| Name | Age | Location | Website | Fave BsB | Fave BsB Song |
| Isaac, Chelsea | 15 | Arkansas | N/A | Nick aKa Frack; Brian aKa Frick | 10,000 Promises |
| Parks, Krystal | 16 | Lake Elsinore, CA | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | Set Adrift On Memory Bliss |
| Christine | 17 | Los Angeles, CA | As Long As You Love The Backstreet Boys... | AJ aKa Bone | All I Have To Give |
| Smith, Stephanie Hillari | 11 | New Port, CA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Anywhere For You |
| B, Sabrina | 19 | San Jose, CA | N/A | Where Do We Go | Brian aKa Frick |
| Kate | 14 | San Jose, CA | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | All |
| Nena | 14 | San Jose, CA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All |
| Mary Jae | 19 | California | N/A | Howie aKa Sweet D | Hey Mr. DJ (Keep Playin' This Song) |
| Saturn | 21 | California | N/A | Howie aKa Sweet D | Set A Drift On Memory Bliss |
| Holmes, Amy Frances | 15 | Bristol, CT | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | Get Down (You're The One For Me) |
| Stefanie J | 14 | Southbury, CT | Get Down With The Backstreet Boys | AJ aKa Bone | All |
| Sarah | 17 | Delaware | Da Spam Crew's Page | Howie aKa Sweet D | Every Time I Close My Eyes |
| Ryan, Beverley | 20 | Kissimmee, FL | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | Like A Child |
| Cristina | 17 | Miami, FL | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All I Have To Give |
| I, Jessica Marie | 13 | Miami, FL | N/A | Howie aKa Sweet D | I Wanna Be With You; Just To Be Close To You |
| Lena | 18 | St. Pete, FL | N/A | All | Show Me The Meaning |
| Jessica | 18 | Savannah, GA | N/A | Howie aKa Sweet D | All I Have To Give |
| Ruthann | 17 | Georgia | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Everybody (Backstreet's Back) |
| Lin, Karen | 14 | Hawaii | N/A | Nick aKa Frack; Brian aKa Frick | That's What She Said |
| McDaniel, Justinn | 12 | Charleston, IL | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Long, Rana | 14 | North Vernon, IN | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Quit Playin' Games (With My Heart) |
| Schueler, Ae Rin | 14 | Indiana | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Set Adrift On Memory Bliss |
| Facteau, Jenifer | 14 | Spring Hill, KS | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | As Long As You Love Me |
| Amanda | 14 | Louisville, KY | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | That's What She Said |
| Rachel | 12 | Kentucky | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All |
| Almeida, Linda | 16 | Fall River, MA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack; Brian aKa Frick; AJ aKa Bone | All |
| Jaime | 15 | Maryland | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | As Long As You Love Me |
| Nikki | 17 | Maryland | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All |
| Poulter, Lauren Ann | 14 | Eden Prairie, MN | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | That's What She Said |
| Giebner, Josh Ray | 15 | Tracy, MN | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | All |
| Carter, Caitlyn, K | 21 | Minnesota | Cat's Page | AJ aKa Bone | Heaven In Your Eyes |
| Vago, Christina | 15 | Allen Park, MI | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Whitaker, Kaytlin Anne | 13 | Ludington, MI | Kaytlin's BSB Zone | Brian aKa Frick | Heaven In Your Eyes |
| Meldi, Kristen | 17 | Missouri | N/A | All | Set Adrift On Memory Bliss; Heaven In Your Eyes; By My Side |
| W, Elizabeth | 17 | Livingston, MT | N/A | Howie aKa Sweet D | All |
| Becky | 14 | Montana | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Anywhere For You |
| Garcia, Irma Norma | 18 | Mexico, MX | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | I'll Never Break Your Heart; Hey Mr. DJ (Keep Playin' This Song) |
| Rachel | 13 | Kernersville, NC | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All |
| Khatib, Dara | 17 | New Milford, NJ | N/A | All | All |
| Neri, Michelle K | 15 | Randolph, NJ | N/A | All | All I Have To Give |
| Khatib, Dara | 16 | New Jersey | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Let's Have A Party |
| Wormann, Kristy | 16 | New Jersey | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | All |
| Laci | 14 | Deming, NM | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Quit Playin' Games (With My Heart); As Long As You Love Me; Everybody (Backstreet's Back) |
| Laigue, Julie Ann Raras | 12 | Bronx, NY | BSB Paradise | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me; Anywhere For You; Quit Playin' Games (With My Heart) |
| Nicole | 14 | Queens, NY | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | All |
| Christina | 15 | New York | Christina's Nick Carter Page | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Erin | 16 | New York | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | All I Have To Give; If You Want It To Be Good Girl (Get Yourself A Bad Boy) |
| Kira | 17 | New York | Set Adrift On Memory Bliss With Nobody But BSB | Nick aKa Frack | That's The Way I Like It; As Long As You Love Me |
| Perez, Stephanie | 19 | New York | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Quit Playin' Games (With My Heart) |
| Wohlrab, Karen | 19 | New York | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | That's The Way I Like It; All I Have To Give; Like A Child |
| Jessica | 16 | North Carolina | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Just To Be Close To You |
| Stephanie | 18 | Ohio | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Get Down (You're The One For Me) |
| Zapata, Kym | 26 | Tulsa, OK | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | Everybody (Backstreet's Back) |
| McGee, Macy | 17 | Oklahoma | N/A | Nick aKa Frack; Brian aKa Frick; AJ aKa Bone | Hey Mr. DJ (Keep Playin' This Song) |
| Shihab, Mimi | 13 | Drexel Hill, PA | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | That's What She Said |
| Britney | 18 | Pittsburgh, PA | 5 Fly Guys - The Backstreet Boys | Kevin aKa Train | Everybody (Backstreet's Back) |
| Lindsey | 14 | Swoyersville, PA | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | All I Have To Give |
| Carl, Kristy | 20 | York, PA | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | Lay Down Beside Me |
| Katrina | 12 | Pennsylvania | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Kristy | 14 | Rhode Island | N/A | All | All |
| Dawson, Rebekah Catharine | 15 | Laurel Bay, SC | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | All |
| Dawn Elizabeth | 14 | Parker, SD | N/A | All | 10 000 Promises |
| Taylor, Emily M | 17 | Bartlett, TN | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Heaven In Your Eyes |
| Sanchez, Ninfa M | 17 | Laredo, TX | N/A | AJ aKa Bone; Howie aKa Sweet D | Just To Be Close To You; I'll Never Break Your Heart |
| Galvan, Magan | 15 | Hampton, VA | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | I'll Never Break Your Heart |
| Anna | 16 | Richmond, VA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Anywhere For You; Heaven In Your Eyes |
| Leach, Tiffany A | 15 | Torrington, WY | N/A | All | All I Have To Give |
| Allen, Lashe | 14 | USA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Carl, Leslie | 22 | USA | N/A | All | Set A Drift On Memory Bliss |
| Jamie | 15 | USA | N/A | Brian aKa Frick | That's What She Said |
| Paige | 15 | USA | N/A | AJ aKa Bone | Get Down (You're The One For Me) |
| Raymond, Kathy | 20 | USA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Shannon | 14 | USA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | As Long As You Love Me |
| Wolters, Mandy | 15 | USA | N/A | Nick aKa Frack | Everybody (Backstreet's Back); As Long As You Love Me |