Nasir al
Din al Tusi
Iranian Experimental
Physicist
By: J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Born:
18 Feb 1201 in Tus,
Khorasan (now Iran) Died:
26 June 1274 in
Kadhimain (near Baghdad now in Iraq)
Although usually
known as Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, his proper name was
Muhammad ibn Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Tusi. In fact al-Tusi
was known by a number of different names during his lifetime
such as Muhaqqiq-i Tusi, Khwaja-yi Tusi and Khwaja Nasir.
Al-Tusi
was born in Tus, which lies close to Meshed in northeastern
Iran high up in the valley of the Kashaf River. He was born at
the beginning of a century which would see conquests across
the whole of the Islamic world from close to China in the east
to Europe in the west. It was the era when the vast military
power of the Mongols would sweep across the vast areas of the
Islamic world displaying a bitter animosity towards Islam and
cruelly massacring people. This was a period in which there
would be little peace and tranquillity for great scholars to
pursue their works, and al-Tusi was inevitably drawn into the
conflict engulfing his country.
In Tus,
al-Tusi's father was a jurist in the Twelfth Imam School. The
Twelfth Imam was the main sect of Shi'ite Muslims and the
school where al-Tusi was educated was mainly a religious
establishment. However, while studying in Tus, al-Tusi was
taught other topics by his uncle which would have an important
influence on his intellectual development. These topics
included logic, physics and metaphysics while he also
studied with other teachers learning mathematics, in
particular algebra and geometry.
In
1214, when al-Tusi was 13 years old, Genghis Khan, who was the
leader of the Mongols, turned away from his conquests in China
and began his rapid advance towards the west. It would not be
too long before al-Tusi would see the effects of these
conquests on his own regions, but before that happened he was
able to study more advanced topics. From Tus, al-Tusi went to
Nishapur which is 75 km west of Tus. Nishapur was a good
choice for al-Tusi to complete his education since it was an
important centre of learning. There al-Tusi studied
philosophy, medicine and mathematics. In particular he was
taught mathematics by Kamal al-Din ibn Yunus, who himself had
been a pupil of Sharaf al-Din al-Tusi. While in Nishapur al-Tusi began to acquire a
reputation as an outstanding scholar and became well known
throughout the area.
The
Mongol invasion reached the area of Tus around 1220 and there
was much destruction. Genghis Khan turned his attention again
towards the east leaving his generals and sons in the west to
continue his conquests. There was, amid the frequent fighting
in the region, peaceful havens which attracted al-Tusi. The
Assassins, who practised an intellectual form of extremist
Shi'ism, controlled the castle of Alamut in the Elburz
Mountains, and other similar impregnable forts in the
mountains. When invited by the Isma'ili ruler Nasir ad-Din
'Abd ar-Rahim to join the service of the Assassins, al-Tusi
accepted and became a highly regarded member of the Isma'ili
Court. Whether he would have been able to leave, had he wished
to, is not entirely clear. However, al-Tusi did some of his
best work while moving round the different strongholds, and
during this period he wrote important works on logic,
philosophy, mathematics and astronomy. The first of these
works, Akhlaq-i nasiri, was written in 1232. It was a
work on ethics which al-Tusi dedicated
to the Isma'ili ruler Nasir ad-Din 'Abd ar-Rahim.
In 1256
al-Tusi was in the castle of Alamut when it was attacked by
the forces of the Mongol leader Hulegu, a grandson of Genghis
Khan, who was at that time set on extending Mongol power in
Islamic areas. Some claim that al-Tusi betrayed the defences
of Alamut to the invading Mongols. Certainly Hulegu's forces
destroyed Alamut and, Hulegu himself being himself interested
in science, he treated al-Tusi with great respect. It may be
that indeed al-Tusi felt that he was being held in Alamut
against his will, for certainly he seemed enthusiastic in
joining the victorious Mongols who appointed him as their
scientific advisor. He was also put in charge of religious
affairs and was with the Mongol forces under Hulegu when they
attacked Baghdad in 1258.
Al-Musta'sim, the last Abbasid caliph in Baghdad, was a
weak leader and he proved no match for Hulegu's Mongol forces
when they attacked Baghdad. After having laid siege to the
city, the Mongols entered it in February 1258 and al-Musta'sim
together with 300 of his officials were murdered. Hulegu had
little sympathy with a city after his armies had won a battle,
so he burned and plundered the city and killed many of its
inhabitants. Certainly al-Tusi had made the right move as far
as his own safety was concerned, and he would also profit
scientifically by his change of allegiance.
Hulegu
was very pleased with his conquest of Baghdad and also pleased
that such an eminent scholar as al-Tusi had joined him. So,
when al-Tusi presented Hulegu with plans for the construction
of a fine Observatory, Hulegu was happy to agree. Hulegu had
made Maragheh his capital . Maragheh was in the Azerbaijan
region of northwestern Iran, and it was at Maragheh that the
Observatory was to be built. Construction of the Observatory
began in 1259 west of Maragheh, and traces of it can still be
seen there today.
The
observatory at Maragheh became operational in 1262.
Interestingly the Persians were assisted by Chinese
astronomers in the construction and operation of the
observatory. It had various instruments such as a 4 metre wall
quadrant made from copper and an azimuth quadrant which was the
invention of Al-Tusi himself. Al-Tusi also designed other
instruments for the Observatory which was far more than a
centre for astronomy. It possessed a fine library with books
on a wide range of scientific topics, while work on science,
mathematics and philosophy were vigorously pursued there.
Al-Tusi
put his Observatory to good use, making very accurate tables
of planetary movements. He published Zij-i ilkhani (the
Ilkhanic Tables), written first in Persian and later
translated into Arabic, after making observations for 12
years. This work contains tables for computing the positions
of the planets, and it also contains a star catalogue. This
was not the only important work which al-Tusi produced in
astronomy. It is fair to say that al-Tusi made the most
significant development of Ptolemy's model
of the planetary system up to the development of the heliocentric model in the time
of Copernicus. In
al-Tusi's major astronomical treatise, al-Tadhkira fi'ilm
al-hay'a (Memoir on astronomy) he [17]:-
... devised a new model of
lunar motion, essentially different from Ptolemy's.
Abolishing the eccentric and the centre of prosneusis, he
founded it exclusively on the principle of eight uniformly
rotating spheres and thereby succeeded in representing the
irregularities of lunar motion with the same exactness as
the "Almagest". His claim that the maximum difference in
longitude between the two theories amounts to 10
proves perfectly true. In his model Nasir, for the first
time in the history of astronomy, employed a theorem
invented by himself which, 250 years later, occurred
again in Copernicus,
"De Revolutionibus", III 4.
The
theorem referred to in this quotation concerns the famous
"Tusi-couple" which resolves linear motion into the sum of two
circular motions. The aim of al-Tusi with this result was to
remove all parts of Ptolemy's system
that were not based on the principle of uniform circular
motion. Many historians claim that the Tusi-couple result was
used by Copernicus after
he discovered it in Al-Tusi's work, but not all agree; see for
example [38] where it is claimed that Copernicus took
the result from Proclus's
Commentary on the first book of Euclid and not
from al-Tusi.
Among
numerous other contributions to astronomy, al-Tusi calculated
the value of 51' for the precession
of the equinoxes. He also wrote works
on astronomical instruments, for example on constructing and
using an astrolabe.
In
logic al-Tusi followed the teachings of ibn Sina (Avicenna). He
wrote five works on the subject, the most important of which
is one on inference. In [33] Street describes this as
follows:-
Tusi, a thirteenth century
logician writing in Arabic, uses two logical connectives to
build up molecular propositions: 'if-then', and 'either-or'.
By referring to a dichotomous tree, Tusi shows how to choose
the proper disjunction relative to the terms in the
disjuncts. He also discusses the disjunctive propositions
which follow from a conditional proposition.
Al-Tusi
wrote many commentaries on Greek texts. These included revised
Arabic versions of works by Autolycus,
Aristarchus,
Euclid, Apollonius,
Archimedes,
Hypsicles,
Theodosius,
Menelaus and
Ptolemy. In
particular he wrote a commentary on Menelaus's
Spherics (see [41] for details), and Archimedes' On
the sphere and cylinder (see [21] for details). In the
latter work al-Tusi discussed objections raised by earlier
mathematicians to comparing lengths of straight lines and of
curved lines. Al-Tusi argues that comparisons are legitimate,
despite the objections that, being different entities, they
are incomparable.
Ptolemy's
Almagest was one of the works which Arabic scientists
studied intently. In 1247 al-Tusi wrote Tahrir
al-Majisti (Commentary on the Almagest) in which he
introduced various trigonometrical techniques to calculate
tables of sines; see [5] for details. As in the Zij-i
Ilkhahi al-Tusi gave tables of sines with entries
calculated to three sexagesimal places for each
half degree of the argument.
One of
al-Tusi's most important mathematical contributions was the
creation of trigonometry as a mathematical discipline in its
own right rather than as just a tool for astronomical
applications. In Treatise on the quadrilateral al-Tusi
gave the first extant exposition of the whole system of plane
and spherical trigonometry. As stated in [1]:-
This work is really the
first in history on trigonometry as an independent branch of
pure mathematics and the first in which all six cases for a
right-angled spherical triangle are set forth.
This
work also contains the famous sine formula for plane
triangles:
a/sin A =
b/sin B = c/sin C.
Another
mathematical contribution was al-Tusi's manuscript, dated
1265, concerning the calculation of n-th roots of an integer;
see [6] for details of a copy of this manuscript made in 1413.
This work by al-Tusi is almost certainly not original but
rather it is his version of methods developed by al-Karaji's
school. In the manuscript al-Tusi determined the coefficients
of the expansion
of a binomial to any power giving the
binomial formula and the Pascal
triangle relations between binomial
coefficients.
We
should mention briefly other fields in which al-Tusi
contributed. He wrote a famous work on minerals which contains
an interesting theory of colour based on mixtures of black and
white, and included chapters on jewels and perfumes. He also
wrote on medicine, but his medical works are among his least
important. Much more important were al-Tusi's contributions to
philosophy and ethics. In particular in philosophy he asked
important questions on the nature of space.
Al-Tusi
had a number of pupils, one of the better known being Nizam
al-a'Raj who also wrote a commentary on the Almagest.
Another of his pupils Qutb ad-Din ash-Shirazi gave the first
satisfactory mathematical explanation of the rainbow.
al-Tusi's influence, which continued through these pupils, is
summed up in [1] as follows:-
Al-Tusi's influence,
especially in eastern Islam, was immense. Probably, if we
take all fields into account, he was more responsible for
the revival of the Islamic sciences than any other
individual. His bringing together so many competent scholars
and scientists at Maragheh resulted not only in the revival
of mathematics and astronomy but also in the renewal of
Islamic philosophy and even theology.
Article by:
J J O'Connor and E F
Robertson
|