know what I will do.

I'll buy a ticket for the next hockey game, and when they start to sing "Gens du Pays" instead of "Oh Canada" I'll let out a big BOOOOOO.

Kevin

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: michel malin (4.43.100.---)
Date:   04-01-03 13:51

I'm with you Kevin....I think I'd even blow some air miles to join you in the big boooooo (the only problem is Brisebois would probably think its about him!)

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Mike Sullivan (---.cg.shawcable.net)
Date:   04-04-03 23:47

As a former quebecer living in Alberta, I feel compelled to add my two cents: Given the results of the last "neverendum", one can assume that 50% of those who boo-ed the U.S. anthem were separtists who were in attendance to cheer on the "Canadiens".

Who knows what they want.

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: - (---.sympatico.ca)
Date:   04-06-03 23:28

Maybe the booing had nothing to do with French-speaking vs English-speaking (wouldn't that be quite a change!!!). How about how poorly Americans are treating Canadians for a decision our federal government has made about the war. How about the Americans having no class by refusing service to Canadians (French and English speaking), as well as treating them rudely when in the States. [This, by the way, I can say with 100% accuracy] Why? Because our federal government....NOT us little people...makes a decision that is unpopular to those who hypocritically turn around after and scream "no to war". How about them not knowing what they want. Maybe Canadians are letting it be known how tired they are of being dumped on by their all-mighty-holier-than-thou American neighbours. Although I find the act a bit tacky, I think it's about time we started standing together. We are one of the most divided countries.

Reply To This Message
 
 Re: A Canadiens fan no more...
Author: Marc Wigle (---.qc.sympatico.ca)
Date:   04-21-03 21:16

In my humble opinion, the only reason that the fans booed is because a game was played in Montreal before one was played in Toronto. If it had been the other way around, the fans in T.O. would have booed and then the counrtry would have ranted about the terrible fans at the ACC. If there had been no uproar as a resulf of the booing in Mtl then you could have bet the house that the fans would have booed in Toronto.

Reply To This Message
 Threaded View   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 


 
 Reply To This Message
 Your Name:
 Your E-mail:
 Subject:
   

phorum.org