Contact

International Treaties

Rights of the Child

ICCPR

Pictures

Groups

Links

Media

Stories

Executions

Home

Florida ought not tolerate executing minors

Last year, Florida legislators passed and Gov. Jeb Bush signed into law a bill prohibiting the execution of people who are mentally retarded. It was a humanitarian gesture suggesting that those whose intellectual capacities were severely diminished should not face the ultimate penalty for crimes they committed but whose implications they could not have fully understood.

Now lawmakers are considering a bill that would prohibit the execution of anyone under 18. A similar measure was debated last year.

Supporters say the bill is intended to clarify a proposed referendum asking voters to include capital punishment in the state constitution. "It was never our intent to execute minors in Florida and this puts that in statute," said state Sen. Victor Crist, R-Tampa.

The proposal is especially appropriate since Florida's death penalty statute already faces possible revamping because of judicial scrutiny. The U.S. Supreme Court is reviewing Arizona's capital punishment law, which grants judges the power to impose death sentences. Florida law grants judges similar authority. As a result of the Arizona case, 2 pending Florida executions have been delayed, one by the Supreme Court itself, the other by Mr. Bush.

This is all the more reason for a statewide moratorium on executions until a thorough, independent review of the system is undertaken. However, an explicit ban on the execution of minors is relevant regardless and should be imposed.

(source: Editorial, Tallahassee Democrat)

Feb. 7, 2002


Contact | ICCPR | International Treaties | Pictures | Resources | Rights of the Child | Home