Two Churches: Romanesque VS Gothic
Throughout history there have been many great pieces of art,
some small, some large, some so old that they can hardly be restored.
Although this is all true, no pieces of art can compare to the
monumental work of the Romanesque and Gothic churches. They are beyond
gorgeous, with their many twists and turns, thick walls or flying
buttresses, they hold much power and serenity.
Many of these churches emerged in France. Two in particular, are
Sainte-Foy at Conques and Saint Denis near Paris. Something that sets
these churches apart right away, is the fact that Foy is a Romanesque
church and Denis is a Gothic church. Sainte-Foy’s floor plan was made in
the shape of a cross, whereas Sainte Denis has no intended symbolic
shape.
Sainte-Foy was constructed from 1050 to 1120. It was dedicated to
Sainte Foy, who was a virgin martyr of the third century, was martyred
as a child because she denied the pagan faith and refused to worship the
pagan gods. Relics of saints were placed in the church for honor and to
preserve them, they were "holy" relics. The church was built above her
grave and still stands today in Conques.
In accordance with romanesque archetecture, the actual construction
of the church was one of thick walls and small windows with a beautiful
bell tower towering overhead. The walls were made thick to support the
weight and the windows small to keep the walls strong. What are known
as transverse ribs cross the underside of the cross the underside of the
quadrant and are supported by many clustered piers. The piers put a nice
touch to the corners of the groin-vaulted walls otherwise known as bays.
Many murals surround the church so that the illiterate part of the
population could “read” the events and Bible stories portrayed in text.
The giant relief sculpture of The Last Judgment covers the west
portal of Sainte-Foy. It is where Jesus Christ is at the center of all
things and the wicked are condemned and those of faith are released to
live forever in paradise.
In 1084 Abbot Sugar was born in France. He was educated at Saint
Denis monastery and would become the first bishop of France to King
Louis VII. He would be the architect for Saint-Denis.
The difference would be tremendous from Sainte-Foy to Saint Denis.
There would be ribbed vaults to spread the pressure of the weight out
evenly across the top of the roof and flying buttresses to create a pull
on the walls so that the walls could be thinner as well as containing
grander windows. Windows held many pieces of colored glass, creating
figures, telling stories. The stained glass windows of Saint-Denis
reached as high thirty feet. Letting much light pass through the church
making it feel as if it was God’s place of refuge. Pointed arches could
be raised to any height regardless of the distance between supports much
unlike the rounded arches of the Romanesque church of Sainte-Foy.
All in all, with their differences and similarities, these churches
are outstanding in size and excellence. They astound us today just as
much as the did before and will never lose their grace.
|