Police tribunal hearing hinges on credibility

by Gay Abbate
Staff Reporter
The Globe and Mail

Toronto -- A police officer charged with neglect of duty confronted his accuser yesterday at a Police Act trial in which credibility was the key issue.

Constable Mark Denton, an 18-year veteran, and Selwyn Pieters, who has alleged that the officer harassed him because of his skin colour, each attacked the other's credibility.

Superintendent Ed Hoey, who adjudicated the internal police-tribunal hearing, will have to decide which man he found more believable.

Constable Denton is charged under the Police Services Act with insubordination and neglect of duty. On trial with him is Constable Michael Abbott, who is also charged with insubordination. If convicted, the penalities range from a reprimand to loss of rank to dismissal.

The charges were laid after Mr. Pieters, 32, a former jail guard, filed a complaint following a confrontation in his apartment building in March, 1998. Mr. Pieters alleged that the two police officers refused to identify themselves and that Constable Denton made an obscene gesture with his finger. Mr. Pieters was not arrested.

Constable Denton also faces a criminal charge of possession of hashish for the purposes of trafficking. That charge was laid in November, after the Ontario Provincial Police stopped his vehicle in York Region. He was off duty at the the time. He was suspended with pay pending the outcome of the charges.

Courtesy of the Globe and Mail
July 29, 2000

Toronto Police Issues Homepage | Sign Guestbook ||