home reviews awards oscars music lists links
    2005 2004 a - e f - l m - r s - z 2003 Unreleased
 
800 BULLETS (Alex de la Iglesia, 2002, Spain)
When I was a kid, I wrote some stories that I read nowadays and I find them ridiculous but normal considering my age. 800 balas looks like it was written by a 10-year-old boy. It's nonsensical, insulting and it's also very long!
 
THE AVIATOR (Martin Scorsese, 2004, USA)
Technically speaking, the movie is excellent. But Scorsese still has a problem with length because not only the movie is unbearably long but it’s also irrelevant. The Aviator just tells distant anecdotes about Howard Hughes without being deep. As a whole, the movie doesn’t have a unity. Just you take any subject you want (the Katherine Hepburn affair, the plane crash or the trial for example) and you’ll still have the same movie, because those separated anecdotes don’t seem to influence in Hughes’ personality, and what’s worse, they don’t say or mean anything.
 
BAD EDUCATION (Pedro Almodovar, 2004, Spain)
While the movie is receiving mixed reviews, I still think this is one of his best films to date. Bad Education is an interesting noir movie about relationships and betrayals. An original screenplay with some twists and stories within stories.
 
BEFORE SUNSET (Richard Linklater, 2004, USA)
Some people will be upset because the only thing the two characters do is talk (even though they should’ve known that, considering its Before Sunrise’s sequel), but what they say is, actually, really interesting.
 
BEING JULIA (Istvan Szabo, 2004, UK, USA)
A witty and funny movie. Being Julia has a great start, it falls somewhere in the middle but fortunately it rises again at the end (even though I found the finale very cruel). But the great pleasure of the film is Annette Bening who, of course, is wonderful and elevates the material. Yes, she gets the role of a lifetime, but it perfectly fits her; she’s ideal for the role and I can’t imagine someone else playing Julia.
 
BIRTH (Jonathan Glazer, 2004, UK, USA)
A personal favorite. Amazingly, most of reviewers didn’t like this film because they found it predictable and not very deep, but Birth is one of those productions were everything (and I mean everything) is perfectly done: Alexandre Desplat’s score is marvelous; Nicole Kidman proves again that she’s the best working actress today; and Glazer promises a very good career. And my congratulations to the director and screenwriters for dealing such polemic subject with class and tact.
 
THE BLIND SWORDSMAN: ZATOICHI (Takeshi Kitano, 2003, Japan)
 
BON VOYAGE (Jean-Paul Rappeneau, 2003, France)
 
CLOSER (Mike Nichols, 2004, USA)
It’s really hard to like a film with “disgusting”, “selfish”, “coward” and “buster” characters. Still, that’s not even the problem. The thing is, Closer is too cold and distant to tell a good love story (pessimistic or not), because everything seems calculated and unnatural.
 
COFFEE & CIGARETTES (Jim Jarmusch, 2003, USA)
There are only two really good shorts (the one with Cate Blanchett and the one with Rice & Mead); the others are just good, mediocre or bad. I give this movie two stars as an average, because there are more bad shorts than good ones.
 
COLLATERAL (Michael Mann, 2004, USA)
The most entertaining part is the very last one, the rest is very insipid. Some scenes are completely ridiculous (the shooting in the club is delirious). And… take note, please: mixing suspense with stupid jokes never works; believe me, it ruins the whole atmosphere. In a few words: nothing special.
 
DAWN OF THE DEAD (Zach Snyder, 2004, USA)
The movie never stops because Snyder doesn’t want you to get bored. Sometimes it feels like he’s obligated to do that, but, well… it works. The plot promises you fun and that’s what you’ll get (if you like this kind of films).
 
DARKNESS (Jaume Balaguero, 2002, Spain)
Darkness Instead of saying this is a bad film; let’s say it’s a good B-Movie. It’s a decent and entertaining horror production where the finale is totally electrifying and non-stopping. Of course, I saw the uncut and R-Rated version, so I can’t imagine how bad the American version could be.
 
THE DAY AFTER TOMORROW (Ronald Emmerich, 2004, USA)
Guilty pleasure of the year? Well… not exactly, considering I know it’s not a very good film. But, I do have to admit it was a nice surprise to find out that it was not as awful and insulting as Emmerich’s previous films. Delirious and clichéd but okay.
 
DISTANT (Nuri Bilge Ceylan, 2002, Turkey)
 
DOGVILLE (Lars von Trier, 2003, Denmark)
Lars von Trier keeps saying that world is filled with evil people by torturing his female characters again. But this time he says it better. The original set design and the excellent metaphor of how ungrateful the society can be, specially with immigrants, make this movie worth a look.
 
THE DOOR IN THE FLOOR (Tod Williams, 2004, USA)
 
THE DREAMERS (Bernardo Bertolucci, 2003, Italy)
The best thing about the movie are the characters, even though I also found them really snobbish and pedant. The worst thing about it, is that the film feels empty: the relationship between the two siblings is incomplete and the spirit of that era is completely forgotten.
 
ETERNAL SUNSHINE OF THE SPOTLESS MIND (Michel Gondry, 2004, USA)
I admit it; I’ve never liked Charlie Kaufman that much. But this time his screenplay has a meaning, is more original and Michel Gondry’s inventive elevates the movie to a better material.
   
 
The Blind Swordsman: Zatoichi
Bon Voyage
Distant
The Door in the Floor