Van Morrison
by Johnny Rogan
191 pages
Copyright 1984 by Proteus Books
Review by Nathan Wirth:
While this book does offer some interesting anecdotes and snippets
of interviews, Rogan is far too preoccupied with exposing the real
man behind the myth to offer a objective overview of Morrison's
career. The book starts off with a fairly interesting look at Van's
childhood and covers his career up until Inarticulate Speech of
the Heart. Rogan seems obsessed with proving that Morrison,
while a talented writer, performer, and singer, is not worthy of the
myth status that he has gained, and, specifically, that Astral Weeks is
hardly worthy of all the praise it has received. Rogan presents
Morrison as rude, thankless, self centered, and clueless as to the
proper way to present himself to the public, completely dismissing
Van's valid view that the record industry is only concerned with
sales, citing the opinion as further proof of Van's rudeness and
foolish disregard for self promotion.
The book also suffers from being rather dated. Rogan goes through
great effort to show that Morrison is an inconsistent performer and
does not care for touring. While this may have been true before, Van
tours regularly now and appears to be comfortable with it. I would
also add that the book is weighed down heavily by the author's
opinions, which something as objective as a biography should not
even include -- and the author's views seem almost like they are a
result of the fact that he knows Morrison would likely condemn the
book's existence. Still, despite all of the book's faults, it is an
interesting read.
(Rogan has also written books about the Byrds, Neil Young and
Roxy Music. More recently he has also published a new
biography of Van Morrison.)
Part of the van-the-man.info unofficial website
|