| Year | Hornsby (MVP) | Johnson (Cy Young) | Mantle (ROY) |
| 2005 | No Award Given | No Award Given | No Award Given |
| 2006 | Albert Pujols- Wooley Swamp | Carlos Zambrano- Wooley Swamp | Javier Valentin- FHoD |
| 2007 | Justin Morneau- Wooley Swamp | Roy Halladay- Wooley Swamp | Jonathan Papelbon- Wooley Swamp |
| 2008 | Alex Rodriguez- Green-Wood | Rich Hill- Las Vegas | Dustin Pedroia- Green-Wood |