| 1960 | AL | Ron Hansen, BAL | SS | .255 BA | 22 HR | 86 RBI |
| NL | Frank Howard, LA | OF | .268 BA | 23 HR | 77 RBI | |
| 1961 | AL | Don Schwall, BOS | P | 15-7 | 3.22 ERA | 0 SV |
| NL | Billy Williams, CHI | OF | .278 BA | 25 HR | 86 RBI | |
| 1962 | AL | Tom Tresh, NY | SS | .286 BA | 20 HR | 93 RBI |
| NL | Ken Hubbs, CHI | 2B | .260 BA | 5 HR | 49 RBI | |
| 1963 | AL | Gary Peters, CHI | P | 19-8 | 2.33 ERA | 0 SV |
| NL | Pete Rose, CIN | 2B | .273 BA | 6 HR | 41 RBI | |
| 1964 | AL | Tony Oliva, MIN | OF | .323 BA | 32 HR | 94 RBI |
| NL | Dick Allen, PHI | 3B | .318 BA | 29 HR | 91 RBI | |
| 1965 | AL | Curt Blefary, BAL | OF | .260 BA | 22 HR | 70 RBI |
| NL | Jim Lefebvre, LA | 2B | .250 BA | 12 HR | 69 RBI | |
| 1966 | AL | Tommie Agee, CHI | OF | .273 BA | 22 HR | 86 RBI |
| NL | Tommy Helms, CIN | 2B | .284 BA | 9 HR | 49 RBI | |
| 1967 | AL | Rod Carew, MIN | 2B | .292 BA | 8 HR | 51 RBI |
| NL | Tom Seaver, NY | P | 16-13 | 2.76 ERA | 0 SV | |
| 1968 | AL | Stan Bahnsen, NY | P | 17-12 | 2.05 ERA | 0 SV |
| NL | Johnny Bench, CIN | C | .275 BA | 15 HR | 82 RBI | |
| 1969 | AL | Lou Pinella, KC | OF | .282 BA | 11 HR | 68 RBI |
| NL | Ted Sizemore, LA | 2B | .271 BA | 4 HR | 46 RBI |
[1949-1959] [1970's] [1980's] [1990's]