| 1906* | A. R. Vangeeson | 1956 | Rayburn Loughridge |
| 1907* | A. S. Abbott | 1957* | John E. Fuller |
| 1908* | S. H. Coffman | 1958 | Kenneth Melton |
| 1909* | W. F. Houk | 1959* | Jack Mathis |
| 1910* | Perry D. Hawkins | 1960* | Winfred Juenger |
| 1911* | R. E. Breuer | 1961 | Leroy Hoss |
| 1912* | A. M. Gorman | 1962* | Elmer Giddens |
| 1913* | Ashel W. Cottle | 1963 | Tom Aaron |
| 1914* | John H. Freeman | 1964* | Paul Coffman |
| 1915* | Walter E. Duncan | 1965 | Wayne Heavin |
| 1916* | W. T. Wilkins | 1966 | Lee Zink |
| 1917* | W. E. Mathews | 1967 | Roy Davidson |
| 1918* | Walter B. Rice | 1968 | Leonard Myers |
| 1919* | Niles G. Gottschell | 1969 | Ben Hyder |
| 1920* | L. L. Jordan | 1970* | Baxter Pendergrast |
| 1921* | E. H. Towell | 1971 | L. L. Sherrell, Jr |
| 1922* | A. B. Cottle | 1972* | Homer Guffey, Jr |
| 1923* | Homer J. Houston | 1973 | Paul Borders |
| 1924* | S. A. Montgomery | 1974* | Robert Naugle, Sr |
| 1925* | Delbert Johnson | 1975 | Gary Heavin |
| 1926* | Charles E. Jones | 1976 | Larry Yates |
| 1927* | Emil Kramme | 1977 | Dewey Riden |
| 1928* | Ivan E. Fuller | 1978 | Ronald Yates |
| 1929* | Walter C. Kerr | 1979 | James Jocsing |
| 1930* | Harold M. Stoll | 1980 | Herman Murray |
| 1931* | W. T. Houk | 1981 | Ralph Alkire |
| 1932* | George C. Hughes | 1982 | Edward Schollian |
| 1933* | Homer J. Houston | 1983 | T. R. Havens |
| 1934* | Oran C. Fordyce | 1984 | Wayne Daniels |
| 1935* | Harold C. Lynch | 1985 | Thomas Ruggles |
| 1936* | Albert C. Williams | 1986 | Jimmy R. Hoss |
| 1937* | Frank R. Short | 1987* | Daniel Malone |
| 1938* | Lee Johnson | 1988 | William C. Woolsey |
| 1939* | L. H. Riddle | 1989 | Larry Forster |
| 1940* | J. R. Jordan | 1990* | Jim Lewis |
| 1941* | Ernest Roemer | 1991 | Bill Earney |
| 1942* | Woodrow Brown | 1992 | Billy D. Birdsong |
| 1943* | Don Brown | 1993 | Dennis Neese |
| 1944* | Dean Brown | 1994* | Homer Guffey, Jr. |
| 1945* | John B. Vrooman | 1995 | George H. Smith |
| 1946* | Delbert Johnson | 1996 | Dale E. Campbell |
| 1947* | Earl H. Carter | 1997 | Luther H. Fryer |
| 1948 | Phillip A. Delashmit, Sr. | 1998 | Chris G. Smith |
| 1949* | Harry Cochran | 1999 | Ray D. Wann |
| 1950* | J. W. Finley | 2000 | Adam J. Birdsong |
| 1951* | W. Troy Root | 2001 | George E. Ornsbey |
| 1952* | Clair Roach | 2002 | Shelby C. Chism |
| 1953* | Harry E. Fuller | 2003 | . |
| 1954* | Louie Deshurley | 2004 | . |
| 1955* | Marion Sisk | 2005 | . |