Don't let the government scapegoat
refugees and immigrants
Slam the door on Racists
IN IRELAND we are more used to emigration than immigration, but
this is starting to change. In the last year, the tiny trickle of
immigration has increased slightly, and the number of people seeking
asylum here has risen from a few hundred to a few thousand. This is
still a trickle by European standards, but it comes as a shock to
some. Ireland has for so long been a uniformly white country, that
even a handful of black faces is enough to spark fear - and hatred.
Racism in Ireland, as everywhere else, tends to be stronger in the
poorest areas. The reason is simple - when you don't have much, you
have to hold on tight to what you've got. These are also the areas
where most asylum seekers live. Because asylum seekers are visibly
different, and are new to the community, its easy to separate them,
to say that they're taking things that should be yours - your houses,
your dole, your job. So if you want a better life, you start by
taking back what should be yours, by right of birth, by right of
colour. That's how the racists want us to see it.
A Black and White Solution?
The logic seems obvious, but there's a big problem with it. The
briefest look shows that it isn't logical at all. You can't blame
refugees for the poverty of the more deprived areas, because it was
just as bad before they got here. How can they be stealing our jobs,
when there aren't that many jobs to 'steal' in the first place?
Indeed, as the government does not let refugees work or study until
their cases have been heard, and only a handful have have had their
hearings to date, the overwhelming majority are forced to survive on
Community Welfare (the lowest welfare payment there is).
And if asylum seekers were to be stopped from claiming welfare,
would their money be divided up between the rest of us, or would it
go on another tax amnesty? We all know the answer. Asylum seekers are
an easy target, since there aren't many of them and they don't have
much power. They are being used as scapegoats for the government's
neglect of the low paid and unemployed.
In contrast, the last year has given us a good example of
something worth fighting against. The campaign against heroin has
involved thousands of people organising, as communities, against
something that is destroying those communities. The campaign has been
strong enough to hold together in the face of sustained harassment by
the gardaí and vilification in the media. Now that it has had
some success in its immediate aims, making many places no-go areas
for pushers, what's left is a group of organisations with strong
local support and involvement, who are beginning to look at the
problems that caused the heroin epidemic.
For all the talk of the "Celtic tiger', there are many places
which have been passed over by the economic boom. Areas where housing
and education are drastically underfunded, and where, for many, it
seems like the choice is between heroin and the dole queue. Who is
responsible? Is it refugees, who have to leave their families and
friends, their whole lives, behind to escape from war or government
persecution? Or is it the politicians, who only care about drugs when
they spread to the more affluent suburbs, and are more concerned with
tax amnesties for their rich friends than with creating well paid
useful jobs?
The Colour of Money
In the run-up to the last general election, many politicians made
great play of the increase in the number of refugees arriving in
Ireland recently, appealing to people's prejudices in an attempt to
win votes. One of the last acts of the outgoing government was to
order the deportation of 500 refugees. Since then, the press has been
full of stories about refugees causing crime or sponging off the
dole, blowing up every tiny incident out of all proportion. It is
against this background that the Anti Racist Campaign (ARC) was set
up a few months ago. It was formed to counter the lies being spread
about refugees, and to stop the growth of racism in Ireland.
Its important to see that the cause of racism, here as anywhere
else, isn't simply fear of the new, or not understanding other
cultures. If it was, then racism could be fought simply by educating
people about different cultures, and we could expect racism to die
out after a generation or so. Racism would stop being a problem once
children from different cultures started going to school together.
But in America, or England, where different races have lived side by
side for decades, or centuries, racist attacks continue. And there is
an obvious pattern - racism increases during recessions and decreases
during booms. Visible racism, (abuse and attacks) is always stronger
in poorer areas.
The real issue, the real reason why refugees are being attacked,
is money. Working class people are being encouraged to divide against
themselves, the Irish poor being set against the non-Irish (and
non-white) poor. At the same time, for those who have a couple of
million to invest, there are plenty of Irish passports available. The
former president of Mexico, Carlos Salinas, was able to settle in
Ireland recently, and you can be sure he wasn't asked to prove his
'refugee' status. It doesn't matter what language they speak, or what
colour their skin, the rich will always look after each other.
Across Europe, while integration is supposed to lead to freedom of
movement, the borders around Europe are getting higher and tighter.
Again, if you're from a rich country or have money, you won't have
any trouble getting in. But if you're fleeing civil war, or
'friendly' dictatorships who want to lock you up for talking too much
about democracy, you're out of luck. Inside Europe, there's another
type of border between richer and poorer areas. Every city and
country in Europe has its poverty-stricken localities, where long
term unemployment and anti-social crime are concentrated. And, just
like in Ireland, the politicians and police aren't too concerned as
long as they can contain it in those areas.
Time to See Red
Our government, every government, wants to keep those barriers up.
They want to keep refugees out, not because of their race or colour,
but because they're poor. And the Irish working class are kept out
too - kept away from the resources and power to make the decisions
effecting our lives. We may have the same colour skin as our rulers,
but our interests clash.
We want decent homes, decent jobs, good hospitals and schools, but
politicians are concerned with 'managing the economy', ensuring 'good
industrial relations' with a 'flexible workforce'. What does this
mean? That we work on contract, rather than real jobs, with no
security, and few rights. That our unions, where they're allowed, are
bought off with 'social partnership' deals, offering minimal pay
increases in return for an almost total abolition of strikes. That
nothing gets in the way of the rich getting richer and the poor
getting poorer.
Anarchism, ultimately, is about freedom and equality. Everyone
should have an equal say in the decisions that effect them, and the
freedom to live their own lives as they see fit, the only limitation
being the equal freedom of others. Obviously then, we oppose border
controls and refuse the false distinction between 'economic' and
'political' refugees.
Equally, we oppose discrimination on the basis of colour or
language, just as we oppose discrimination on the basis of sex or
religion, and have always opposed the cruel racism against Travellers
which so often goes unchallenged in Ireland. Institutional racism is
the biggest enemy (immigration controls, deportations, etc.), but one
which gets little mention. The people we should be fighting are the
rich who make their profits from our work, and the politicians who
make their money telling us what to do; not the victims they want us
to scapegoat. Why fight over the crumbs, when you can have the whole
bakery?
Ray Cunningham
Lies about refugees
- Refugees get housing and welfare benefits before Irish people.
- Refugees get the same social welfare as Irish people. They
are not housed any faster than anyone else. The housing crisis in
Dublin effects refugees as well. Refugees are actually
discriminated against as they cannot work or study in Ireland
until they have been granted asylum, a process that can take
years.
- Refugees and asylum seekers are all 'spongers'.
- Because refugees and asylum seekers are not allowed to work,
they must claim social welfare or starve. Many refugees are
escaping from war, famine and political persecution, as millions
of Irish people have done before. The right to asylum is a basic
human right.
- Refugees are bringing crime, prostitution and begging to
Ireland.
- Just like Irish people, there is a minority involved in crime.
As always, the government and media need someone to blame, native or
refugee, for problems they cannot solve.
(Taken from an Anti-Racist Campaign leaflet, ARC can be
contacted at 01-4750376)
