009
ALLEGED QUOTE
"Kill the Germans, wherever you find them! Every German is our moral enemy. Have no mercy on women, children, or the aged! Kill every German wipe them out!"
Llya Ehrenburg, Glaser, p. 111
RESPONSE
This quote is #009 from the anti-Semitic document http://abbc.com/quotes/q001-050.htm "1000 Quotes by and about Jews". It is available in similar form from many sources, but not necessarily with the same number.
Whilst Llya Ehrenburg was a historical person, an extensive library search was conducted and no book called "Glaser" or edited by a person of that name could be located. It is therefore very probable that this "quote" is a forgery.
In fact, Ehrenburg's attitude to the war-time treatment of civilians is quite the opposite of what is suggested in the quote. In a letter in the spring of 1945 to Stalin, Ehrenburg made clear the position he had held all along:
I heard from Pravda that they will be re-publishing my article "Enough!" in a mass printing. The Pravda article claims, incomprehensibly, that an anti-Fascist calls for the universal destruction of the German people. I did not call for this. In those years, when the usurpers trampled upon our soil, I wrote that it was necessary to kill the German occupiers. But at the time I emphasized that we are not Fascists and far from reprisals. After returning from East Prussia, I emphasized several articles . . . that we are approaching the civilian population with different measures than the Hitlerlites used. In this, my conscience is clean. (Quoted in Rubenstein 224)Ehrenburg was also the target of anti-Semitic smears by people such as Goebbels (and modern-day anti-Semites) who invoked some true quotations from Ehrenburg in an attempt to discredit him. An example of such a quote is "If you kill one German, kill another - there is nothing more amusing for us than a heap of German corpses" (cited in Ehrenburg, Ilya. "Kill." *Krasnaya Zvezda* (Red Star) (July 18, 1942): 3). This was written at the height of the war and was written for a military audience, not for the benefit of civilians. Whilst it sounds extreme, such a sentiment would not be unexpected in time of total war. He never urged the killing or rape of civilians as proved by the letter cited above.
014
QUOTE
"Judea declares War on Germany." (Daily Express, March 24, 1934)
RESPONSE
This quote is #014 from the anti-Semitic document http://abbc.com/quotes/q001-050.htm "1000 Quotes by and about Jews". It is available in similar form from many sources, but not necessarily with the same number.
This "quote" is widely cited on Holocaust denial/Neo-Nazi web sites. The inference attempted is that the Jews deserved to be murdered by the Nazis (even though simultaneously denying that no such murder occurred...) because the Jews of the world "declared war" on Germany. The origin of this claim is one single headline of the Daily Express, London, March 24, 1934. If one reads the article (below) it soon becomes obvious that what was meant is that a call was sent out among Jews to engage in an economic boycott against Germany. This was to be in retaliation for the persecution of Jews by Germany which was part of Nazi policy since the Nazis were elected in 1933.
Economic boycotts in retaliation for mistreatment of various groups and human rights violations are still widely practiced today both by groups and governments.
This quote is a classic example of a propaganda technique in which the real victimised party is made to look as though they themselves are the oppressors.
David S. Maddison (maddison@connexus.net.au)
Thank you to J.D. for finding the source and some commentary on this quote.
Here is the original article. It can be viewed on the Nizkor Web Site at http://www.nizkor.org/features/qar/qar11.html
Daily Express. London, March 24, 1933, pp. 1-2.
JUDEA DECLARES WAR ON GERMANY
[A composite photo with Hitler before a presumably Jewish court]
JEWS OF ALL THE WORLD UNITE
BOYCOTT OF GERMAN GOODS
MASS DEMONSTRATIONS
"Daily Express" Special Political Correspondent.
A strange and unforeseen sequel has emerged from the stories of German Jew-baiting.
The whole of Israel throughout the world is uniting to declare an economic and financial war on Germany.
Hitherto the cry has gone up: "Germany is persecuting the Jews."
If the present plans are carried out, the Hitlerite cry will be:
"The Jews are persecuting Germany."
All Israel is rising in wrath against the Nazi onslaught on the Jews. Adolf Hitler, swept into power by an appeal of elemental patriotism, is making history of a kind he least expected. Thinking to unite only the German nation to race consciousness, he has roused the whole Jewish people to national renascence.
The appearance of the Swastika symbol of a new Germany has called forth the Lion of Judah, the old battle symbol of Jewish defiance.
Fourteen million Jews, dispersed throughout the world, have banded together as one man to declare war on the German persecutors of their co-religionists. Sectional differences and antagonisms
[strip-shaped drawing with alternating swastikas and lions]
have been submerged in one common aim - to stand by the 600,000 Jews of Germany who are terrorised by Hitlerite anti-Semitism and to compel Fascist Germany to end its campaign of violence and suppression directed against its Jewish minority.
Plans For Action Maturing In Europe And America
World Jewry has made up its mind not to rest quiescent in face of this revival of medieval Jew-baiting.
Germany may be called on to pay a heavy price for Hitler's antagonism to the Jews. She is faced with an international boycott in commerce, finance, and industry.
The Jewish merchant prince is leaving his counting-house, the banker his board-room, the shopkeeper his store, and the pedlar his humble barrow, to join together in what has become a holy war to combat the Hitlerite enemies of the Jew.
Plans for concerted Jewish action are being matured in Europe and America to strike back in reprisal at Hitlerite Germany.
In London, New York, Paris, and Warsaw Jewish merchants are waiting for a commercial crusade.
Resolutions are being taken throughout the Jewish business
BRITISH JEWS PROTEST AT NAZI TACTICS
MERCHANTS AND FINANCIERS RALLY TO MOVEMENT
GERMAN LINERS AFFECTED?
world to sever trade relations with Germany.
Large numbers of merchants in London have resolved to stop buying German goods, even at the cost of suffering heavy loss.
A meeting of the Jewish textile trade in London has been called for Monday to consider the situation and to determine what steps should be taken.
Germany is a heavy borrower in foreign money markets, where Jewish influence is considerable. Continued anti-Semitism in Germany is likely to react seriously against her. A move is on foot on the part of Jewish financiers to exert pressure to force anti-Jewish action to stop.
The Organisation of Jewish Youth in Britain are organizing demonstrations in London and the provinces during the weekend.
The Board of Deputies of British Jews, representing the entire Jewish community of Great Britain, are meeting in special session on Sunday to discuss the German situation, and to decide on what action should be taken to counteract the attacks on their German fellow-Jews.
World-wide preparations are being made to organise demonstrations of protest.
EMBARGO IN POLAND
A concerted boycott by Jewish buyers is likely to involve grave damage to the German export trade. Jewish merchants all over the world are large buyers of German manufactured goods, chiefly cotton goods, silks, toys, electrical fittings, and furniture.
In Poland, the trade embargo on Germany is already in operation. In France, a proposed ban on German imports is being widely canvassed in Jewish circles.
German Transatlantic shipping traffic is likewise threatened. The Bremen and the Europa, the German crack liners, may suffer heavily from a Jewish anti-German boycott. Jewish trans-ocean travellers form an important part of the patrons of these liners because of their extensive part in international trade. The loss of their patronage would be a heavy blow to Germany's Atlantic trade.
In New York yesterday 10,000 Jewish ex-soldiers marched to the City Hall to hold a protest demonstration.
Large crowds watched the men, some of whom wore old British uniforms, petition the mayor to support them in a boycott of German goods.
Another petition was handed in at the British Consulate-General requesting that Palestine should receive refugees from Germany without restriction.
Members of the American House of Representatives are introducing resolutions protesting against the anti-Jewish excesses in Germany. The American trade unions, representing 3,000,000 workers, have also decided to join in the protest.
A rabbinical decree in New York has made the next Monday a day of fasting and prayer over the Hitler campaign.
Fasting will begin on Sunday at sunset and finish at sunset on Monday.
All Jewish shops in New York will be closed on Monday during a parade.
Apart from a monster meeting in Madison-square Garden, meetings are to be held in 300 American cities.
Madison-square Garden will see the remarkable sight of Bishop Manning speaking from a Jewish platform appealing for an end of the Hitler "terror."
DAY OF SERMONS
It had been arranged to charge a shilling admission and 5 s. for box seats, but a public-spirited Jew, Frank Cohen, an insurance broker, gove [sic] a personal cheque for L 1,000 to cover all expenses, so admission will be free.
Every rabbi in the city of New York has been placed under a sacred obligation by rabbinical decree to devote Saturday's sermon to the plight of Jews in Germany.
Representative Jewish organisations in the European capitals are understood to be making representations to their various Governments to use influence with the Hitler Cabinet to induce it to call a halt in the oppression of the German Jews.
The old and reunited people of Israel are rising with new and modern weapons to fight their age-old battle with their persecutors.
Uploaded 17 July 2000