Observations and Findings Suggestive of True and Untrue Traumatic Memory (compiled and modified from Fredrickson)
from Memory and Abuse by Charles Whitfield
Observation True Memory
Untrue Memory
High Risk Disorders Present
Yes
No
Attractions, fears or avoidances unexplained
by known history
May be Present
Absent
Indications of Emerging Memories (e.g.
dreams, images, flashbacks or somatic sensations
May be Present
Absent
Evidence of Dissociation
Often Present
Absent
Time Loss
Often present
Absent to Slight
Supplying inconsequential detail in abuse history
May be Present
Absent
Story matches depth of pain and symptoms
throughtout life
Usual
May be Present
Tends to avoid sympathy and support
May be Present
May be Absent
Knows or senses how a perpetrator will act
May be Present
Absent
Corroborationg data present
(e.g. medical, witness, photos)
Usually Absent, but
helpful if present
Absent
High Ambivalence about abuse, memories
May be Present
Absent to Present
Evidence of florid imagination, psychosis
or pathological lying (but dissociation may
resemble and person may be misdiagnosed)
Usually Absent
May be Present