1992 ACC Rookie of the Year Award
1997 Players Choice Outstanding American League Rookie
1997 ESPY Breakthrough Player of the Year
1997 American League Rookie of the Year
1997 Silver Slugger Award
1997 Rookie Home Run Derby winner
1997-98 Thomas A. Yawkey Award (Red Sox MVP)
1999 American League Batting Crown
2000 American League Batting Crown
1998 Number "5" retired by Trenton Thunder
1997 American League All-Star
1999 American League All-Star
2000 American League All-Star
2002 American League All-Star
2003 American League All-Star
2000 Big League Challenge Participant
2001 Ted Williams Hitters Hall of Fame Inductee
2001 Arizona Fall League Hall of Fame Inductee
Arizona Fall League Team of the Decade, 1990-2000