The Cross

 

Ambon Berdarah On-Line
News & Pictures About Ambon/Maluku Tragedy

 

 


 

 

 

The Jakarta Post


The Jakarta Post, July 05, 2007

On national taboos

Opinion and Editorial

Asher Tauran's letter on national taboos (The Jakarta Post, July 3) raises various concerns. For example, he noted that "The reactions of certain public figures regarding the "Ambon incident" are proof of an embarrassing lack of factual knowledge regarding their nation's history." What kind of history he refers to is unclear.

He also keeps putting the act of separatism in quotes, as if those things were imaginary and unnecessary to note. The fact still remains that the RMS or the Republic of South Maluku waged an act of secession and bloody war against a "baby nation" in the early 1950s. An act that could have crippled the republic at an early age.

Such fact could not be ignored in passing the judgment of "hypersensitivism." Indeed, a healthy debate could be necessary, but yet we all need to remember that all nations have their sensitive issues. We need to remember that the people involved in the act, whether they are merely "actors" or "directors," are not the victims. They are the perpetrators.

Being cynical is not helping the call for "dialog," as dialogs do not commence with cynicism. Dialogs should begin with the ability to understand that each culture has its own taboos. While those taboos might need to be fought against, some work needs to be done gradually.

G. ADI KUSUMA

Blacksburg, VA

The Jakarta Post, July 03, 2007

On national taboos

Opinion and Editorial

A little more than a week ago, the Netherlands' under 21 soccer team won the European finals on home soil and a whole nation could be seen celebrating the victory as a gesture of national pride. Soon after, several Dutch players of Surinam origin created quite a stir when they decided to wave and wrap themselves up in flags of the republic of Surinam during the cup ceremony.

The host country's politicians expressed dismay and disapproval about the incident.

"They are playing for the Kingdom of the Netherlands, so Dutch flags would have been appropriate. If they wanted to represent Surinam they should have become Surinam citizens".

Luckily they had, and still have, that choice to make. They were lucky they were not charged with treason. Of course such a charge would have been quite outrages and separatism was not the issue, just ancestral pride at best.

By contrast, our "home grown separatists" were caught dancing with six machetes, four spears and a musical instrument, all of which are part of the outfits used in local traditional war dances. They were also allegedly carrying some 19 "separatist flags, including incriminating documents". This may be enough for prosecutors to do their patriotic best and pin treason on these "war dancers".

The "Ambon incident" again shows how hypersensitive this country is in regard to "acts of separatism". Like an explosion, the incident put our politicians and law enforcers to the test and public outcries could be likened to those of a nation under siege. Maybe the authorities believe bombs "merely" kill fellow citizens, while "separatist symbols" kill a nation over time.

Communism, separatism and religious totalitarianism are all massive taboos in this part of the world. Unexplained, and therefore undisputed, taboos can last generations thriving on ignorance, misinformation and/or unashamed lies.

The reactions of certain public figures regarding the "Ambon incident" are proof of an embarrassing lack of factual knowledge regarding their nation's history.

When it comes to issues of communism or separatism, dialog is categorically denied or avoided by officials. Why? Maybe we should dig into the nation's psyche to look for a plausible explanation for this response. My guess, however, is that it is caused by fear. Fear of loosing the debate, one's land, one's national dignity, one's pride, one's livelihood or one's life.

ASHER TAURAN

Jakarta

All contents copyright © of The Jakarta Post.
 


Copyright © 1999-2002 - Ambon Berdarah On-Line * http://www.go.to/ambon
HTML page is designed by
Alifuru67 * http://www.oocities.org/aboroe
Send your comments to alifuru67@yahoogroups.com
This web site is maintained by the Real Ambonese - 1364283024 & 1367286044