[ACoS: 25, Mindtrap, 417-19]
[TPoD: 2, Unweaving, 81-4]
[WH: 13, Wonderful News, 319]
[WH: 35, With the Choedan Kal, 646]
First of all, I don't believe that Moridin is a born-again-Chosen simply because the Dark One has not shown that much sympathy toward the Chosen. If Osan'gar and Aran'gar truly are Aginor and Balthamel (respectively), then I believe that is as far as the Dark One's mercy would go. Just look at them. They now obey Shadar Haran, the more-than-ordinary Halfman, yet Shadar Haran seems to serve Moridin, or at least respects (?) him as an equal. Haran goes to "visit" Graendal in TPoD to "convince" her to serve Moridin. Moghedian has certainly failed him; she's now being held by a mindtrap (again, by Moridin). Asmodean was killed, apparently by an agent of the DO (or so one would assume). No, I'm afraid that the DO has not been such a merciful overlord in the past. Much less, I don't believe that he would grant someone who has failed him (all of the dead Chosen) to be named Nae'blis.
Furthermore, Moridin has given no indication in his thoughts or words that indicate that he is born-again. RJ made quite sure in the brief intro to Osan' and Aran' that they were reincarnations. Who is Moridin, then? I think that perhaps he is someone from the Age of Legends that we have never seen before, and I believe this because of a small, but perhaps significant change in the Glossary entry for "The Forsaken." It states: "While it has long been believed that they alone abandoned the Light during the War of the Shadow, in fact others did as well; these thirteen were only the highest ranking among them." Coincidence? This is also the first Glossary entry to include Moridin's name among the Forsaken. Again, coincidence? If he isn't a born-again-Chosen, then what the he** is he? That, my friends, I don't know. (I never said I knew everything.)Okay, I admit it, I was wrong. It would seem that Moridin is in fact a reborn Ishamael. Just look at those last two entries.
The first one seems to state quite matter-of-factly that he has been reborn once before. The second one, the one about the madness, leads directly to Ishamael. He had been mad for years, before and after the Bore, and it would seem that some tinges of that still remain. After all, only someone that mad would be so blase about handling the True Power.
See also:
Shayol Ghul: The Forsaken: Ishamael
Updated 01/18/01