Craig Finn
has a way with words like few others. It’s not
about economy or verbosity – it’s just about what
he says. From the moment he says “She said always
remember/Never to trust me” on opener “Hornets!
Hornets!” as an introduction to the central character
of Charlemagne on Separation Sunday, it’s
all systems GO!
Of course, if it was just the lyrics on Separation
Sunday that made it such a fascinating and
absorbing listen then the Hold Steady would only
be doing half the job. Thankfully, that’s far from
the case; instead the music is nothing short of
radical in that it’s not in keeping with any stylistic
movement. Instead, the backing to Finn’s thematic
tale of addiction, loss and ultimate redemption
is classic rock.
The warm keyboard of Franz Nicolay makes him the
essential ingredient and difference between Separation
Sunday and its predecessor Almost Killed Me.
His flourishes on the likes of “Cattle and the Creeping
Things” and “Stevie Nix” are as thrilling as Jim
Steinman’s on Bat Out of Hell. Yep, with songs
like “Your Little Hoodrat Friend” and “Banging Camp” (with
that line “I dig those awkward silences/Because I
grew up in denial and went to school in Massachusetts”)
the Hold Steady are as anthemic as Meat Loaf was
at his best. Elsewhere the guitar work, with a killer
solo on “Charlemagne in Sweatpants”, is just awesome.
Oh, yeah, ‘cos it’s all about the
anthems on Separation
Sunday. But, again, it comes back to the combination
of Finn and the musical backing – without the one
complementing the other, perhaps the Hold Steady
would be just another very good band, instead of
the great one that they clearly are. It’s not for
no reason that they’ve been touted as ‘mclusky
meets the E Street Band’, with vicious barbed lyrics
coupled with classic Americana rock.
So, with Separation Sunday having
already garnered acclaim aplenty in 2005 (when
it was released
in the band’s native United States), it would now
seem that it will just as likely earn similar kudos
in 2006 outside of that particular country. The music
converts simply because the album really is just
that good. The theme of Catholic guilt and drug addiction
/ recovery is and will always be universal. And,
as the Hold Steady prove on Separation Sunday,
great rock ‘n roll will never die.