Barbered wire
Graphic by Martin
Barbered wire

Operation Musketeer

( Operation Mousquetaire )

Chapter 14

The Days after Port Said Under Sieg

The destiny had chosen his target and  hit strongly.....The smashing hand was so powerful and mighty... we were knocked out... we lost balance...we laid on our back and the counting bagan.

The sound of rattling machine guns did not stop...though single shots were to be heared here and there, but they faded slowly during Wednesday the 7th. November....  At sunsust, there were mostly nothing to hear, but the sound of sadness and doubt....  Many have lost all their belongings, many more have marked the day as damned day of their life...more have lost every thing.... It is the terrible moment that follows war.......

A remarcable calmness has come upon the city,.. every one was walking around trying to find out the rest of his whereabouts.., the family,..the friends,..the people we knew.... Many of the building that stood there for ages were
only a rubble...seceral collapsed....  Port Said was never built to face war...... and we were NOT prepared for such...

All of a sudden, we saw British soldiers around every corner....and patrolling every where, ....military cars, armoured vehicles ...., helicopters hovering above the city..... Leaflets of the invadors were no remedy.....

The air was not only full of tense, but also a piculiar penetrating smell has dominated the air.... Not only we have  smelled the burned buldings with all its contents....and inhabitents, but the worst of all was the small of death that dominated the city. Corpses laid tévery where and the Red Cross could not move them all as soon as possible.... many citzens have forgotten the moment and have helped removing them.....many were burried any where there was sand to cover them... Egyptians and particularly Moslems do respect death.... it will hit every one of us...

The tense was felt every where you go... Sadness,....doubt...were soon replaced by  determination to overcome this
status.....Many many patrolling British soldiers (most of them as young as I was),... faces we saw  5  months ago full of joy living side by side with us, were now carrying their rifles with bayonettes...walking  carefully and slowly  along the streets.....  we wereleft alone....and we were besieged...

A fact  for the records

The remarkable thing, that many many British soldiers were seeking immediately contact with us,...they were trying to explain to us that THEY did NOT want this war to happen against us.. and that they were doing their duty (and had to ),  otherwide they will be court marshalled....Many talked to us, many others approached us and never knew how they could start talking...at the beginning we have avoid them, but later, we got into hot discussions...

We have noticed a look of guilt in many eyes....many have apologized and asked for forgiveness.... It was the politician's decision and not theirs.... It was not the war of some days ago... it was something else we also faced ..

This was the strange attitude we have noticed from several soldiers .... They were asking for our understanding to what has happend....it  was a piculiar situation...

This attitude was represented  later in the way how in PORT SAID, things were different to Port Fouad, where the french have took control

But all that did not stop the fact, that Port Said and Port Fouad fall and was besieged..... and that we were occupied militarly, we lost our freedom. The flow of military equipment began to roll... and the harbour was filled with several huge gray structures of death.... The Royal Navy has blocked the line of horizon with his large ships, the French were doing the same and were witnessing the occupation which no Hollywood movie could have presented as real as it is......

Though the British troops were around the city, but they did not gain control of it completely.... We have started to build our Resistance pocket, not only in the Arab town, but also within them.....in El Efrang ( the European part
of the city)....

It was a disillusioning period for every one....  A dangerous tension began to build up...
 
 

The unanswered big Why ??
Sir General H. Stockwell has hesitated to let the British ships enter the waters of Port Said to dislodge their loads of war equipment before the minesweapers have swept the area and confirmed that it is free of mines - particularly the soviet made mines -. Consequentlly, this hesitation has caused a serious delay of implementing the war plans and created an additional tension between him and his deputy, the French General Andree Baufre. The result was that neither the rest of 6 RTR nor the armoured cars, field guns,transport lorrys, jeeps, batallions logistic materials, amunition, mobile Radar units, weapons or etc., which mounted to 30.000 tons were at the disposal of the fighting units in after more than 48 houres.
In addition, General Stockwell refused to disembark 3 Infantry Brigade, 2 Para, 1 Para, mainly needed soldiers to proceed and advance southwards along the Suez Canal to take Qantara, then attack Ismailia and eventually branch from there both westwards to Cairo and southwards to capture Suez advance The essential equipment needed for advancing southward were not vaialable ontime. The troops disembarked to face - a near to no actions status - waiting for them in Port Said. The Euphoria was gone.... and frustration began to sneek his way to the troops.
 
General Stockwel seems to have anticipated the Egyptian tactics or their eventual plans, to draw his troops to the desert plains south of El Qantara, where the Egyptians would have launched a possible armoured counter attack. He had 48 Centurions and 30 light AMX-13 at his disposal to face the outnumbering heavy Stalin Russian tanks, several T34 mediuum tanks, SU-100 self-propelled antitank guns, the new type of Czeh anti-tank gunand the 32-barrelled rocket launchers which has been deployed against 3 Para the day before may have added more eventual reasons to his concerns.

May be , because the cease fire was ordered, General Stockwell was simply avoiding pulling him and his troops in a needless attrition and Guerella war against his soldiers, where the Egyptians have the advantage a backing infrastructure - both geographically and in Human resources - knowing their own terrain.
Was he a far sighted tactician ? or did he have intellegence information about what would come ???
The fact is, his hesitation has saved eventual greater British and French human losses.The information available and published about the Egyptian counter-attack plan, to drag the Anglo-French soldiers in a savage attrition Guerella war confirms his (assumptions)

Captured Egyptian equipments
by the British Forces in Port Said


The amount of captured Egyptian military equipments in Port Said is a sad indication of the city's preparation for ther war and the to be expected outcome.... No wonder....!!

The captured military equipments by the Anglo-French forces during the operations were listed by the British Ministry of Defence on the 21st November included many rifles and a pair of field guns in addition to 3 Self-propelled antitank guns SU-100 Self-propelled anti-tank guns, Rocket launchers, new type of Czeh anti-tank gun, Praga 10-ton vehicles Lorries, 32-barrelled rocket launchers, light machine-guns, Rifles and sub-machine-guns, Personal weapons (Enfield and similar), Large quanteties of ammunition, Amounts of British origin anti-tank mines, 6-pdr anti-tank guns, 3.7-inch guns, Field guns(All equipment details are available in my book):
  

Captured Egyptian equipments
by the French in Port Fouad

General Jaques Massu, has listed on page 264 of his book " Vérité sur Suez 1956" the captured Egyptian military equipments by the French forces during the operations as follows: although he does not explain that the French trrops have captured the Port Fouad local police station, of which weapons a large part is included, and that of many retreating soldiers from Sinai who were found helpless in the surroundings of Port Fouad)

1. Captured by 2e R.P.C and enforcement units on 5th an 6th November, (All equipment details are available in my book

Sad facts and the agony of war
The War toll of the Anglo-French Operations

Death, casualties, handicaped and lost The British and French losses

Britsh and French casualties sustained in Port Said landing appear to have been 32 killed, 132 wounded and 1 missing (French pilot). Never the less, there are some discrepancies between the the abovementioned figures and those announced by General Keightly´s headquarters announced on 14th November, these were given as 32 killed and 129 wounded, 1 missing

Both these figures do not include the post-invasion loses and casualties correcting the definate final total figures of operation Musketeer. The real truth about the war toll of death, casualties, handicaped and lost seems to will stay for ever in dark on both sides.

The first published Britsh and French casualties sustained in Port Said landing appear to have been, 32 killed, 132 wounded And 1 missing (French pilot).
 



British Casualties & Losses
Killed Wounded Missing
Royal Navy 1 0 0
Royal Marines 9 60 0
Army 8 36 0
Royal Air Force 4 1 0
British Totals 22 97 0


French Casualties & Losses
Killed Wounded Missing
Navy 4 0 0
Army 10 33 0
Air Force 0 0 1
French Totals 14 33 1


Anglo-French Casualties & Losses
Killed Wounded Missing
British Totals 22 97 0
French Totals 14 33 1
Aglo-French Totals 36 130 1

But we have to consider, that the Invasion has ended on 22nd December 1956. Discrepancies continue to excist between the abovementioned detailed figures and the figures announced on 14th November by Genera Keightly´s headquarters. These were given as follows

    32 killed
    129 wounded
    1 missing
Neither of the abovementioned figures have considered or included the post-invasion loses and casualties after the fall of Port Said and its occupation, nor those were caused during the secret resistance against the Anglo-French troops. Therefore the definate correct final total of all the losses during Operation Musketeer seems to stay in dark forever.

The Truth from own mouth
Death, casualties, handicaped and lost

The French

Referring to the often citated famous book that was seized by the French Government upon ist publication ( "St. Michael and the Dragon " memories of a paratrooper),. Written by Pierre Leulliette, a member of the B.P.C Battalion Parachutiste Colonial who participated in the French Para Assault on Raswa and the invasion of Port Fouad. Pierre Leulliette documents as of page 218, quote "....The first casualty list indicates sixty of our regiment wounded.

The hospital ship takes them on board. Our thirteen dead, we bury almost secretly in the sand, behind the barracks. A fourtenth, listed as missing, is found a few days later , riddles with bullets, behind what had been the enemy lines .......". According to my researches and information, the bodies of remains of these soldiers are still in their place since 1956where they have been burried then......A weak after the burial of our Regiment's , a great ceremony to honor all the dead of Force H brings out a few generals and some sort of cabinet minister. As there are no ammusements any more, many come to it as a party. While the list of dead - much longer than we'd thought - is being read before the eight hundred men in attention.. I had the sad honor of responding, after each name, with the traditional "mort pour la France". It takes so long that at the end no one is listining........"

It is the obligation of every civilized Government, particularly the French government to care for the graves of
its fallen soldiers in a military conflict.

The British

The British still keep their - secret - under tight cover. I know for sure, - from my interviews with several Medics who landed with the British troops - that 5 soldiers of No. 45 Royal Marine Commandos were dead during the fightings on November 6th. .Thy were laid (with the green berets covering their faces) on the terrace of Casino Palace, before they were carried away with the Helicopters back to Theseus.

There has been similar casualities at the El Gamil and during the street fights. A Buffalo driver was shot by Egyptian snipers during penetrating The Mohamed Aly street which had stopped his LVT from proceeding forward, and his comerades from 42 RMC had to change their LVT and go into another one, in order to reach their destination in the Gulf camp. Many 42 RMC has suffered fatal injuries during their approach to the building blocks facing the amphepian landing on the shore. Other 42 RMC were killed or injured during their advance to the Governorate Building.

The Street fightings that followed, particularly at the El Mahrousa street have costed 42 RMC addiotnal loses.
Also the Wyvern friendly fire on 42 RMC C troop had costed them 3 dead.

On the sea shore, some were fatally wounded and were carried away by LVTs. The Navy House fightings have costed 40 RMC and 42 RMC casualties and dead. A larger amount of injuries and death was caused during the Navy House fierce fightings. This concludes the unreality of the abovementioned publishe figures by the British MOD. The same applies to the French troops in Port Fouad, which resulted in the attrocities reported and documented.

The Egyptian casualties losses

The Egyptian casualties were the subject of a British Government report by Sir Edwin Herbert. His findings was that the Egyptian casualties in Port Said were moderate .The British official estimate of Egyptian casualties has been critisized as being too low.

Egyptians Casualties,  dead , wounded,  wounded and detained in hospital with further slightly wounded , missing
Civilans, Police and Military unkwonly burried or other Assumed killed in the City flames



Egyptian & English Figures of Casualties & Losses
Egyptian figures Killed Wounded Missing
Port Said 600 900 1.200
British figures
Port Said 1.200 743 618
Port Fouad 100

You are my today's

Web guest

Thank you for your visit



Part Fifteen

Author's remark

Select a Language


Back to Index & proceed

Graphic by Martin



© 2000 Yahia Al Shaer. All rights reserved.

This web site is maintained by

ICCT, Internet Computer Consulting & Training, Germany, USA, UK

Specialized in multilingual "Arabic, English, German and French" Internet applications, Home-pages and Web-sites, design implementation, consulting and training.