A strange thing happened to me a few days ago. I was rummaging through the information available via the link below, when I came across a review that caught my eye. It mentioned a transcending of genres. A book that was marketed as young adult holding its own with the best that fantasy has to offer. Before that moment, I had not considered The Golden Compass or The Subtle Knife to be anything other than fantasy.
This occurrence is not remarkable in any way, save its revelatory nature. In retrospect, the review is quite sensible. It is simply a matter of perspective.
[ The Subtle Knife ] Wow. I finished this book yesterday. Pullman continues to exceed my expectations. I say that with the utmost admiration. In my opinion, he has taken the trilogy to a higher level with this book.

Lyra is maturing. While that is occasionally obvious, it is often suggested in an entertaining fashion. Her relationship with Will is wonderful. It gives the reader a glimpse of a hidden facet of her character. Lyra's relationship with Iorek (and her mother around the time of their reunion) was based upon love and respect. With Will, there is also the concept of equality. Emotionally, they are children. That kinship is beautiful.
The story is sombre. The death of Lee Scoresby is magnificent. Will's reunion with his father is perfect. I suspected that it would be unpleasant, but not tragic. Will's reaction is chilling.

Do you agree? Send me any comments you might have.
Last modified: March 31, 1998
[ Bag End - An Interpretation ]
bag_end@oocities.com
Many thanks to my contributors.