As this list shows, Catholics were the first to establish settlements in over twice as many states as Protestants (33 to 15; Alaska and West Virginia not included). We list the first settlement of each group. The Asterisk * stands for a continuation of the group above it.
Rhode Island St.Clair expedition/Newport 1398 Catholic
1636 Protestant
(Taken from the soon-to-be published Journey America: Pathways to the Present, Marian Publications, Inc.)
1) this would not reveal who was actually first in establishing a settlement,
2) this would violate justice, since in such states as Maine, Virginia, North and South Carolina, Georgia, and a few others, the first settlements were by Catholics, but were violently attacked and destroyed by enemies of the true Faith.
STATE
SETTLEMENT
YEAR/Group
.
South Carolina San Miguel de Guadalupe 1526 * 1670 *
Florida Apalachee Mission 1539 * 1564 *
Alabama Santa Cruz (Nanipacna) 1559 * 1763 *
North Carolina Mission of Guatari 1566 * 1585 *
Georgia Mission of Guale 1568 * 1733 *
Virginia Mission Axacan 1570 * 1607 *
New Mexico San Juan 1590 * 1846 *
Maine Sainte Croix 1604 * 1626 *
Arizona San Bernadino 1619 * 1846 *
Massachusetts Plymouth 1620 Protestant 1750 Catholic
New Hampshire Rye (Portsmouth) 1623 * 1820 *
New York Fort Orange (Albany) 1623 * 1655 *
New Jersey New Nassau 1625 * 1672 *
Delaware Settlement near Lewes 1631 * 1750 *
Maryland Kent Island 1631 * 1634 *
Pennsylvania Post on Delaware R. 1633 * 1710 *
Connecticut Hartford (Dutch post) 1633 * 1755 *
Michigan Saulte Ste. Marie 1660 Catholic 1763 Protestant
Wisconsin Holy Ghost Mission 1665 * 1783 *
Vermont St. Anne(Isle La Motte) 1666 * 1690 *
Texas Sacramento Mission 1675 * 1821 *
Illinois Fort Crevecoeur(Creve Coeur) 1679 * 1763 *
Tennessee Fort Prudhomme(Memphis) 1682 * 1735?/1769 *
Indiana Mission @ South Bend 1686 * 1763 *
Minnesota Fort Frontenac 1686 * 1783 *
Louisiana Natchez Mission 1698 * 1803 *
Arkansas Little Rock 1699 * 1804 *
Mississippi Biloxi 1699 * 1763 *
Missouri Trading Post (St. Louis) 1699 * 1783 *
Nebraska Posts on South Platte 1718 * 1820 *
Ohio Sandusky Mission 1751 * 1788 *
California San Diego Mission 1769 * 1812 *
Nevada Beatty Mission 1772-3 * 1849 *
Kentucky Harrodsburg 1774 Protestant 1775 Catholic
Iowa Dubuque 1788 Catholic 1830 Protestant
South Dakota Pawnee House 1794 * 1807 *
Oklahoma Chouteau Post 1796 * 1918 *
Montana trading post(Fort Union) 1796 * 1809 *
North Dakota Pembina (trading post) 1797 * 1851 *
Idaho Pend d’Oreille Post 1809 * 1810 *
Washington Spokane Settlement 1810 Protestant 1839 Catholic
Oregon Astoria 1811 * 1839 *
Hawaii Missions 1820 * 1824 *
Kansas Fort Leavenworth 1827 * 1836 *
Wyoming Fort Laramie 1834 * -
Utah Goodyear Settlement(Ogdon) 1841 * -
Colorado San Luis (or San Pedro) 1851 Catholic 1859 Protestant
Sources:
-The Catholic Pioneers of America, John O'Kane Murray (Philadelphia, PA: H. L. Kilner Co., 1882)
-Documents of American Catholic History, John Tracy Ellis (Milwaukee, WI: Bruce Publishing Co., 1956)
-Our Catholic Heritage, By a Benedictine Monk (New York, NY: Benziger Brothers, Inc., 1950)
-Spanish Roots of America, Bishop David Arias (Huntington, IN: Our Sunday Visitor, 1992)
Return to US Catholic History main page