Katie Melua has a sweet style, but she’s not Norah
Jones nor a Joss Stone, and but her warm style has
more in common with the former than the latter, but
with a sweeter sound instead of Ravi’s daughter’s
husky tones. It’s all very sophisticated for a teenager,
and as such it’s hard not to feel like you’re being
sold for a patsy.
The marketing for Katie Melua has
evolvied, with almost singular purpose, in the
same way that Norah
exploded with her first album – a low-key release
was followed by intensive marketing to the ‘just
right’ folks, and long touring, and then (presumably
while she’s off making her much-anticipated follow-up)
this double-DVD effort.
It’s hard not to like her sound – as evidenced
by both the live show at Fairfields Hall in Croydon
back in March 2004, but more so in the Concert for
Nelson Mandela’s 46664 Charity almost a year to the
day later, she’s a clever little performer who can
engage the crowd. But, perhaps most importantly of
all, can she deliver songs like “Mockingbird Song” in
the style and grandeur that they deserve?
Er, no. She looks the part, she’s got all the right
moves, and when she scats it doesn’t so absolutely
appalling, just mildly so. But the thing is the girl
has absolutely no range, and when she speaks not
sings she sounds like a complete and utter lower
class Pom, not some über-cool jazz performer. That’s
beside the point, because it’s the lack of range
and lack of strength in her voice that will be her
downfall.