| Start Date | Player | Former Team | Position | BRAR/PRAR | 2009 SJL Salary | Minimum Bid | Compensation | New Team | Annual Salary | Years | Thru | |
| 4-Jan | Roy Halladay | Chicago Cockroaches | SP | 101 | $10M | $7.5M | 2nd Rd Pk/$15 | Florida | $14.1M | 5 | 2013 | |
| Ryan Dempster | Dutchess County Robber Barons | SP | 80 | $7.333M | $5.5M | -- | Ft. Lauderdale | $7.4M | 4 | 2012 | ||
| Jon Rauch | Durham Knights | RP | 34 | $1.2M | $900k | -- | Dutchess County | $3M | 3 | 2011 | ||
| A.J. Pierzynski | Hagerstown Hobgoblins | C | 13 | $5.85M | $5M | -- | Ft. Lauderdale | $5M | 2 | 2010 | ||
| Jim Thome | Savannah Carpetbaggers | 1B | 40 | $15.667M | $11.8M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Jeff Kent | Durham Knights | 2B | 14 | $9M | $6.8M | -- | No bids, retired | |||||
| Aramis Ramirez | Chicago Cockroaches | 3B | 46 | $15M | $11.3M | -- | Hagerstown | $11.3M | 4 | 2012 | ||
| Cesar Izturis | Aldwych Thanes | SS | 2 | $2.85M | $2.2M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Carlos Beltran | Durham Knights | OF | 60 | $18.622M | $14M | -- | Florida | $14M | 1 | 2009 | ||
| 11-Jan | Andy Pettitte | Savannah Carpetbaggers | SP | 62 | $16M | $12M | -- | No bids | ||||
| Vicente Padilla | Chicago Cockroaches | SP | 46 | $11M | $8.3M | -- | St. Louis | $8.3M | 3 | 2011 | ||
| Doug Davis | Dutchess County Robber Barons | SP | 39 | $7.75M | $5.9M | -- | Mudville | $5.9M | 1 | 2009 | ||
| JC Romero | Florida Panthers | RP | 31 | $3.25M | $2.5M | -- | Newark | $2.5M | 3 | 2011 | ||
| Ramon Hernandez | Aldwych Thanes | C | 11 | $7.5M | $5.7M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Frank Thomas | Newark Five Spot | 1B | 11 | $12.56M | $9.5M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Damion Easley | Baltimore Hons | 2B | 6 | $950k | $800k | -- | Savannah | $1M | 1 | 2009 | ||
| Troy Glaus | Mudville Slugs | 3B | 45 | $12.5M | $9.4M | -- | Baltimore | $9.4M | 2 | 2010 | ||
| Alex Gonzalez | Kanab Hotties | SS | 0 | $4.625M | $3.5M | -- | No bids | |||||
| J D Drew | Savannah Carpetbaggers | OF | 40 | $14M | $10.5M | -- | River City | $10.5M | 1 | 2009 | ||
| 18-Jan | Jon Garland | Durham Knights | SP | 33 | $12M | $9M | -- | Baltimore | $9M | 1 | 2009 | |
| Brian Moehler | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | SP | 33 | $400k | $400k | -- | Savannah | $600k | 2 | 2010 | ||
| Jose Contreras | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | SP | 33 | $10M | $7.5M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Jesus Colome | Durham Knights | RP | 15 | $1.25M | $1M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Ivan Rodriguez | Savannah Carpetbaggers | C | 11 | $12.38M | $9.3M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Dmitri Young | Savannah Carpetbaggers | 1B | 9 | $5M | $3.8M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Esteban German | Dutchess County Robber Barons | 2B | 1 | $1M | $800k | -- | Baltimore | $800k | 1 | 2009 | ||
| Carlos Guillen | Durham Knights | 3B | 29 | $12M | $9M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Adam Everett | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | SS | (1) | $2.8M | $2.1M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Gary Matthews, Jr. | Florida Panthers | OF | 6 | $9.4M | $7.1M | -- | No bids | |||||
| 25-Jan | Paul Byrd | Kanab Hotties | SP | 32 | $7.5M | $5.7M | -- | No bids | ||||
| Sidney Ponson | Aldwych Thanes | SP | 18 | $390k | $400k | -- | Ft. Lauderdale | $400k | 1 | 2009 | ||
| Jon Lieber | Savannah Carpetbaggers | SP | 10 | $3.5M | $2.7M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Kent Mercker | Newark Five Spot | RP | 5 | $600k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Scott Elarton | Kansas City Whirlwind | RP | 4 | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Brian Schneider | Florida Panthers | C | 8 | $4.9M | $3.7M | -- | Kansas City | $3.7M | 1 | 2009 | ||
| Tony Clark | Savannah Carpetbaggers | 1B | 3 | $900k | $700K | -- | No bids | |||||
| Tony Graffanino | Savannah Carpetbaggers | 2B | 0 | $3.25M | $2.5M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Mike Lowell | Florida Panthers | 3B | 21 | $12.5M | $9.4M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Jonny Gomes | Savannah Carpetbaggers | OF | 3 | $1.275M | $1M | -- | No bids | |||||
| 1-Feb | Bartolo Colon | Dutchess County Robber Barons | SP | 9 | $390k | $400k | -- | Mudville | $800k | 5 | 2013 | |
| Livan Hernandez | Durham Knights | SP | 9 | $5M | $3.8M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Shawn Chacon | Newark Five Spot | SP | 9 | $2M | $1.5M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Tanyon Sturtze | Aldwych Thanes | RP | 1 | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Armando Benitez | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | RP | 0 | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Mike Myers | Kanab Hotties | RP | 0 | $1.25M | $1M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Greg Zaun | Newark Five Spot | C | 7 | $3.75M | $2.9M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Daryle Ward | St. Louis Sprockets | 1B | 2 | $1.2M | $900k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Pablo Ozuna | Savannah Carpetbaggers | 2B | (2) | $1.05M | $800k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Geoff Blum | Florida Panthers | 3B | 4 | $1.1M | $900k | -- | Dutchess County | $900K | 2 | 2010 | ||
| Eric Young | St. Louis Sprockets | OF | 0 | $390k | $400k | -- | Retired | |||||
| 8-Feb | Claudio Vargas | Savannah Carpetbaggers | SP | 8 | $390k | $400k | -- | Aldwych | $400k | 5 | 2013 | |
| Jason Davis | Baltimore Hons | SP | 3 | $390k | $400k | -- | Savannah | $400k | 3 | 2011 | ||
| Glendon Rusch | Florida Panthers | SP | 0 | $850k | $700k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Mike Stanton | Kanab Hotties | RP | 0 | $2M | $1.5M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Jay Witasick | Kanab Hotties | RP | 0 | $400k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Mike Redmond | Durham Knights | C | 1 | $950k | $800k | -- | Newark | $1M | 1 | 2009 | ||
| Josh Phelps | Aldwych Thanes | 1B | (1) | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Luis Rivas | Savannah Carpetbaggers | 2B | (6) | $525k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Wes Helms | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | 3B | 0 | $2.4M | $1.8M | -- | Ft. Lauderdale | $1.8M | 1 | 2009 | ||
| Jay Payton | St. Louis Sprockets | OF | 0 | $5.0M | $3.8M | -- | No bids | |||||
| 15-Feb | Aaron Sele | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | SP | 0 | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | ||||
| Mark Prior | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | SP | 0 | $1M | $800k | -- | Hagerstown | $800k | 1 | 2009 | ||
| Matt Clement | Kansas City Whirlwind | SP | 0 | $1.25M | $1M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Dan Kolb | St. Louis Sprockets | RP | 0 | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Chris Reitsma | St. Louis Sprockets | RP | (2) | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Eric Munson | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | C | 1 | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Travis Hafner | Durham Knights | 1B | (1) | $8.05M | $6.1M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Eric Byrnes | Hagerstown Hobgoblins | OF | (3) | $6.667M | $5M | -- | No bids | |||||
| 22-Feb | Josh Fogg | Aldwych Thanes | SP | (3) | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | ||||
| Mark Redman | Hagerstown Hobgoblins | SP | (3) | $1M | $800k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Dontrelle Willis | Hagerstown Hobgoblins | SP | (4) | $7M | $5.3M | -- | River City | $5.3M | 2 | 2010 | ||
| Julian Tavarez | Ft Lauderdale Clementes | RP | (4) | $3.85M | $2.9M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Cliff Politte | Florida Panthers | RP | (5) | $390k | $400k | -- | No bids | |||||
| Toby Hall | Kansas City Whirlwind | C | (1) | $1.75M | $1.4M | -- | No bids | |||||
| Brad Ausmus | Kansas City Whirlwind | C | (4) | $2M | $1.5M | -- | No bids |