STRAT PLANET
PLATOONING IN MLB VS LEAGUE PLAY
by Bill Dearing

    When comparing all aspects of baseball, and how they compare to a SOM
league we find out that we have the closest thing to real MLB to date. In
fact the only thing that I know of that varies from MLB is the amount of
platoons, as we will platoon way more in our leagues than actually happens in
MLB.

    I often wonder why I don't see more platoon situations in baseball. I
mean baseball has become a specialized sport, statistics are available to
everyone, and the lefty/righty concept has been around for years! One reason
for this could be a player's health. If a full time player is nursing a
nagging injury then the manager will give him days off whenever he is
favoring his injury regardless of the opposing pitcher for that game, but by
far the number one reason is money! If I have Ray Lankford, and Ron Gant on
my team they are going to platoon in left Field. I don't think any team in
MLB would carry those kinds of salaries for one position let alone two or
three positions. Teams tend to adopt what I call financial platooning where
they use their bench players to give regulars days off against certain
pitchers, and their regulars get about 100 at bats more than they would in a
straight platoon situation. Finally, with all the offense around any extra
roster spots were needed for pitchers, and pitching staff's were still pushed
to the limit.

    One thing that will happen in baseball as well as in life is that things
will change, and in some cases change back. It has been announced that
baseball will go back to an old concept of the game, and some of you may
remember it, a strike zone. I like this move and hope it helps out the
pitching. We could have decent pitching in our leagues, and naturally MLB
managers will counter with more position players, and thus more platoon's
which would put a few more players in our draft. So keep you fingers crossed
that a balance between pitching and hitting can be achieved in MLB.

    In our SOM leagues it is easy to see why we platoon at positions so
much. Leagues rarely exceed 24 teams so there is a surplus of players to use,
and be it to cover at bats, or to have your best hitters in the lineup, every
team will platoon if they want too compete. By using the lineups in the
computer manager we will always be able to start the game with the best side
of our platoon, but there is no guarantee that HAL will pull the trigger, and
pinch hit with the other half of your platoon when its the 7th inning and
your clinging to a one run lead, and sure could use some insurance runs.
There are a few options at your disposal to try to increase the odds of HAL
making the move. Using the avoid rightys, and avoid leftys under the players
options is a must. You can also take the two players from one of you platoons
and insert them into the pinch hit vs. lefty, and pinch hit vs. righty in the
batters page of your computer manager. I even go as far as to check the boxes
next to don't PH vs. lefty and righty in hopes that HAL will pinch hit for
him when the time comes because it is the only time the settings will allow
for him to be pinch hit for. Use these ideas as they will help you get the
most out of your team, and may all your split rolls be low!

TEST YOUR SOM KNOWLEDGE:
Since it is my first article I just couldn't resist throwing this one at you.
We all know that just about anything that can happen in baseball can also
happen in SOM. In fact in all my years there is only one thing I know of that
will happen on rare occasions in baseball, but can never happen in SOM.  This
is what my trivia question is about. If you know the answer e-mail it to me.
The first one to answer it correctly will win nothing more than a mentioning
in my next article. This is just for fun.

QUESTION: When players are at bat in SOM what is the one thing that can only
happen to position players, and will never happen to any pitcher while they
are at bat?

Return to this week's articles